This topic contains 28 replies, has 11 voices, and was last updated by Avatar bluedevils12 10 years, 4 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #6306
    Avatar
    valentine
    Keymaster

    pg sg sf pf c
    1 magic johnson, michael jordan, lebron james, tim duncan, shaq

    2 jerry west, kobe bryant, larry bird, karl malone, kareem abdul-jabbar

    3 isaiah thomas, dwayne wade, dr.j / elgin baylor, charles barkley, wilt chamberlain

    4 chris paul/b.davis, allen iverson, scottie pippen, kevin garnett, hakeem olajuwon

    5 d.williams/billups, clyde drexler, george gervin, dirk nowitzki, david robinson

    6 jason kidd, oscar robertson, carmelo/pierce, dennis rodman, bill russell

    7 tony parker, tracy mcgrady, grant hill, chris webber, dwight howard/yao ming

    8 steve nash, pistol pete, rick barry, al jefferson/bob petit, willis reed

    9 gary payton, penny hardaway, kevin durant, amare stoudemire, patrick ewing

    10 john stockton, reggie miller, chris mullin, carlos boozer, alonzo mourning

    11 kevin johnson, vince carter, domonique wilkins, pau gasol, mutombo

    12 earl monroe, mitch ritchmond, danny granger, chris bosh, moses malone

    13 stephon marbury, manu ginoboli, ron artest, jermaine oneal, bill walton

    14 gilbert arenas, ray allen, glenn robinson, dave cowens, big ben

    15 tim hardaway, joe dumars, michael finley, antonio mcdyess, marcus camby

    hm nick van exel, brandon roy, shawn marion, larry johnson, ilgauskas

    any thoughts?

    0
  • #182859
    Avatar
    NYK2010
    Participant

    Chris Mullen better than Dominque Wilkins now I’ve heard it all.

    0
  • #182888
    Avatar
    j1232e
    Participant

    tony parker the 7th greatest pg. Marbury even in your top 15. John stockton #10 stock is one of the greatest of all time.Actually after looking at it again it is very bad. I have question about everything. Boozer the 10th best power forward of all time come one, he might barly crack the top 5 of current power forwards. poor list.

    0
  • #182940
    Avatar
    Hale
    Participant

    Ilguaskas?????????

    0
  • #183172
    marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    John Stockton at 10???? Are you kidding me or what? Deron Williams, Baron Davis and Tony Parker should be AFTER Stockton…the all-time leader in assists…Carmelo in top 10 is a no-no… He forces his ugly game and he feels like he’s a superstar… OVERRATED!

    0
  • #183208
    Avatar
    ckowalski
    Participant

    I can’t believe you have Shaq as the greatest center of all time. And that Bill Russell is all the way down at number 6. And please tell me the number 14 center of all time is not Ben Wallace.

    0
  • #183344
    Avatar
    da guru

    all those players career averages are better than stocktons and they would kill him head to head

    0
  • #183346
    Avatar
    da guru

    look at chris mullin stats with golden state

    0
  • #183347
    Avatar
    da guru

    shaq will destroy bill russell and russell played wit short ass players

    0
  • #183356
    Avatar
    ckowalski
    Participant

    So what is your whole reasoning on this list? Best statistics? Most championships? Head to Head? What? If you go by stats there is no way that some of these guys are on there. Shaq is not the greatest center ever, that’s ridiculous. Bill Russell would be at the very least top 3 IMO, the guy has 11 championships as a player. What do you mean by he played with short players? Russell played with a lot of the guys on your list and he didn’t dominate because he was tall he dominated because he was simply better than everyone else. The guy was not even 7 feet tall and he averaged 22 RPG over his CAREER. When is Shaq, or Yao, or Dikembe, or Robinson, or Olajuwon going to do that? A lot of these selections are kind of crazy man. Mcdyess the 15th best power forward ever? Gasol the 11th best power forward ever? Marbury the 13th best PG ever? Based on what? Gasol has 1 championship and a whole lot of nothing for his career. I’m surprised you didn’t round out the list with Mbenga. At the very least this list should consist of guys that are in the HOF or virtual locks for the HOF, I mean we’re only talking about a list of 65 players. You can’t put players on this list that will only get in the HOF if they pay admission, that’s just ridiculous.

    0
  • #183509
    Avatar
    da guru

    there are players in the hall of fame by just playing on good teams like say james worthy now head to head you can say shawn marion is better than james worthy stat wise and talent wise bob cousy is a hall of famer but stephon marbury got career averages of 20ppg and 8apg and he is a better talent im basing this list on career numbers in their prime, and overall talent all hall of famers werent special talents or franchise players like stockton he was good but hes no franchise player like dwill and baron davis

    0
  • #183601
    Avatar
    bluedevils12
    Participant

    this list is pure terrible!how in the blue hell can u put Jon stockton so low? z ilguaskas made the list? boozer? manu before ray ray? o and my favorite: Mullens over wilkins? please Revise before i throw up

    0
  • #183620
    Avatar
    nthegoodlife
    Participant

    and so does your list. You’ve disrespected generations of players and the league itself. How old are you (seriously)? If this is all you have to offer this community, then STFU!!!! I’m not huge on many players of the past, but you are beyond out of line. You have LeBron as the greatest sf ever, are you fucking kidding me. Maybe one day, but he has a lot to accomplish to surpass the great Larry Legend. Shaq the greatest center, please, maybe the most dominating ever. Check the 94 finals, when the DREAM dominates shaq and the magic. It was a sweep. Shaq is physically imposing, but never really had skill, he still can’t even shoot a free throw.

    WTF moments?

    L Johnson
    J Oneal
    C Webb
    A Jefferson
    K Durant (huge fan, but nowhere near qualified for this list-maybe one day)
    G Robinson
    Melo
    B Davis
    Iverson
    Marbury
    T Parker
    Arenas
    M Finley
    S Marion
    A McDyess
    Big Z
    Camby
    Artest
    Granger
    G Hill (to many injuries, was great in his prime)
    Ginobili
    Penny
    Gasol (maybe in a few more years)
    Boozer
    Big Ben
    VC
    Where is Kevin McHale
    How about Parish
    The Glove is way to low
    Stockton should be no lower than 3rd best on ANY list
    What about Nate?

    I could go on and on, but I’m done. Maybe you should actually watch basketball sometime.

    0
  • #183953
    Avatar
    da guru

    u guys know nothing research those players

    0
  • #184031
    Avatar
    j1232e
    Participant

    stockton is the all time leader in steals and assists. maybe you should do a little research. 10 yr. olds should not be making lists of alltime basketball rankings.

    0
    • #184287
      Avatar
      da guru

      yeah cause he started till he was 41 stockton=calderon better defense

      0
  • #184145
    Avatar
    Knicksboy34
    Participant

    Da Guru….you need to fix that list…that is terrible.

    0
  • #184163
    Avatar
    bluedevils12
    Participant

    wow this may be the 1st post ive ever seen where everyone completely snaps and disses the guy who made the list. hahahahahaha

    0
  • #185083
    Avatar
    D_Legend
    Participant

    SMH….. boy I was so tempted to flag this a offensive

    0
  • #185787
    Avatar
    bluedevils12
    Participant

    haha wow i never thought of that d legend. haha. yea i def may flag some dam body if they post sum madness like this again. haha

    0
  • #186152
    Avatar
    da guru

    u guys just infatuated with big names didnt even look at no stats

    0
  • #186264
    Avatar
    nthegoodlife
    Participant

    No one is infatuated with “big” names so to speak, instead we acknowledge the past legends how they should be. Maybe you should become “infatuated” with grammar, atleast you would then have something going for you.

    0
  • #186921
    Avatar
    da guru

    look at some of the players numbers in their prime

    0
  • #188727
    Avatar
    j1232e
    Participant

    stocton started until he was 41. If calderon is so much better than stockton shouldn’t he start until he is 41 also. calderon will start for maybe 5-6 more seasons.

    0
  • #189191
    Avatar
    da guru

    thats y he got th all time numbers he wasnt doin shit

    0
  • #189277
    Avatar
    thepoopsmith
    Participant

    i would’ve commented sooner, but i saw the list, threw up out of rage, then passed out for 2 weeks. this is just…bad. my personal fav: kevin durant (with 2 years of NBA experience) ranked 2 places higher than dominique wilkins. and you can argue stockton is the best ever at his position…definately no worse than 3rd.

    0
  • #189593
    Avatar
    da guru

    if you was drafting theres no way youll take stockton 3rd with that list of pgs!!!!!!!

    domonique wilkins was a great scorer on losing teams he cant make the big shot for the game i bet durant can!!

    0
  • #189614
    Avatar
    j1232e
    Participant

    if you were old enough to remember the 80’s hawks they were pretty good, made it to they easstern finals.

    0
  • #190377
    Avatar
    bluedevils12
    Participant

    everyone lets stop harassing this idiot before he decides 2 create a topic in which he is threatening to leave the website. hahaha

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login