This topic contains 20 replies, has 14 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar The Big O 16 years, 8 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #9647
    AvatarAvatar
    MagikKnick
    Participant

    PG: Rajon Rondo (i think hes overrated…but hes still a great defender)
    SG: Hard one…lets go with Andre Iguodala
    SF: Shane Battier
    PF: iono…..Kevin Garnett
    C: Dwight Howard…i was hesitant to say Kendrick Perkins but Howard is a way better shot blocker…which creates a better “presence” overall

    Make Yours!

    0
  • #223725
    AvatarAvatar
    purpleFROG
    Participant

    PG- Kidd, not as fast anymore but still a good defender
    SG- Kobe
    SF-Shane Battier/ Ron Artest
    PF- Kevin Garnett
    C- Dwight Howard

    0
  • #223730
    AvatarAvatar
    JNixon
    Participant

    PG: Rajon Rondo & (even though he NEVER gets mention) Kyle Lowry
    SG: Andre Iguodala and John Salmons
    SF: Shane Battier
    PF: KG
    C: Dwight Howard

    0
  • #223732
    AvatarAvatar
    gainsey15
    Participant

    pg- rando(but remember young kidd he could guard fast pg and big 2 guard)
    sg- kobe
    sf- iggy(played sf last year)
    pf- gernett
    c- duncan (played c most of last season)

    0
  • #223733
    AvatarAvatar
    Bryant24
    Participant

    PG:Rondo
    Sg: Kobe
    SF:Ron Artest/Shane Battier
    PF:Kg
    C: Dwight

    0
  • #223738
    AvatarAvatar
    td8118
    Participant

    PG- Rondo
    SG-Kobe Bryant
    SF- Trevor Ariza/ Battier
    PF- Garnett
    C- Perkins

    0
  • #223756
    AvatarAvatar
    doubledribbler
    Participant

    PG: Rondo…I’m not sure anyone is as much of a pesk and the guy seems glued when he’s defending on the ball.
    SG: Artest…not really much to pick from. Kobe seems to be the popular choice, but I feel that Ron is more consistent defensively and brings effort more often than Kobe. Kobe generally just picks spots to play D or just brings it at the end of games. With that said, Ron’s not what he used to be.
    SF: Battier…no one is more disciplined on d. Doesn’t have the ridiculous numbers, but that is because he is so sound. I honestly think he is the best defender in the NBA period.
    PF: Garnett…I’m kind of surprised that he’s still the best now because of all the wear and tear but he brings it every night. Able to guard out on the perimeter as well as inside. Alter shots and still rebounds at a high rate.
    C: Duncan…another solid guy. I think Dwight has more electrifying moments, but he’s still not a disciplined defender. Sometimes he goes for blocks instead of staying on his feet or tries to kill shots out of bounds instead of trying to keep them in bounds.

    0
  • #223785
    AvatarAvatar
    The8thDeadlySin
    Participant

    PG: Chris Paul
    SG: Dwayne Wade
    SF: Lebron James
    PF: Tyrus Thomas
    C: Dwight Howard

    0
  • #223792
    AvatarAvatar
    JJeff6
    Participant

    wat about guys like roy hibbert, not sayin hibbert is ur guy, but sure can block a shot. CP3 is a great one too, as well as all of the celtics and spurs. RAJA BELL seriously underrated defender

    0
  • #223795
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    Best Defenders:

    PG- Chris Paul is one of the best pickpocketers in the league…
    SG- Kobe Bryant is probably the best wing defender right now… He just don’t let anyone get easy buckets.
    SF- Shane Battier… I remember when Kobe was asked who defends him the best and without hesitation, he answered,” Shane Battier”… A pretty compliment from a great offensive player.
    PF- Kevin Garnett- The 2008 Defensive Player of the Year and the glue that binds the Celtic D.
    C- Dwight Howard- The 2009 Defensive Player of the Year and the guy that makes the Magic run like a well-oiled machine on the defensive side… Such a beast.

    0
  • #223808
    AvatarAvatar
    bubbleryan
    Participant

    Pg- Russel Westbrook- Quick and long, still getting better.

    Sg- Courtney Lee- even as a rookie he stood up pretty well against everyone else’s main scorers. Probably not the best yet, but he is already up there.

    Sf- Battier- He kinda has to be on the list.

    Pf- Tim Duncan- Only over KG because he is healthier this year.

    C- Dwight Howard- easy one.

    0
  • #223809
    AvatarAvatar
    youngmag
    Participant

    Pg:Rondo…Yes I believe he is overrated to but best pg defender
    Sg:Wad…your a 6’4 shooting guard averagin more blocks than Lebron? Lets be serious
    Sf.Battier or Artest
    Pf-Garnett
    C-Dwight

    0
  • #223817
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    pg-rondo, but westbrook is close
    sg-Kobe, but Iguodala is close
    sf-Battier, but Artest is close
    pf-KG, but duncan is close
    c-Dwight, but KPerk is close

    0
  • #223834
    AvatarAvatar
    The Big O

    Pick up game “all-Defense” scenario

    Dwyane Wade (*)
    Andre Iguodala (1-2-3 position)
    Lebron James(**)
    Dwight Howard (natural position)
    Yao Ming (just his presence)
    *combo guard, at the PG he has great size and is more of a factor in transition defense than CP3
    **Shane Battier will foul out guarding an elite wing (Kobe), Lebron will not… Knowing when not to FOUL is also a key part of defense

    0
  • #223906
    AvatarAvatar
    Im Your Father
    Participant

    How is he a “natural power-forward?” Just because he is not 7′ tall does not make him a 4. He plays exactly like a center.

    0
    • #223912
      AvatarAvatar
      The Big O

      “How is he a “natural power-forward?” Just because he is not 7′ tall does not make him a 4. He plays exactly like a center.”

      Yao Ming plays exactly like a finesse power forward so what r u saying?

      because he is 7’6 tall Yao cannot guard quicker 4s. Howard on the other hand can defend other PFs. He got drafted as a F/C. he’s quick enough to guards PFs. He’s just a better option at center UNLESS you have Yao Ming on your team, thus he’s at the PF spot .)

      0
    • #223911
      AvatarAvatar
      The Big O

      He plays like Shaq but he’s Kevin Durant’s height.
      He plays like a center (that is an INSULT to 7 footers Patrick Ewing,Lew Alcindor, and Wilt Chamberlain)

      He’s the same size as Al Jefferson, he just has more help side blocks

      0
  • #223918
    AvatarAvatar
    Im Your Father
    Participant

    He is definitely quick enough to guard 4s, but he was the DPOY playing Center. He is best served holding down the paint and anchoring Orlando’s defense. His game is much more suited to that of a Center, therefore, he is clearly not a natural power forward. We had this exact same discussion about Deron Williams. Just because a player is capable of playing/guarding another position, doesn’t make it their natural one. Yes Howard can defend power forwards, but he is much better when he is playing Center. Therefore, he is a natural center.

    0
    • #223926
      AvatarAvatar
      The Big O

      If u were a coach on the floor and u had every PF/C
      u would sit Yao Ming on the bench

      and if so thats cool bcuz its only an opinion

      and Deron williams at the 2 isn’t better 4 the team but I think in this case

      Yao Ming and Howard would be better 4 an ALL DEFENSE TEAM.

      0
  • #223935
    AvatarAvatar
    MagikKnick
    Participant

    You guys are buggin, Kobe is the best defender at SG? Kobes defense is overrated…

    0
    • #223936
      AvatarAvatar
      The Big O

      The best players can defend MULTPLE positions

      VERSATILE PLAYERS LINEUP
      Dwyane Wade
      Andre Iguodala
      Lebron James
      Dwight Howard/Tim Duncan
      Yao Ming

      0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login