This topic contains 32 replies, has 11 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar Rip256 10 years, 8 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #61566
    AvatarAvatar
    valentine

    If a player has US Citizenship, they shouldn’t be on the list.  Tim Duncan is not an international player.  An international player is somebody who wasn’t a US Citizen when they started in the NBA.

    0
  • #1016832
    AvatarAvatar
    ZachAttack
    Participant

     I agree with that… Guys that are ACTUALLY international meaning played basketball outside the U.S. should be on that list. Guys like Emmanuel Mudiay and Rudy Gobert should eventually be on that list. Not Tim Duncan, as great as he is. He played in the NCAA.

    0
  • #1016967
    AvatarAvatar
    ZachAttack
    Participant

     I agree with that… Guys that are ACTUALLY international meaning played basketball outside the U.S. should be on that list. Guys like Emmanuel Mudiay and Rudy Gobert should eventually be on that list. Not Tim Duncan, as great as he is. He played in the NCAA.

    0
  • #1016852
    AvatarAvatar
    BEARDED-DRAGON
    Participant

     he clearly states his qualifications for someone making the list. born outside of the united states. if you want to say that hakeem, duncan, nash arent eligible because they played college ball in the us, all i can say is… make your own list. i mean, he includes guys who spent almost thier whole lives in the us and in the us basketball system like kyrie irving and dominique wilkins. those guys i take more exception to being called international. but they werent born in the usa. so they made his list. it was a great list. personally i think nash could be slightly higher… but im in victoria.

    0
    • #1016861
      AvatarAvatar
      Gronounours
      Participant

       So if he had said ‘are considered international those whose names don’t sound American’, you would find that okay? 

      0
      • #1016925
        AvatarAvatar
        BEARDED-DRAGON
        Participant

         yes. although i dont know if i understand what an "american name" is… arent they pretty much english names? or other european names that were changed to sound more english? kobe bryant? a japanese name mixed with an english name… chandler parsons? chandler is an english name originally meaning candle maker and parsons means a priests servant… im not trying to be a dick but unless we talking native american i dont know what an american name is… but sure, if those are the guidelines i guess kareem abdul jabbar may be the best international player ever. if your guidelines are "never stepped foot on the soil of the continental united states of america until they were drafted" then you will definitely have a different list than this guy.

        0
      • #1017061
        AvatarAvatar
        BEARDED-DRAGON
        Participant

         yes. although i dont know if i understand what an "american name" is… arent they pretty much english names? or other european names that were changed to sound more english? kobe bryant? a japanese name mixed with an english name… chandler parsons? chandler is an english name originally meaning candle maker and parsons means a priests servant… im not trying to be a dick but unless we talking native american i dont know what an american name is… but sure, if those are the guidelines i guess kareem abdul jabbar may be the best international player ever. if your guidelines are "never stepped foot on the soil of the continental united states of america until they were drafted" then you will definitely have a different list than this guy.

        0
    • #1016997
      AvatarAvatar
      Gronounours
      Participant

       So if he had said ‘are considered international those whose names don’t sound American’, you would find that okay? 

      0
  • #1016987
    AvatarAvatar
    BEARDED-DRAGON
    Participant

     he clearly states his qualifications for someone making the list. born outside of the united states. if you want to say that hakeem, duncan, nash arent eligible because they played college ball in the us, all i can say is… make your own list. i mean, he includes guys who spent almost thier whole lives in the us and in the us basketball system like kyrie irving and dominique wilkins. those guys i take more exception to being called international. but they werent born in the usa. so they made his list. it was a great list. personally i think nash could be slightly higher… but im in victoria.

    0
  • #1016859
    AvatarAvatar
    Gronounours
    Participant

    It doesn’t make sense at all. Wilkins and Vanderweghe are ‘international’ because they were born in France and Germany… So Parker should be listed as Belgian, as he was born in Belgium. 

     

    Laughable, really. 

    0
  • #1016995
    AvatarAvatar
    Gronounours
    Participant

    It doesn’t make sense at all. Wilkins and Vanderweghe are ‘international’ because they were born in France and Germany… So Parker should be listed as Belgian, as he was born in Belgium. 

     

    Laughable, really. 

    0
  • #1016907
    AvatarAvatar
    Choppy
    Participant

     It said Nash was born in South Africa, but listed him as Canadian. Luol Deng plays for England at the national level, but they listed him by his birth country, Sudan. 

    Also, I, I don’t think you can leave internationals off this list who play NCAA ball, as it is a much more recognised route to the NBA for internationals. Look at Ben Simmons. He’s international (Australia) but will be playing college ball this year. 

    0
    • #1017184
      AvatarAvatar
      XYRYX
      Participant

      I think there is a difference between international prospects or players an foreign players. Jennings was an international player in his year in Italy but was no foreigner.

      Then you have guys like Duncan or Kyrie who were born outside the US but have the citizenship.

      in the end players should be viewed as where they play (NCAA or somewhere else) because the only difference is mainly the media coverage and where they are developing their games. 

      0
    • #1017048
      AvatarAvatar
      XYRYX
      Participant

      I think there is a difference between international prospects or players an foreign players. Jennings was an international player in his year in Italy but was no foreigner.

      Then you have guys like Duncan or Kyrie who were born outside the US but have the citizenship.

      in the end players should be viewed as where they play (NCAA or somewhere else) because the only difference is mainly the media coverage and where they are developing their games. 

      0
  • #1017043
    AvatarAvatar
    Choppy
    Participant

     It said Nash was born in South Africa, but listed him as Canadian. Luol Deng plays for England at the national level, but they listed him by his birth country, Sudan. 

    Also, I, I don’t think you can leave internationals off this list who play NCAA ball, as it is a much more recognised route to the NBA for internationals. Look at Ben Simmons. He’s international (Australia) but will be playing college ball this year. 

    0
  • #1017174
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. HookShot
    Participant

    International players are players who played international for any team other than USA, with the exception of players born in the USA but switched to another nationality in order to play internationally (e.g. Kaman).

    0
  • #1017039
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. HookShot
    Participant

    International players are players who played international for any team other than USA, with the exception of players born in the USA but switched to another nationality in order to play internationally (e.g. Kaman).

    0
  • #1017192
    AvatarAvatar
    Cynthia
    Participant

    It’s hard to say who’s international and who’s not, it can be very subjective. Myself for example; I was born in Europe and came to the United States at a fairly young age. I’ve been in the US well over half of my life, I don’t even hardly remember living in Europe at all. I’ve been here so long I’ve always considered myself as an American rather than a European. However, regardless of living here most of my life I still had to get my US citizenship once I turned 18. So it’s kind of an odd situation, legally though I am in fact an "international".

     

    0
  • #1017056
    AvatarAvatar
    Cynthia
    Participant

    It’s hard to say who’s international and who’s not, it can be very subjective. Myself for example; I was born in Europe and came to the United States at a fairly young age. I’ve been in the US well over half of my life, I don’t even hardly remember living in Europe at all. I’ve been here so long I’ve always considered myself as an American rather than a European. However, regardless of living here most of my life I still had to get my US citizenship once I turned 18. So it’s kind of an odd situation, legally though I am in fact an "international".

     

    0
  • #1017194
    AvatarAvatar
    Dazzling Dunks and Basketball Bloopers
    Participant

     Players who were raised and learned the game primarily in the US (i.e kyrie, boozer, Ewing) should not be considered international players imo. Virgin islands are technically part of the US so its hard for me to consider Duncan international as well. 

    0
  • #1017058
    AvatarAvatar
    Dazzling Dunks and Basketball Bloopers
    Participant

     Players who were raised and learned the game primarily in the US (i.e kyrie, boozer, Ewing) should not be considered international players imo. Virgin islands are technically part of the US so its hard for me to consider Duncan international as well. 

    0
  • #1017196
    AvatarAvatar
    Dazzling Dunks and Basketball Bloopers
    Participant

     Players who were raised and learned the game primarily in the US (i.e kyrie, boozer, Ewing) should not be considered international players imo. Virgin islands are technically part of the US so its hard for me to consider Duncan international as well. 

    0
  • #1017060
    AvatarAvatar
    Dazzling Dunks and Basketball Bloopers
    Participant

     Players who were raised and learned the game primarily in the US (i.e kyrie, boozer, Ewing) should not be considered international players imo. Virgin islands are technically part of the US so its hard for me to consider Duncan international as well. 

    0
  • #1017218
    AvatarAvatar
    jaycee24
    Participant

     If you can play for team USA you aren’t international that’s my opinion 

    0
  • #1017082
    AvatarAvatar
    jaycee24
    Participant

     If you can play for team USA you aren’t international that’s my opinion 

    0
    • #1019176
      AvatarAvatar
      European Basketballer
      Participant

      Wrong. Team USA has used many naturalized players over the years. They are in the very top of all teams in the world in doing so.

      That means every player in the world is eligible to play for Team USA, because that is how the naturalized player rule works.

      Any player can play for Team USA, because they allow naturalized players.

       

       

       

       

      0
    • #1019035
      AvatarAvatar
      European Basketballer
      Participant

      Wrong. Team USA has used many naturalized players over the years. They are in the very top of all teams in the world in doing so.

      That means every player in the world is eligible to play for Team USA, because that is how the naturalized player rule works.

      Any player can play for Team USA, because they allow naturalized players.

       

       

       

       

      0
  • #1017104
    AvatarAvatar
    Rip256

     The simplest way is to just ask someone what nationality they identify themselves as.

     

    0
    • #1019178
      AvatarAvatar
      European Basketballer
      Participant

       But Seikaly and Peja both state over and over they identify themselves as Greeks, and yet no one in former Yugolsavia, and no NBA only fans will ever admit that as truth.

      I never seen anyone from NBA only fans or ex Yugo country to admit that. Same with Lebanonese, as they all claim it is not true either.

      The players identify as Greek, but millions of people claim they don’t.

      You can’t ever mention in any basketball forum the truth that both Seikaly and Peja consider themselves Greek, without having dozens of people claim that is a lie. Even though they both claimed many many times they consider themselves Greek.

       

       

       

      0
    • #1019037
      AvatarAvatar
      European Basketballer
      Participant

       But Seikaly and Peja both state over and over they identify themselves as Greeks, and yet no one in former Yugolsavia, and no NBA only fans will ever admit that as truth.

      I never seen anyone from NBA only fans or ex Yugo country to admit that. Same with Lebanonese, as they all claim it is not true either.

      The players identify as Greek, but millions of people claim they don’t.

      You can’t ever mention in any basketball forum the truth that both Seikaly and Peja consider themselves Greek, without having dozens of people claim that is a lie. Even though they both claimed many many times they consider themselves Greek.

       

       

       

      0
      • #1019242
        AvatarAvatar
        Rip256

         Dude u know more about Euro prospects than anyone. Who is the top 5 for 2016

        0
      • #1019101
        AvatarAvatar
        Rip256

         Dude u know more about Euro prospects than anyone. Who is the top 5 for 2016

        0
  • #1017240
    AvatarAvatar
    Rip256

     The simplest way is to just ask someone what nationality they identify themselves as.

     

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login