This topic contains 22 replies, has 9 voices, and was last updated by
rileymcshea3 11 years, 11 months ago.
- AuthorPosts
- Posted on: Thu, 07/17/2014 - 4:33pm #57426
Lotto StudParticipantThis issue hits some kind of nerve for me, because a lot of athletes get criticized for coming into the league not fully "developed". When I refer to undersized, I am not speaking on the lack of inches that are given up to play a specific position. I am speaking up for the guys in the league who are considered "malnourished".
Prime example being Zach LaVine.
- LaVine is a freak athlete who is very skilled by taking advantage of his elite athleticim. The problem that is constanly brought up, is that he is very undersized, and that he needs to hit the weight room hard to add bulk on his 6’5” 180.
While many believe it’s a must that LaVine do so, I say not so fast my friend! Do you all not forget how effective Reggie Miller was with his wiry frame, despite playing in an era that wasn’t as strong physically back then as it is today. The argument may be that he was just an outside shooter, but if you all know about the late-’80s and early-’90s era, it was the closest thing to a MMA bout.
If the Miller example isn’t good enough, I now present to you Richard "Rip" Hamilton who happens to go down in my book, as the best mid-range player in the history of the game at 6’7” 193. While people still complained about his thin frame, many forget how much endurance he had being "malnourished". The best at playing off the ball, and creating space to get his shots off at will in congested areas, around some of the tallest athletes in the world.
Before you be so quick to judge these athletes, think about the advantages they have at the playing weight they check-in at. Bulk is always not the route to take, just because the league is in a new wave of the professional athlete.
Lastly, do not forget about Kobe Bryant emphasising that he had to get back down to his HS playing weight, at 217 lbs. from the 230 lbs. he was carrying around the season before.
0 - Posted on: Thu, 07/17/2014 - 5:18pm #937481
treytalkssports.comParticipantWith the no hand-checking rules today, the only time being thin really hurts guards is when they drive. Lavine will be effective right away as a ball-handler, distributor, and shooter. However, he will never be able to use his superb athleticism until he bulks up. Finishing in the lane requires core strength. More and more help-side defenders are learning to jump straight up and take contact from drivers. For skinny drivers, that amount of contact throws their shot off, especially if the defender is long and can keep his hands up to disrupt the shot.
0 - Posted on: Thu, 07/17/2014 - 5:18pm #937351
treytalkssports.comParticipantWith the no hand-checking rules today, the only time being thin really hurts guards is when they drive. Lavine will be effective right away as a ball-handler, distributor, and shooter. However, he will never be able to use his superb athleticism until he bulks up. Finishing in the lane requires core strength. More and more help-side defenders are learning to jump straight up and take contact from drivers. For skinny drivers, that amount of contact throws their shot off, especially if the defender is long and can keep his hands up to disrupt the shot.
0 - Posted on: Thu, 07/17/2014 - 6:10pm #937501

festar35ParticipantCurrently there are "skinny" dudes in NBA, Kevin Durant, Jamal Crawford, Monta Ellis plenty more.
If you can ball you can ball, whether skinny or not it shouldn’t make a difference.
0 - Posted on: Thu, 07/17/2014 - 6:10pm #937371

festar35ParticipantCurrently there are "skinny" dudes in NBA, Kevin Durant, Jamal Crawford, Monta Ellis plenty more.
If you can ball you can ball, whether skinny or not it shouldn’t make a difference.
0- Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 9:26pm #937848
Lotto StudParticipantEveryone is so enamored with the body builders of the sport, that they forget about the guys who are actually conditioned well being slim.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 9:26pm #937979
Lotto StudParticipantEveryone is so enamored with the body builders of the sport, that they forget about the guys who are actually conditioned well being slim.
0
- Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 3:59am #937506

JoeWolf1Strongly disagree. You cited two of the best jump shooters of the past 25 years, and to shoot 15-25 feet away from the basket you don’t need to be that strong. Reggie Miller only shot 5.1 free throws per game on his career, and Rip Hamilton only 4.1. In 2014, 5 attempts per game gets you in the top 25 in FT attempted, 4.1 gets you in the top 60.
I think maybe you’re misunderstanding Kobe’s comment on 217 lbs. That wasn’t his high school weight, he said he was in mid-season form. Kobe was around 200lbs as a rookie, and although combine records are tough to find from back then, you can look at his rookie card, and playing weight in 1996.
http://www.smalltraditions.com/ItemImages/000001/5_1119b_lg.jpeg
LaVine has a unique blend of athleticism and he needs to put on 15-20 lbs to, not only, take the punishment of a slasher, but to aid in his finishing amongst the 275 lb rim protectors of the league. Sure, he could stay at 181 and fall in love with his jump shot, but IMO that wouldn’t do his potential justice.
You look at his FG% at the rim at the NCAA level, and it’s a pretty underwhelming 54.8%. Finishing at the rim in the NBA isn’t going to get any easier, and just for some comparison, other combo guards, and wings (also stronger) in the draft class shot much better at the rim percentages. Marcus Smart (64.9%) Markel Brown (67.4%) Nick Johnson (68.2%) James Young (61.6%) Andrew Wiggins (63.6%) C.J. Wilcox (70.9%).
Look no further than DeMar DeRozan. 6’5.5” in socks, 6’9” wingspan, 216 lbs and in the top 10 in Free Throws attemtped per game at 8 per game. LaVine ins 6’4.5” in socks, with a 6’8.25” wingspan and 181 lbs. He has room to grow, and has the long fram to bulk up to 195-200 lbs, if not more, and not lose his athletic ability. NBA trainers are flat out fitness guru’s and the guys that fail at bulking up and lose athleticism (Drew Gooden comes to mind ) are guys that don’t eat right and gain fat too. There’s not a doubt in my mind, a 195 lb Zach LaVine could still fly over a Great Dane with his knees straight. 15 lbs of lean muscle isn’t that much for a 6’5” guy with long arms, hell it’s not much for a guy a shade over 6′ like myself.
Slashers in today’s game are strong, whether hand checking is extinct or not. I think to maximize his potential, LaVine would be wise to put on some weight. It might actually help him out a bit on his 2nd jumps, and when he’s greatly fatigued at the end of a game.
15 lbs on a frame as slight as Zach’s isn’t even going to be that noticable, but the strength he’ll gain will pay off immensely. Whether it’s taking a hit, posting up a mismatch who would normally push him off the block, or possible helping him jump higher. The best player in the league and most all around athletic guy in the league is 265 lbs and IMMENSELY benefitted from putting on 30 lbs since high school ( Lebron ). The 2nd best player in the league put on 20 lbs since his year at Texas and got MORE athletic. LaVine will benefit from hitting the weights, he may be a jaw dropping leaper now, but no one is asking him to play at 230, or eat McDonalds to get there. NBA trainers know what they’re talking about, and in that enviroment, I feel strength training is the best way to get the most out of LaVine’s potential. Yeah, he’s got a good enough shot, and is fast enough to develop into a jump shooter and transition dunker like Gerald Green, but he has the natural ability to become much better, well rounded player, and I strongly feel the weight room is just on element of him maximizing his potential.
0- Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 4:47am #937520
phila9012ParticipantYeah, nobody is saying he needs to add 30 to 40 pounds of muscle. 10 to 20 punds is good enough to help with his finishing ability and so he won’t get destroyed by bigger guards in the post.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 4:47am #937650
phila9012ParticipantYeah, nobody is saying he needs to add 30 to 40 pounds of muscle. 10 to 20 punds is good enough to help with his finishing ability and so he won’t get destroyed by bigger guards in the post.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 2:34pm #937757
Lotto StudParticipantWill Barton is proving this theory all wrong, weighing-in at 145 lbs. soaking wet.
0- Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 5:01pm #937792

JoeWolf1He lost 29 lbs since he was drafted?
i know you’re a Memphis fan, but a 4 ppg career scorer having a nice summer league isn’t proving anything wrong.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 5:01pm #937922

JoeWolf1He lost 29 lbs since he was drafted?
i know you’re a Memphis fan, but a 4 ppg career scorer having a nice summer league isn’t proving anything wrong.
0
- Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 2:34pm #937887
Lotto StudParticipantWill Barton is proving this theory all wrong, weighing-in at 145 lbs. soaking wet.
0
- Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 3:59am #937636

JoeWolf1Strongly disagree. You cited two of the best jump shooters of the past 25 years, and to shoot 15-25 feet away from the basket you don’t need to be that strong. Reggie Miller only shot 5.1 free throws per game on his career, and Rip Hamilton only 4.1. In 2014, 5 attempts per game gets you in the top 25 in FT attempted, 4.1 gets you in the top 60.
I think maybe you’re misunderstanding Kobe’s comment on 217 lbs. That wasn’t his high school weight, he said he was in mid-season form. Kobe was around 200lbs as a rookie, and although combine records are tough to find from back then, you can look at his rookie card, and playing weight in 1996.
http://www.smalltraditions.com/ItemImages/000001/5_1119b_lg.jpeg
LaVine has a unique blend of athleticism and he needs to put on 15-20 lbs to, not only, take the punishment of a slasher, but to aid in his finishing amongst the 275 lb rim protectors of the league. Sure, he could stay at 181 and fall in love with his jump shot, but IMO that wouldn’t do his potential justice.
You look at his FG% at the rim at the NCAA level, and it’s a pretty underwhelming 54.8%. Finishing at the rim in the NBA isn’t going to get any easier, and just for some comparison, other combo guards, and wings (also stronger) in the draft class shot much better at the rim percentages. Marcus Smart (64.9%) Markel Brown (67.4%) Nick Johnson (68.2%) James Young (61.6%) Andrew Wiggins (63.6%) C.J. Wilcox (70.9%).
Look no further than DeMar DeRozan. 6’5.5” in socks, 6’9” wingspan, 216 lbs and in the top 10 in Free Throws attemtped per game at 8 per game. LaVine ins 6’4.5” in socks, with a 6’8.25” wingspan and 181 lbs. He has room to grow, and has the long fram to bulk up to 195-200 lbs, if not more, and not lose his athletic ability. NBA trainers are flat out fitness guru’s and the guys that fail at bulking up and lose athleticism (Drew Gooden comes to mind ) are guys that don’t eat right and gain fat too. There’s not a doubt in my mind, a 195 lb Zach LaVine could still fly over a Great Dane with his knees straight. 15 lbs of lean muscle isn’t that much for a 6’5” guy with long arms, hell it’s not much for a guy a shade over 6′ like myself.
Slashers in today’s game are strong, whether hand checking is extinct or not. I think to maximize his potential, LaVine would be wise to put on some weight. It might actually help him out a bit on his 2nd jumps, and when he’s greatly fatigued at the end of a game.
15 lbs on a frame as slight as Zach’s isn’t even going to be that noticable, but the strength he’ll gain will pay off immensely. Whether it’s taking a hit, posting up a mismatch who would normally push him off the block, or possible helping him jump higher. The best player in the league and most all around athletic guy in the league is 265 lbs and IMMENSELY benefitted from putting on 30 lbs since high school ( Lebron ). The 2nd best player in the league put on 20 lbs since his year at Texas and got MORE athletic. LaVine will benefit from hitting the weights, he may be a jaw dropping leaper now, but no one is asking him to play at 230, or eat McDonalds to get there. NBA trainers know what they’re talking about, and in that enviroment, I feel strength training is the best way to get the most out of LaVine’s potential. Yeah, he’s got a good enough shot, and is fast enough to develop into a jump shooter and transition dunker like Gerald Green, but he has the natural ability to become much better, well rounded player, and I strongly feel the weight room is just on element of him maximizing his potential.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 5:46am #937542

ItsVictorOladipoParticipantLastly, do not forget about Kobe Bryant emphasising that he had to get back down to his HS playing weight, at 217 lbs. from the 230 lbs. he was carrying around the season before.
——————————————————————————–I’m not sure if this anecdote supports the rest of your argument. If Kobe is playing at 217 lbs, and is about 6-4 bare foot, dude is jacked and probably much stronger than Lavine who is the same height and measured 36 lbs lighter at the combine. Lavine doesn’t have to become a monster but getting up to 195-200lbs would surely help his game.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 5:46am #937672

ItsVictorOladipoParticipantLastly, do not forget about Kobe Bryant emphasising that he had to get back down to his HS playing weight, at 217 lbs. from the 230 lbs. he was carrying around the season before.
——————————————————————————–I’m not sure if this anecdote supports the rest of your argument. If Kobe is playing at 217 lbs, and is about 6-4 bare foot, dude is jacked and probably much stronger than Lavine who is the same height and measured 36 lbs lighter at the combine. Lavine doesn’t have to become a monster but getting up to 195-200lbs would surely help his game.
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 2:46pm #937759
gbmantisParticipantAllen Iverson was 150 lbs soaking wet
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 2:46pm #937889
gbmantisParticipantAllen Iverson was 150 lbs soaking wet
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 3:01pm #937763

The Scare Crow RisesParticipant170 pounds with all his jewelry…
0 - Posted on: Fri, 07/18/2014 - 3:01pm #937893

The Scare Crow RisesParticipant170 pounds with all his jewelry…
0 - Posted on: Sun, 07/20/2014 - 9:53pm #938524

rileymcshea3ParticipantObviously Lavine isn’t going to become absolutely bolked up and lose athleticism. His wiry frame and length wouldn’t even let him if he tried. That being said this is a mans league, and adding 10-20 pounds of muscle can only help you in almost every aspect of the game of basketball. Don’t see any negatives to it.
0 - Posted on: Sun, 07/20/2014 - 9:53pm #938392

rileymcshea3ParticipantObviously Lavine isn’t going to become absolutely bolked up and lose athleticism. His wiry frame and length wouldn’t even let him if he tried. That being said this is a mans league, and adding 10-20 pounds of muscle can only help you in almost every aspect of the game of basketball. Don’t see any negatives to it.
0 - AuthorPosts
| You must be logged in to reply to this topic. | Login |