This topic contains 13 replies, has 8 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar Grandmama 15 years ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #29624
    AvatarAvatar
    Allen_Iverson_3
    Participant

    I see that on the 2011 mock draft there has been a major change: Derrick Williams is placed at number 1. How do you explain this? Is this due to Irving’s physical condition or rather to the fact that the Cavs rather need to draft a SF/PF over a PG? I think it’s a mix of both.

    Thoughts?

    0
  • #537810
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    Irving and dwill will probably be up in the air for awhile.

    0
  • #537811
    AvatarAvatar
    Allen_Iverson_3
    Participant

    Tobias Harris climbing at 18….Marshon Brooks goes 19…. Tyler at 28…. Jordan Williams decreasing… Goudelock at 41….

    And Lauvergne finally in the draft! That kid can become nice (I have him in my mock).

     

    So many things to comment on!

    0
  • #537814
    AvatarAvatar
    M-DYMES
    Participant

    I think it is a combo of a few things…

    1.  Kyrie skipped workouts and alot of people think its because he was afraid his athleticism and other portions of his game may be exposed as not being #1 pick worthy.

    2.   Derrick Williams has done nothing to hurt himself at all.  He is confident, which you need, and is a far better defensive player than Kyrie. 

    3.  The Cavs do have decent PGs…Baron, Sessions, Gibson…all solid PGs to have on your squad.

    4.  I may be reading into this too much but…

    Given that trade rumor of T-Wolves getting picks 4/8…Cavs get 1/2…and Pistons get rid of Hamilton.

    Personally, there is a side of this to me that says the Cavs covet Williams slightly more than Irving.  My reasoning…

    If you have picks 1 and 4 you could go Williams at 1 and still get a stellar PG in Knight or Walker at 4 (odds are).  If you have 1 and 4 and go PG…you essentially have no shot at Williams IMO.  By stating intersest in moving up to 1 and 2…you are assuring yourself of Irving and Williams.  I think this strong intersest means that they truly want Williams in this draft, and while they also want Irving, I think they either trade up to get both of them or they go William @1 and then go either Knight/Kanter/Walker @ 4. 

    5.  Derrick Williams was clearly the most dominant player in college Bball last year IMO. 

     

    0
  • #537815
    AvatarAvatar
    Allen_Iverson_3
    Participant

    I feel like all of your reasons are valid. I’m just kinda surprised that all of these mocks had Irving in front of Williams for so long. I thought from the start that the Cavs are nearly full with average/decent PGs and had in contrast nearly nothing at SF if you consider Jamison is more a PF.

    0
  • #537820
    AvatarAvatar
    bksmith
    Participant

    Willaims was not the most dominant player in College basketball last season. He has a good squad around him but some games he just didn’t show up. I hope that is not what happens to him in the NBA.

     

    I would hesitate to draft Irving as well. You should back yourself up a little bit and he did no such thing. Peoples imaginations can be so much worse than the truth and he might have just set himself up for that.

    0
  • #537822
    AvatarAvatar
    bennydabull
    Participant

    seems like they are has been an update

     

    0
  • #537823
    AvatarAvatar
    M-DYMES
    Participant

    bksmith…who do you suggest was the best played in college bball last year then?  And Im going from the standpoint of those who are in this year’s draft class.

    Who in this years class was more dominant than Williams?  Walker maybe, but personally I’ll still say Williams given his clutch D and all around game. 

    0
  • #537825
    AvatarAvatar
    Allen_Iverson_3
    Participant

    That point on the best player in this year’s NCAA is kind of the only one on which I don’t totally agree. I think Kemba, because he nearly won the title by himself or at least UConn might not have made the March Madness without him, can be considered as the most dominant player in NCAA. Derrick Williams was also dominant, but I don’t know if Arizona would have won the title if he was not injured. On that point, Kemba and Williams are very tight.

    0
  • #537828
    AvatarAvatar
    M-DYMES
    Participant

    So you can’t really knock me for saying he was the most dominant player.  I agree, from this draft class, Kemba was really the only one who was close to him.  But if you have the number 1 pick, IDK how many teams are necessarily considering Kemba @ 1.  That is more or less between Kyrie and Derrick…and between those two, Derrick was far more dominant throughout the whole season (given Kyrie’s injury, made Derrick far more consistent and proven).  I should have been more specific with my intent from my post.

    I can’t argue with you though that Kemba was arguably the most dominant.  Its just that he is not being considered for the 1st overall pick IMO and that strengthens the argument for Williams @ 1 even more.

     

    If you could get Williams @ 1 and Kemba @ 4, I think you are bringing in the 2 most dominant players in college Bball last season (from this class).  

    0
  • #537830
    AvatarAvatar
    Allen_Iverson_3
    Participant

    People are still questioning if Kemba will be as dominant once in the NBA, firstly due to his size

    0
  • #537840
    AvatarAvatar
    NYFLAVA2K9
    Participant

    I think this mock is the reflection of a point ive been bringing up for a few weeks. If you take Irving #1 and then Kanter and Williams go #2 and #3, that would put the Cavs in a spot where they are stuck with a combo of Irving and Leanord/Valanciunas/Vesely which would be a major dissapointment. The Cavs know this too.. why do you think they are trying so hard to get that #2 pick… Atleast if DW goes #1 you still have a worst case scenario of DW to pair with Knight or even Kanter if Knight goes to the Jazz at 3.. The Cavs don’t want a combo of Irving and Kanter bcuz they both have too many question marks health wise.. DW is a lot easier to pair someone with..

    0
  • #537892
    AvatarAvatar
    HotSnot
    Participant

    As another poster brought up regarding the Cavs PG status… Baron for 2 more years, Sessions and Gibson, Pg doesn’t seem like the most pressing need.  I know your thinking the Cavs could trade Sessions, but why would they?  For what Sessions brings to the table at such an affordable price I’d rather hang on to him. 

    Is PG really a priority for the Cavs?  Even if it is a priority is Irving really worth the 1st overall.  I don’t care about him skipping the combine testing.  You knew he would.  Not just because of his draft slot, but because his training has been inconsistant since he returned from the toe injury.  He would get smoked by vitrtually every other guard on the testing… which would give everyone something to pick at.  If your not in peak condition why test?  The results would not be representative of who you really are anyways…  However, in todays NBA, with some truely elite athletes at the position, Irving will be at an athletic disadvantage on most nights on Defense even if he’s in great shape.  Thats ok if your game management, handles, shot selection and shooting #’s are all above average.   Are Irvings intangibles that good?  I don’t know the answer to that.  Its guess work to say how a guy will turn out especially with such a limited sample in his lone year of college.

    If I’m the Cavs I’d go for Williams #1.  What I most like about his game is his ability to draw fouls and shoot at a high clip from the line.  Its a necessity to be considered a great player.  You need a good ft % and he has one.  Williams can also stretch floor to the 3 point line to help unclog the paint and keep his own defenders honest.  In the NCAA’s I noticed some remarkable footwork out of the high post.  He is definitly nice on his feet.

    After the Cavs take Williams I think there’s a chance Minny takes Kanter second.  As a true center who is nimble and athletic, there’s not too many Center’s who will be able to match up with his athleticism AND size.  260 at 5.4% body fat is pretty amazing.  Kanter could put on 10 pounds of fat and he’d still be under 7.5% body fat.  Do you think defensive ace in the hole Kendrick Perkins would have an easy time guarding Kanter?  Kanter will draw fouls and much like Williams he will be able to convert at the line.  Kanter has a nice array of most moves and should be a really nice Starting Center for a long time.

    Should the Cav’s Wolves Pistons trade go through, I’d like to see the Cavs take Williams and Kanter #1 and #2.  The Cavs frontline would be quite fantastic and versatile with Hickson, Side show bob, Kanter and Williams up front.  Of those 4 Williams is the only one who has a chance at playing the 3 but thats ok.  The Cavs would have a big available to matchup with any frontline in the NBA.  This was the Memphis plan with Gasol and ZBO.  Could Kanter and Williams eventually turn into that kind of duo?  I know I’m repeating myself here but its the FT’s that make the memphis combo what they are.  They love getting to the line. They don’t alter their own shots on offense to avoid the line (there are some NBA bigs who do this).  They attack the rim which will put opposing bigs in foul trouble and make for slightly more honest and passive D later.

    This leaves the Utah pick and wouldn’t you know… after shipping out their franchise PG to the Nets, they can draft another potential franchise PG in Irving at #3, or they could go Brandon Knight?  Either way Utah is pretty Darn happy.

    So my first three picks are Williams Kanter and then Irving or Knight. 

    Teams have a history of NOT passing on bigs in favor of PG’s.  Williams and Kanter are very skilled and above average athletically with excellant size. 

    I know teams have been floating Valanciunus and Vesely as being above Kanter on their draft boards but I really believe thats a complete lie.  What these teams are trying to sell you is misdirection based on potential.  I have no doubt they like those 2 players but not if Kanter is on the board.  Why would teams draft either of those 2 guys based on their potential when Kanter will come in and start at C from day one?  Both Valanciunus and Vesely will need alot of luck to ever be as good as Kanter is right now.

    From the Cavs perspective I believe there’s a good chance acquiring the first and second picks was not for Williams and Irving.  I think it was for Williams and Kanter.  Kanter won’t make it to 4th. 

    0
  • #537903
    AvatarAvatar
    Grandmama
    Participant

    lol bennydabull, obviously people have no idea why you posted what you….i got a good laugh but i think it went way over some of these dude’s heads

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login