[rhofernParticipant]

would you rather:

– chris paul or steve nash in 2005
– dwyane wade or kobe in 2006
– brandon roy in 2011 or paul pierce in 2002
– oj mayo in 2012 or vince carter in 2000
– kobe in 2006 or lebron in 2010
– kevin durant in 2011 or carmelo anthony in 2010
– guarding kobe: artest or battier
– nowitzki in 2005 or duncan in 2001
– paul millsap or david lee
– chris bosh or david west
– antwan jamison or al harrington
– shaq in 1999 or dwight howard in 2011
– derrick rose in 2011 or oj mayo in 2010
– brook lopez in 2010 or kevin love in 2010

[Michael.S.Participant]

– chris paul or steve nash in 2005 NASH
– dwyane wade or kobe in 2006 KOBE
– brandon roy in 2011 or paul pierce in 2002 ROY
– oj mayo in 2012 or vince carter in 2000 CARTER
– kobe in 2006 or lebron in 2010 LEBRON
– kevin durant in 2011 or carmelo anthony in 2010 BANKING ON DURANT
– guarding kobe: artest or battier BATTIER
– nowitzki in 2005 or duncan in 2001 DUNCAN
– paul millsap or david lee LEE
– chris bosh or david west BOSH
– antwan jamison or al harrington JAMISON
– shaq in 1999 or dwight howard in 2011 HOWARD
– derrick rose in 2011 or oj mayo in 2010 ROSE
– brook lopez in 2010 or kevin love in 2010 LOPEZ

[MagikKnickParticipant]

2005 – Steve Nash
2006 – Dwyane Wade
2011 – Brandon Roy
2000 – Vince Carter
2010 – Lebron
2011 – Kevin Durant
Battier On Kobe
2001 – Duncan
Paul Milsap
Chris Bosh
Al Harrington
2011 – Dwight
2011 – Derrick Rose
2010 – Brook Lopez

[llperez]

just to save time, I agree with everything mikenike said except I’ll take ’99 Shaq over ’11 Dwight.

[llperez]

you guys are all going with Dwight in 2 years over a prime Shaq when he was dominating the league? He was unstoppable from ’99-01. Dwight is great, but his offense and physical dominance might never reach what a prime Shaq was.

[rhofernParticipant]

i too would take shaq over dwight

[sheltwon3Participant]

same here but I can see the Howard pick being good too because right now Howard can do things on defense that O’neal could never do. If Howard can polish his offensive game a lil he may not be as dominating offensively but if you combine his offense and defense he may be the better pick but i will still go with O’neal though

[McWinningParticipant]

Chris Paul
Kobe
B-Roy
Of Mayo
Lebron
Kevin Durant
Battier
Duncan
Lee
Jamison
Shaq
Mayo
Lopez

[DarSParticipant]

Chris Paul
Kobe
Roy
Mayo
LeBron
Durant
Battier
Nowitzki
Millsap
Bosh
Jamison
Shaq
Rose
Lopez

[youngmagParticipant]

Cp3
Kobe
Roy hes better now and he’ll be ten times better than him in 011
Vince ssooo underrated
Idk Kobe I’m sorry lol
Durant Hands down hes the next top 5 player watch
BATTIER
DUNCAN
LEE
BOSH hands down
JAMISON
Shaq
ROSE
LOPEZ

[JNixonParticipant]

– chris paul or steve nash in 2005- Steve Nash…Paul was still in college I believe

– dwyane wade or kobe in 2006-Kobe Bryant

– brandon roy in 2011 or paul pierce in 2002-Brandon Roy

– oj mayo in 2012 or vince carter in 2000-Half Man, Half Amazing

– kobe in 2006 or lebron in 2010-Lebron 2010

– kevin durant in 2011 or carmelo anthony in 2010- Kevin Durant

– guarding kobe: artest or battier- Shane Battier

– nowitzki in 2005 or duncan in 2001-Duncan 2001

– paul millsap or david lee- David Lee, its close though

– chris bosh or david west-Chris Bosh

– antwan jamison or al harrington- Antwan Jamison

– shaq in 1999 or dwight howard in 2011- Shaq O’Neal

– derrick rose in 2011 or oj mayo in 2010-Derrick Rose

– brook lopez in 2010 or kevin love in 2010-Brook Lopez

[MagikKnickParticipant]

EDIT; I was wrong again

[Author]

Posts