This topic contains 109 replies, has 30 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar billyk 13 years, 7 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #21524
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    Alot of meaningless bickering over Rose and Westbrook, people just restating the facts they stated. Just votes please no reasoning.

    Pick Rose or Westbrook and we will settle this debate once and for all. Dont tell me, but people dont know Westbrook is really good because he doesnt get the same exposure as Rose, THATS BULLSHIT! Evertyone knows Westbrook averages more double-doubles.

    I select Rose.

    Rose-1
    Westbrook-0

    0
  • #399923
    AvatarAvatar
    Anton123
    Participant

    Stop this discussion already please!
    No reasoning? Westbrook

    0
  • #399926
    AvatarAvatar
    Anton123
    Participant

    Stop this discussion already please!
    No reasoning? Westbrook

    0
  • #399927
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. Jewboy
    Participant

    i vote westbrook
    i really fell in love with his game this summer

    0
  • #399929
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. Jewboy
    Participant

    i vote westbrook
    i really fell in love with his game this summer

    0
  • #399930
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    I mean no reasoning because weve heard all the arguements already, it is time to just bury this arguement once and for all.

    0
  • #399931
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    I mean no reasoning because weve heard all the arguements already, it is time to just bury this arguement once and for all.

    0
  • #399938
    AvatarAvatar
    The Scare Crow Returns
    Participant

    Derrick “I bite off the heads of gummy bears and spit them out crying” Rose is an MVP type of point guard that can take over in the late stages of the game…If he had an inch more in the height department he’d be Dwayne Wade 2.0 with better passing ability …Westbrook is very explosive and great on the defensive end , he’s getting better at breaking people down and taking over in spurts…but he’s not better than Rose right now and if both guys keep progressing at that rate, Rose will still be better than Westbrook by a close margin….

    0
  • #399939
    AvatarAvatar
    The Scare Crow Returns
    Participant

    Derrick “I bite off the heads of gummy bears and spit them out crying” Rose is an MVP type of point guard that can take over in the late stages of the game…If he had an inch more in the height department he’d be Dwayne Wade 2.0 with better passing ability …Westbrook is very explosive and great on the defensive end , he’s getting better at breaking people down and taking over in spurts…but he’s not better than Rose right now and if both guys keep progressing at that rate, Rose will still be better than Westbrook by a close margin….

    0
  • #399953
    AvatarAvatar
    The Scare Crow Returns
    Participant

    Derrick “I bite off the heads of gummy bears and spit them out crying” Rose is an MVP type of point guard that can take over in the late stages of the game…If he had an inch more in the height department he’d be Dwayne Wade 2.0 with better passing ability …Westbrook is very explosive and great on the defensive end , he’s getting better at breaking people down and taking over in spurts…but he’s not better than Rose right now and if both guys keep progressing at that rate, Rose will still be better than Westbrook by a close margin….

    0
  • #399940
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    Rose-2
    Westbrook-2

    0
  • #399941
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    Rose-2
    Westbrook-2

    0
  • #399955
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    Rose-2
    Westbrook-2

    0
  • #399942
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    And btw Scarecrow thank you for your long list of reasons why you selected Rose thats just what we want with this thread, now someone can send you a response to your reasoning and say why they disagree with you and start a big fricking arguement GOD DANMIT! JUST VOTES PLEASE!

    0
  • #399943
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    And btw Scarecrow thank you for your long list of reasons why you selected Rose thats just what we want with this thread, now someone can send you a response to your reasoning and say why they disagree with you and start a big fricking arguement GOD DANMIT! JUST VOTES PLEASE!

    0
  • #399957
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    And btw Scarecrow thank you for your long list of reasons why you selected Rose thats just what we want with this thread, now someone can send you a response to your reasoning and say why they disagree with you and start a big fricking arguement GOD DANMIT! JUST VOTES PLEASE!

    0
  • #399946
    AvatarAvatar
    Tyrober
    Participant

    Westbrook

    0
  • #399961
    AvatarAvatar
    Tyrober
    Participant

    Westbrook

    0
  • #399954
    AvatarAvatar
    Cardinal_Fan
    Participant

    Obviously Rose, he just a more complete player at this point, better jump shooter and better playmaker, give Westbrook the edge defensively.

    0
  • #399970
    AvatarAvatar
    Cardinal_Fan
    Participant

    Obviously Rose, he just a more complete player at this point, better jump shooter and better playmaker, give Westbrook the edge defensively.

    0
  • #399952
    AvatarAvatar
    RUDEBOY_
    Participant

    Madame Speaker..

    I RUDEBOY of Orlando, Florida ..
    But Mississippi Born…

    Cast my VOTE for Derrick Rose…

    0
  • #399968
    AvatarAvatar
    RUDEBOY_
    Participant

    Madame Speaker..

    I RUDEBOY of Orlando, Florida ..
    But Mississippi Born…

    Cast my VOTE for Derrick Rose…

    0
  • #399956
    AvatarAvatar
    Tyrober
    Participant

    i vote Westbrook simply because I am a biased Thunder fan buts heres how i look at it. Westbrook is a championship piece and Rose is a championship player

    0
  • #399972
    AvatarAvatar
    Tyrober
    Participant

    i vote Westbrook simply because I am a biased Thunder fan buts heres how i look at it. Westbrook is a championship piece and Rose is a championship player

    0
  • #399960
    AvatarAvatar
    doubledribbler
    Participant

    ROSE.

    0
  • #399976
    AvatarAvatar
    doubledribbler
    Participant

    ROSE.

    0
  • #399964
    AvatarAvatar
    Pureshooter
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #399980
    AvatarAvatar
    Pureshooter
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #399967
    AvatarAvatar
    jas225
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #399984
    AvatarAvatar
    jas225
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #399973
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    Can I think this through? It’s a realllllllllly tough choice for me, man…(wink, wink) Both guys are good… zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz… who are you kidding? I’m freakin’ marcusfizer21! A Bull addict… Of course I’m going with mah boy Derrick Rose…LOL

    0
  • #399990
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    Can I think this through? It’s a realllllllllly tough choice for me, man…(wink, wink) Both guys are good… zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz… who are you kidding? I’m freakin’ marcusfizer21! A Bull addict… Of course I’m going with mah boy Derrick Rose…LOL

    0
  • #399975
    AvatarAvatar
    Platypus
    Participant

    i’m picking the number 1 option over the 2nd option

    0
  • #399992
    AvatarAvatar
    Platypus
    Participant

    i’m picking the number 1 option over the 2nd option

    0
  • #399977
    AvatarAvatar
    Hale
    Participant

    Rose.

    0
  • #399994
    AvatarAvatar
    Hale
    Participant

    Rose.

    0
  • #399979
    AvatarAvatar
    Platypus
    Participant

    10 – Rose

    4 – Westbrook

    0
  • #399996
    AvatarAvatar
    Platypus
    Participant

    10 – Rose

    4 – Westbrook

    0
  • #399983
    AvatarAvatar
    Brace94
    Participant

    Rosebrook.

    0
  • #399999
    AvatarAvatar
    Brace94
    Participant

    Rosebrook.

    0
  • #399988
    AvatarAvatar
    joecheck88
    Participant

    rose.

    lets stop the voting before it gets out of hand, lol.

    no doubt westbrook is a beast but rose carries his team come playoff time.

    0
  • #400003
    AvatarAvatar
    joecheck88
    Participant

    rose.

    lets stop the voting before it gets out of hand, lol.

    no doubt westbrook is a beast but rose carries his team come playoff time.

    0
  • #399995
    AvatarAvatar
    tigers04
    Participant

    I’m a memphis tiger fan and have been following and routing for okc come playoff time(bc my knicks were no where around) so its tough to pick bc I like both..but I think rose is better now and will be in thr future

    But I also think westbrook will be a gem as well

    0
  • #400011
    AvatarAvatar
    tigers04
    Participant

    I’m a memphis tiger fan and have been following and routing for okc come playoff time(bc my knicks were no where around) so its tough to pick bc I like both..but I think rose is better now and will be in thr future

    But I also think westbrook will be a gem as well

    0
  • #400000
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    @rosebrook… it’s like answering true or false with TRALSE…lol

    0
  • #400015
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    @rosebrook… it’s like answering true or false with TRALSE…lol

    0
  • #400006
    AvatarAvatar
    Cardinal_Fan
    Participant

    Westbrook is a good player an will have a really good career…..but he is still learning the point guard position when u can say D.Rose was born to play the position. He still lacks a solid jumpshot, also watching some Thunder games he was trying to be the man at the end of games taking the ball out of the franchise players hands. He is a combo guard at best at this point. With that said he is a sick athelete, an absolute beast on defense and i think playing behind Billups and Rose on the olympic team will help him get a feel for what a point guard needs 2 do to be successful in the league. Hands down Derrick Rose is better, but Westbrook is a stud!!!!!

    0
  • #400021
    AvatarAvatar
    Cardinal_Fan
    Participant

    Westbrook is a good player an will have a really good career…..but he is still learning the point guard position when u can say D.Rose was born to play the position. He still lacks a solid jumpshot, also watching some Thunder games he was trying to be the man at the end of games taking the ball out of the franchise players hands. He is a combo guard at best at this point. With that said he is a sick athelete, an absolute beast on defense and i think playing behind Billups and Rose on the olympic team will help him get a feel for what a point guard needs 2 do to be successful in the league. Hands down Derrick Rose is better, but Westbrook is a stud!!!!!

    0
  • #400014
    AvatarAvatar
    Jlv2010

    Westbrook. All day, any day.

    0
  • #400029
    AvatarAvatar
    Jlv2010

    Westbrook. All day, any day.

    0
  • #400024
    AvatarAvatar
    Anton123
    Participant

    It was pretty obvious that Rose would win

    0
  • #400039
    AvatarAvatar
    Anton123
    Participant

    It was pretty obvious that Rose would win

    0
  • #400034
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    RookWestbrook. Gotta go with better overall and not popularity. Better playmaker defense rebounder

    0
  • #400050
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    RookWestbrook. Gotta go with better overall and not popularity. Better playmaker defense rebounder

    0
  • #400035
    AvatarAvatar
    LawDeeZee
    Participant

    I second that rosebrook vote

    0
  • #400052
    AvatarAvatar
    LawDeeZee
    Participant

    I second that rosebrook vote

    0
  • #400051
    AvatarAvatar
    gainsey15
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400068
    AvatarAvatar
    gainsey15
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400075
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. Jewboy
    Participant

    everybody who’s saying that russel westbrook is a worse shooter please give a reason why you think that. through their first two years they have the same %(westbrook-249, rose-242), and during these USA games westbrook was much better (43-28) and also, i think westbrook has better form
    so next time at least use something right when arguing

    0
  • #400092
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. Jewboy
    Participant

    everybody who’s saying that russel westbrook is a worse shooter please give a reason why you think that. through their first two years they have the same %(westbrook-249, rose-242), and during these USA games westbrook was much better (43-28) and also, i think westbrook has better form
    so next time at least use something right when arguing

    0
  • #400083
    AvatarAvatar
    ghettosermon
    Participant

    It depends on the situation. If I need a #2 or #1 guy who is to be relied upon heavily on scoring than I take Rose. But if I am a team with pieces there and I need a point who will facilitate, play defense, and run the break I’m taking Westbrook. It’s kind of like the Rose vs Rondo argument. Rondo is a monster in Boston but if he were on Chicago where he has no perimeter shooters and he has to be a scoring threat, Rondo wouldn’t be half the player Rose is in Chi-town. This is like arguing Frank Gore vs Steven Jackson.

    0
  • #400100
    AvatarAvatar
    ghettosermon
    Participant

    It depends on the situation. If I need a #2 or #1 guy who is to be relied upon heavily on scoring than I take Rose. But if I am a team with pieces there and I need a point who will facilitate, play defense, and run the break I’m taking Westbrook. It’s kind of like the Rose vs Rondo argument. Rondo is a monster in Boston but if he were on Chicago where he has no perimeter shooters and he has to be a scoring threat, Rondo wouldn’t be half the player Rose is in Chi-town. This is like arguing Frank Gore vs Steven Jackson.

    0
  • #400095
    AvatarAvatar
    sc0rebuckets11
    Participant

    westbrook.

    0
  • #400112
    AvatarAvatar
    sc0rebuckets11
    Participant

    westbrook.

    0
  • #400097
    AvatarAvatar
    JNixon
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400114
    AvatarAvatar
    JNixon
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400128
    AvatarAvatar
    IndianaBasketball
    Participant

    I love Westbrook’s defense, rebounding, toughness and athleticism, but I’m going with Rose. Everybody is going off of what happened in FIBA right now, but once the regular season comes around… Rose will squash doubts. NBA isn’t FIBA.

    0
  • #400143
    AvatarAvatar
    IndianaBasketball
    Participant

    I love Westbrook’s defense, rebounding, toughness and athleticism, but I’m going with Rose. Everybody is going off of what happened in FIBA right now, but once the regular season comes around… Rose will squash doubts. NBA isn’t FIBA.

    0
  • #400156
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    Rose- 18
    Westbrook- 8

    This discussion is over.

    0
  • #400171
    AvatarAvatar
    OhCanada-
    Participant

    Rose- 18
    Westbrook- 8

    This discussion is over.

    0
  • #400226
    AvatarAvatar
    Jlv2010

    Westbrook > Rose

    0
  • #400242
    AvatarAvatar
    Jlv2010

    Westbrook > Rose

    0
  • #400232
    AvatarAvatar
    WizardofOz
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400248
    AvatarAvatar
    WizardofOz
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400241
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    EVeryone knows I’ve been saying Westbrook only thing rose has shown to be better at in the regular season is scoring. Westbrook plays wayyyyyyyy better defense. Better rebounder. Better assists. Tougher more aggressive. What more you want. Also he’s close to rose scoring wise while being a second option. I don’t wanna hear the excuse of “if he had this teammate or that” he doesn’t have this or that teammate so stop with the ifs and use the facts. Y’all use facts for other debates so stick to facts for this one!!!!

    0
  • #400258
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    EVeryone knows I’ve been saying Westbrook only thing rose has shown to be better at in the regular season is scoring. Westbrook plays wayyyyyyyy better defense. Better rebounder. Better assists. Tougher more aggressive. What more you want. Also he’s close to rose scoring wise while being a second option. I don’t wanna hear the excuse of “if he had this teammate or that” he doesn’t have this or that teammate so stop with the ifs and use the facts. Y’all use facts for other debates so stick to facts for this one!!!!

    0
  • #400239
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. 19134
    Participant

    Well I wonder what Coach K thinks about this argument because Westbrook certainly had a better tournament then Rose. In the head to head stat comparisons
    http://turkey2010.fiba.com/pages/eng/fe/10/fwcm/player/p/eid/4728/pid/61798/rid//sid/4728/tid/379/profile.html
    It’s interesting to see the Westbrook was able to put up better numbers, more points, and rebounds, in less minutes then Rose.

    0
  • #400256
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. 19134
    Participant

    Well I wonder what Coach K thinks about this argument because Westbrook certainly had a better tournament then Rose. In the head to head stat comparisons
    http://turkey2010.fiba.com/pages/eng/fe/10/fwcm/player/p/eid/4728/pid/61798/rid//sid/4728/tid/379/profile.html
    It’s interesting to see the Westbrook was able to put up better numbers, more points, and rebounds, in less minutes then Rose.

    0
  • #400245
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. 19134
    Participant

    And look at it this way, what would Rose’s numbers look like on OKC. I think they would look similar to Westbrooks, but only less rebounds, but Rose seems like he would be taking shots away from Durant and ruin team chemistry that way. Westbrook on the Bulls would no doubt get around 20 points per game because he averaged 17 on a team with Durant…

    0
  • #400262
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. 19134
    Participant

    And look at it this way, what would Rose’s numbers look like on OKC. I think they would look similar to Westbrooks, but only less rebounds, but Rose seems like he would be taking shots away from Durant and ruin team chemistry that way. Westbrook on the Bulls would no doubt get around 20 points per game because he averaged 17 on a team with Durant…

    0
  • #400257
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    Can’t go by what if

    I’m very curious as to what everyone critera is when decideung if one player is better then another

    it should be offense. Defense. Rebounding. And passing when dealing with a point guard. When it’s close you go with specifics. Westbrook wins because the gap
    between both of there defense is alot wider then the gap between both of there offense

    If you take into account Westbrook has durant which gives him moreopen looks on offense then you also have to take into account rose gets as many looks as he want and gets to shoot alot more

    bosh gets more looks then gasol yet gasol is ranked head of h even though he’s a second option because he’s better overall

    0
  • #400274
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    Can’t go by what if

    I’m very curious as to what everyone critera is when decideung if one player is better then another

    it should be offense. Defense. Rebounding. And passing when dealing with a point guard. When it’s close you go with specifics. Westbrook wins because the gap
    between both of there defense is alot wider then the gap between both of there offense

    If you take into account Westbrook has durant which gives him moreopen looks on offense then you also have to take into account rose gets as many looks as he want and gets to shoot alot more

    bosh gets more looks then gasol yet gasol is ranked head of h even though he’s a second option because he’s better overall

    0
  • #400462
    AvatarAvatar
    dolla130
    Participant

    Rose
    stanford hoops how can u possibly say westbrook is a better passer forget the avg it helps when you have the leading scorer in the NBA no not all of his assist come from durant but there because of durant if u get what im saying durant draws so much attention that it frees up everyone on the thunder and he only avg 2 more assists a game and all that ohh rose takes more shots he also shoots a way way better FG % then a guy who takes a lot more open looks and forget the oylmpics during what really matters the nba regular season and playoffs thus far rose has outplayed westbrook and durant my point being rose is a number 1 option and franchise guy and westbrook is a number 2 or three depending on the team and forget stats this is something we know thats like saying deng is better then carmelo because he avgs more rebs, and is a better defender

    0
  • #400477
    AvatarAvatar
    dolla130
    Participant

    Rose
    stanford hoops how can u possibly say westbrook is a better passer forget the avg it helps when you have the leading scorer in the NBA no not all of his assist come from durant but there because of durant if u get what im saying durant draws so much attention that it frees up everyone on the thunder and he only avg 2 more assists a game and all that ohh rose takes more shots he also shoots a way way better FG % then a guy who takes a lot more open looks and forget the oylmpics during what really matters the nba regular season and playoffs thus far rose has outplayed westbrook and durant my point being rose is a number 1 option and franchise guy and westbrook is a number 2 or three depending on the team and forget stats this is something we know thats like saying deng is better then carmelo because he avgs more rebs, and is a better defender

    0
  • #400494
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    Ben girdan use to draw alot of defenders and he was a very good shooter yet rose didn’t get alot of assist

    Andre miller used yo get alot of assist with less talent then rose

    like I said before Westbrook fans can say Westbrook is the better scorer because he has to share the offense with durant but rise doesn’t

    When I compare players I look at every thing not just offense. Rose defense is a good step below average. Westbrook is a very good deegender. Everything else can either be argued or one player has a little lead. The defense outs Westbrook over the top for me because it’s not even close. You can argue all day about almost anything else. This is one thing that used to put Kobe over tmac and Vince. Defense

    0
  • #400509
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    Ben girdan use to draw alot of defenders and he was a very good shooter yet rose didn’t get alot of assist

    Andre miller used yo get alot of assist with less talent then rose

    like I said before Westbrook fans can say Westbrook is the better scorer because he has to share the offense with durant but rise doesn’t

    When I compare players I look at every thing not just offense. Rose defense is a good step below average. Westbrook is a very good deegender. Everything else can either be argued or one player has a little lead. The defense outs Westbrook over the top for me because it’s not even close. You can argue all day about almost anything else. This is one thing that used to put Kobe over tmac and Vince. Defense

    0
  • #400534
    AvatarAvatar
    dolla130
    Participant

    when Tmac was healthy before all the injuries like 2002 to 06 Mcgrady was IMO a way better player then kobe bryant scorer playmaker rebounder and defender kobe just became an elite defender in like 2008
    and westbrook fans cant say that because of the percentages he shoots poor from the three and and feild and forget roses avg for the season look at his avgs from jan on i think he avg almost 25ppg and almost 7 assists and the bulls won 7 in a row against some of the top teams in the west and dominating the thunder westbrook would not be able to do that if the rolls were reversed its fact he just isnt that good of an offensive player yeah his drives to the hoop are cute but thats about it and an occasional jump shot from here and there for people to say the gap between the 2 in scoring is close are insane roses basketball IQ is way higher then westbrooks also and thats how i know rose is and will be the better player and will have more success then he already does now

    0
  • #400549
    AvatarAvatar
    dolla130
    Participant

    when Tmac was healthy before all the injuries like 2002 to 06 Mcgrady was IMO a way better player then kobe bryant scorer playmaker rebounder and defender kobe just became an elite defender in like 2008
    and westbrook fans cant say that because of the percentages he shoots poor from the three and and feild and forget roses avg for the season look at his avgs from jan on i think he avg almost 25ppg and almost 7 assists and the bulls won 7 in a row against some of the top teams in the west and dominating the thunder westbrook would not be able to do that if the rolls were reversed its fact he just isnt that good of an offensive player yeah his drives to the hoop are cute but thats about it and an occasional jump shot from here and there for people to say the gap between the 2 in scoring is close are insane roses basketball IQ is way higher then westbrooks also and thats how i know rose is and will be the better player and will have more success then he already does now

    0
  • #400550
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    First. You have no idea What Westbrook would do if the roles were reversed and you have to take in account a whole season not just half. Healthy or hurt. If you are playing then it counts. Westbrook doesn’t shoot well and shoots worst then rose but rose is a below average shooter so it’s not like there’s a great big difference there

    What proof shows rose has a better basketball iq??? Please prove that

    So since every game played is included. How many more points dis rose average than Westbrook

    since we can only go by who they play for we can only go by what they average scoring wise

    I notice you didn’t mention how bad rose is on defense compared to Westbrook. Defense is as important as offense in case you forgot

    0
  • #400565
    AvatarAvatar
    stanford hoops

    First. You have no idea What Westbrook would do if the roles were reversed and you have to take in account a whole season not just half. Healthy or hurt. If you are playing then it counts. Westbrook doesn’t shoot well and shoots worst then rose but rose is a below average shooter so it’s not like there’s a great big difference there

    What proof shows rose has a better basketball iq??? Please prove that

    So since every game played is included. How many more points dis rose average than Westbrook

    since we can only go by who they play for we can only go by what they average scoring wise

    I notice you didn’t mention how bad rose is on defense compared to Westbrook. Defense is as important as offense in case you forgot

    0
  • #400572
    AvatarAvatar
    dolla130
    Participant

    rose avg 4 more ppg then westbrook and almost 49% from the field opposed to 41% and its pretty obvious westbrook is a better defender i will never dispute that thats why its pointless to mention it and as far as basketball IQ the plays he makes during the games shot selection and variety also the we he runs his team and controls the pace of the game, westbrook is always out of control and durant is the clear leader and floor general on the team westbrook just brings the ball up.

    en gordan use to draw alot of defenders and he was a very good shooter yet rose didn’t get alot of assist

    Andre miller used yo get alot of assist with less talent then rose

    yeah thats true but he avg more apg then westbrook and when has andre miller ever played with less talent please tell me

    0
  • #400587
    AvatarAvatar
    dolla130
    Participant

    rose avg 4 more ppg then westbrook and almost 49% from the field opposed to 41% and its pretty obvious westbrook is a better defender i will never dispute that thats why its pointless to mention it and as far as basketball IQ the plays he makes during the games shot selection and variety also the we he runs his team and controls the pace of the game, westbrook is always out of control and durant is the clear leader and floor general on the team westbrook just brings the ball up.

    en gordan use to draw alot of defenders and he was a very good shooter yet rose didn’t get alot of assist

    Andre miller used yo get alot of assist with less talent then rose

    yeah thats true but he avg more apg then westbrook and when has andre miller ever played with less talent please tell me

    0
  • #400663
    AvatarAvatar
    IndianaBasketball
    Participant

    “Westbrook doesn’t shoot well and shoots worst then rose but rose is a below average shooter so it’s not like there’s a great big difference there”

    You can’t really be serious with that statement… Rose’s mid-range game is A LOT better than Westbrook’s and you know it. Westbrook shot less than 40% as a rookie. Shot less than 42% as a soph. Rose on the other hand shot over 47% as a rookie and over 48% as a soph…

    Rose is much better on the offensive end. He plays more under control and with much better pace. Westbrook plays at one speed, is out of control and doesn’t make good decisions. You can’t just go off of FIBA (different style of game) and ignore what Rose did last season.

    Westbrook is light years ahead of Rose at the defensive end, but that’s the only edge he has in my opinion.

    0
  • #400676
    AvatarAvatar
    IndianaBasketball
    Participant

    “Westbrook doesn’t shoot well and shoots worst then rose but rose is a below average shooter so it’s not like there’s a great big difference there”

    You can’t really be serious with that statement… Rose’s mid-range game is A LOT better than Westbrook’s and you know it. Westbrook shot less than 40% as a rookie. Shot less than 42% as a soph. Rose on the other hand shot over 47% as a rookie and over 48% as a soph…

    Rose is much better on the offensive end. He plays more under control and with much better pace. Westbrook plays at one speed, is out of control and doesn’t make good decisions. You can’t just go off of FIBA (different style of game) and ignore what Rose did last season.

    Westbrook is light years ahead of Rose at the defensive end, but that’s the only edge he has in my opinion.

    0
  • #400667
    AvatarAvatar
    andxxx
    Participant

    but DRose

    0
  • #400680
    AvatarAvatar
    andxxx
    Participant

    but DRose

    0
  • #400677
    AvatarAvatar
    scoutguru
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400690
    AvatarAvatar
    scoutguru
    Participant

    Rose

    0
  • #400716
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    ill go with rose as i have all along. But this topic doesnt actually end anything. THye still are very early in their careers and it is close enough that im sure it will come up again.

    0
  • #400730
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    ill go with rose as i have all along. But this topic doesnt actually end anything. THye still are very early in their careers and it is close enough that im sure it will come up again.

    0
  • #400739
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    it’s been like 10 years buddy… how’s life? where have you been all these years?LOL

    0
  • #400752
    marcusfizer21marcusfizer21
    marcusfizer21
    Participant

    it’s been like 10 years buddy… how’s life? where have you been all these years?LOL

    0
  • #400747
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    yeah, been gone for a minute. Life is great. You been holding it down around here fizer keeping everyone in line?

    0
  • #400760
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    yeah, been gone for a minute. Life is great. You been holding it down around here fizer keeping everyone in line?

    0
  • #400767
    AvatarAvatar
    Mkadoza
    Participant

    Rose. I’m going to be subscribing to synergy sports to start my own sports analysis site, so I will be happy to show you the numbers supporting how much more advanced Rose is as a scorer. He shot 49% from the field for 20.8 as the first option and primary ball handler.

    0
  • #400780
    AvatarAvatar
    Mkadoza
    Participant

    Rose. I’m going to be subscribing to synergy sports to start my own sports analysis site, so I will be happy to show you the numbers supporting how much more advanced Rose is as a scorer. He shot 49% from the field for 20.8 as the first option and primary ball handler.

    0
  • #400775
    AvatarAvatar
    The Scare Crow Returns
    Participant

    Westbrook fans are mad as hell about it too…

    0
  • #400788
    AvatarAvatar
    The Scare Crow Returns
    Participant

    Westbrook fans are mad as hell about it too…

    0
  • #400863
    AvatarAvatar
    billyk
    Participant

    “6:25: A 3 from Turkey and Rose’s offensive foul gets the crowd involved again. I’m not making too much out of Rose’s lackluster WC performance: The international game is geared toward Stockton-type guards who can shoot 3s and run pick-and-rolls. Rose never seemed comfortable. In fact, guys whose games are geared toward NBA rules (beating guys off the dribble on clearouts, getting every call any time there’s contact) always have the same look on their faces that Kevin Kolb did during Sunday’s Philly-Green Bay game before he got knocked out. Just a bad fit and we didn’t have a better option until Westbrook blossomed. I can’t hold it against him.” – Bill Simmons makes a good point lol…

    0
  • #400877
    AvatarAvatar
    billyk
    Participant

    “6:25: A 3 from Turkey and Rose’s offensive foul gets the crowd involved again. I’m not making too much out of Rose’s lackluster WC performance: The international game is geared toward Stockton-type guards who can shoot 3s and run pick-and-rolls. Rose never seemed comfortable. In fact, guys whose games are geared toward NBA rules (beating guys off the dribble on clearouts, getting every call any time there’s contact) always have the same look on their faces that Kevin Kolb did during Sunday’s Philly-Green Bay game before he got knocked out. Just a bad fit and we didn’t have a better option until Westbrook blossomed. I can’t hold it against him.” – Bill Simmons makes a good point lol…

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login