share

Duncan-Garnett swap

UNCbasketballbum
UNCbasketballbum's picture
Registered User
Joined: 10/05/2011
Posts: 948
Points: 1884
Offline
Duncan-Garnett swap

I was thinking today about Tim Duncan and Kevin Garne. Both are the same age and both dominated during the same time, about 1999-2007. What if they had switched teams? Would Garnett have won 4 championships with the Spurs cast? Would Tim Duncan be a hall of famer and the greatest power forward of all time with the T-wolves cast? Thoughts?


dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Garnett would of won 0 Duncan

Garnett would of won 0 Duncan 4: 3 with Boston one with Minny

UNCbasketballbum
UNCbasketballbum's picture
Registered User
Joined: 10/05/2011
Posts: 948
Points: 1884
Offline
once you hit -500 points do

once you hit -500 points do you think that maybe, just maybe, you should change your basketball outlook?

NYK2010
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 2462
Points: 1498
Offline
Duncan domainted from

Duncan domainted from 1997-2008. KG not sure when but probably 99-2009 till the big injury.

KG didn't do enough on offense to be as good as Duncan.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Garnett had better players

Garnett had better players around him over his career, Duncan pretty much won 99 and 2003 by himself

Brandon>johnson

Wally>jackson

Gugliotta>Elliot

Smith=Robinson

Cassell>parker

Sprewell>Finley

young rasho> old rasho

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Pierce>Ginobili Allen>Parker

Pierce>Ginobili

Allen>Parker

Posey>Barry

Sheed>Blair

Perkins>Nazi

Scalabrine>Mengke Bateer

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
if Popovich coached MInny I

if Popovich coached MInny I would give Duncan 8 titles and Garnett 0, if coaches stayed the same 4 Duncan maybe 1 for Garnett in 2007 if the course of history does not change the the butterfly effect might make the Warriors not upset Dallas in the first round and a Duncan led Spurs team wanted no part of Dallas that year but GS was a bad matchup for them, so obviously a Garnett led SPurs team would of had almost no shot vs. Dallas

Nbanflguy
Nbanflguy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/15/2009
Posts: 1824
Points: 8204
Offline
KG would have won at least 1

KG would have won at least 1 ring with the spurs.

DipoTime
DipoTime's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/09/2008
Posts: 366
Points: 1188
Offline
FG 49.9%, 3pt FG 28.3%, FT

FG 49.9%, 3pt FG 28.3%, FT 79.0%, ORB 2.4, AST 4.0, and PTS 19.3

FG 50.7% 3pt FG 17.7%, FT 68.8%, ORB 3.0, AST 3.1, and PTS 20.3

Those are the two players career offensive numbers. Whose is whose? They are pretty similar to say KG couldn't do enough to be as good offensively.

aamir543
aamir543's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/11/2009
Posts: 5063
Points: 5542
Offline
Ok look, in '99, Duncan

Ok look, in '99, Duncan carried them, not entirely alone because Robinson was still good for 16 and 10, however he did do it sort of on his own, but that would be the only tittle year if any I would take away from Garnett if they were switched, the Celtics would've had another run in them if KG didn't go down in 09, 10 if Perk didn't go down, and 11 if Perk wasn't traded, but KG just didn't have a good supporting cast in Minny, those teams were pretty bad around KG other than that one Cassell Sprewell year.

DipoTime
DipoTime's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/09/2008
Posts: 366
Points: 1188
Offline
What's crazy is that they

What's crazy is that they have both averaged 7.8 made field goals per 15.5 attempts over their career..

aamir543
aamir543's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/11/2009
Posts: 5063
Points: 5542
Offline
@srbadger, Garnett was a good

@srbadger, Garnett was a good offensive guy, but he was never the extremely skilled post magican that Duncan was, however Garnett to an extent was a play maker, so that makes us for that, but Duncan is hands down the more skilled and reliable option especially in the post.

And remember, Garnett might be the better defensive player between the two, but if Garnett is a 10 on a scale of 1-10, than Duncan was a 9.5, he was the anchor of those defenses for all of those Spurs' tittles, a menace protecting the rim.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
It is pretty obvious Duncan

It is pretty obvious Duncan would of got 3 in Boston it would of been a threepeat 08-10, Boston only lost in 09 because of Garnetts injurt and '10 because of Perkins injury and Duncan is more of a natural 5 so he would of stepped in better although the gap in ability between Duncan and Garnett is less now thatn in their prime but just form a matchup perspective I think Boston would of won game 7 if they had not already won it in 6/ And they would of won in 2011 if Rondo did not get hurt. So yes it is true barring injury Garnett would of won 3 or 4 titles in Boston. Ok the one year I forgot about was 2000 the year Duncan missed the playoffs maybe an outside chance a Garnett Spurs team could of won then but like 26% chance maybe.

DipoTime
DipoTime's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/09/2008
Posts: 366
Points: 1188
Offline
People forget that Duncan

People forget that Duncan almost teamed up with T-Mac and Grant hill in Orlando. I think he would have for sure if he was in Minnesota. And I think Pops alone would get KG at least the same amount of rings if not more than Duncan. I think more of the success comes from him, the supporting cast, and the organization as a whole than Duncan himself. He is definitely good enough to carry a team and get one or two on his own but I think the spurs as a whole deserve more credit.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Numbers are a little

Numbers are a little overrated because Duncan could demand a double team more than Garnett and get the defense to scramble, plus he was a better defensive player by a mile even though KG was one of the top 5 defenders in the NBA Duncan was unreal defensively.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
aamir there is no chance the

aamir there is no chance the 2003 Spurs could of won with Garnett, Ginobili and Parker may have been on that team but they were average NBA players at that time even though they became good later on.

DipoTime
DipoTime's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/09/2008
Posts: 366
Points: 1188
Offline
@aamir543

Hey I agree that Duncan was a monster offensively. I mean how many guys can get you 43 from banking in 15 footers all game lol he literally could do it all on both ends. I just think ppl forget how good Garnett was as an all around player and not just a defensive-oriented player.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
This guy asks would Tim

This guy asks would Tim Duncan still be a hall of famer and I am the one who gets negged lol see how much points mean to anyone that has a clue lol

UNCbasketballbum
UNCbasketballbum's picture
Registered User
Joined: 10/05/2011
Posts: 948
Points: 1884
Offline
yeah, Garnet never got any

yeah, Garnet never got any help in Minny, thank Kevin Mchale for basically ruining the career of one of the greatest players of all time. The only help KG ever got was the 2004 team with Spree, Cassell, Trenton Hassell and "the mayor," Fred Hoiberg. Perhaps if Marbury hadn't demanded a trade out of Minny, KG and Starbury could've had something special going on there.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Tim Duncan is about the 8th

Tim Duncan is about the 8th best player in history and that has nothing to do with winning titles just his ability

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Bull&$#%#&@! 2002

Bull&$#%#&@! 2002 Timberwolves supporting cast better than any team Duncan ever played on, that is 3 all stars and Joe Smith a &$#%#&@! legend

1
Kevin Garnett
25
81
81
39.2
8.1
17.3
.470
0.5
1.4
.319
4.4
5.5
.801
3.0
9.1
12.1
5.2
1.2
1.6
2.8
2.3
21.2

2
Wally Szczerbiak
24
82
82
38.0
7.4
14.6
.508
1.1
2.3
.455
2.8
3.3
.831
1.5
3.3
4.8
3.1
0.8
0.3
2.2
2.3
18.7

3
Chauncey Billups
25
82
54
28.7
4.2
10.0
.423
1.5
3.8
.394
2.5
2.9
.885
0.4
2.3
2.8
5.5
0.8
0.2
1.7
2.1
12.5

4
Terrell Brandon
31
32
28
30.1
4.8
11.4
.425
0.1
0.7
.174
2.6
2.6
.988
0.5
2.4
2.9
8.3
1.6
0.2
1.3
1.5
12.4

5
Joe Smith
26
72
63
26.7
4.1
8.1
.511
0.0
0.0
.667
2.4
2.9
.830
2.1
4.2
6.3
1.1
0.5
0.8
1.2
3.5
10.7

6
Anthony Peeler
32
82
0
25.1
3.5
8.3
.421
1.4
3.5
.392
0.6
0.7
.862
0.5
2.1
2.5
2.2
0.7
0.1
0.9
1.7
9.0

7
Rasho Nesterovic
25
82
82
27.0
4.0
8.0
.493
0.0
0.0
.000
0.5
0.9
.549
2.4
4.1
6.5
0.9
0.5
1.3
1.1
3.2
8.4

8
Gary Trent
27
64
10
17.8
3.0
6.0
.507
0.0
0.0
.000
1.4
2.3
.639
1.6
2.6
4.2
0.9
0.

Marc Jackson

3
0.4
0.9
2.5
7.5

9

27
22
0
14.8
1.7
4.5
.384
0.0
0.0
.000
1.2
1.5
.813
1.4
2.5
3.9
0.3
0.3

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
Duncan has always had the

Duncan has always had the team since coming in the NBA. If roles were reverse Garnet would have won just as many championships or more.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Although Marbury kind of

Although Marbury kind of exposed as a fraud overall talent level was down at the time he was an all star:

KG played wiht Marbury/Brandon/Smith all on same team and

marbury/Gugliotta

&$#%#&@! Duncan probably would of won a lot more than 1 title in MInny what was I thinking

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
what are you talking about

what are you talking about Garnett has had like 7-8 different supporting casts with more talent than duncan has ever had, though Popovich is a big factor of course in the Spurs success, but lets face facts Popovich will not even consider coaching another game in the NBA after Duncan retires, I leave nbadraft.net forun forever if Duncan retires and Popovich keeps coaching.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
This guy thinks a washed up

This guy thinks a washed up Cassell and Spree and Hassell Hoiberg were better than Marbury and Gugliotta/Brandon, Billups, Szczerbiak Smith lol he does not even know MInny's best team. Those team did better in the playoffs because Garnett was a leader then. Duncan and marbury would not of clashed Marbury and Szczerbiak would of bowed down to Duncan instead of clashing and wanting it to be their team and having bad team chemistry, one of the biggest reasons for those talented Minny teams around the turn of the millenium losing was chemistry and not talent, and bottomline Tim Duncan was more mature and a better player and would not allow that to happen.

WizKid
WizKid's picture
Registered User
Joined: 01/20/2010
Posts: 2023
Points: 4399
Offline
Nope KG would have never put

Nope KG would have never put up that triple dub Duncan did in the finals. KG wasn't a big time performer in crunch time like Duncan.

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
Garnet and Marbury clashed ?

Garnet and Marbury clashed ? I remember Marbury himself saying he just wanted to leave the city because he hated the cold. Then KG disliked him afterwards for leaving.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Duncan should of had a

Duncan should of had a quadruple double against the Nets he had 8 blocks credited but it should of been 10 true my tv was only 20 inches or so back then and low definition but I'm pretty sure he had 10 blocks in 2003 against NJ.

NYK2010
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 2462
Points: 1498
Offline
8 titles for Minny you must

8 titles for Minny you must be out your mind.

Even MJ never won that and yes never would have if he played in 94 and 95 since no one was stopping Olajuwon in

95.

KG wasn't as clutch as Duncan he couldn't get out of the 1st round for yrs and Pierce was the Finals MVP in 2008 for a reason.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
like I said both him and even

like I said both him and even Wally wanted to be the #1 offensive option, do a search you will see stuff about Westbrook Durant possibly being KG Marbury 2.0

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
I said 8 titles overall that

I said 8 titles overall that would of been 5 in Minny and 3 in Boston I meant if he played with Garnett's rosters every year.

chocboywndr
chocboywndr's picture
Registered User
Joined: 03/27/2012
Posts: 204
Points: 376
Offline
Its pretty well known that

Its pretty well known that Minnesota teams with Garnett were pretty poor. There was even that Joe smith debacle with picks. Garnett did everything for Minny he even brought the ball up when they got pressed. Duncan is a traditional power forward. If you surround him with same cast as Garnett He wins no championships in Minnesota

If you put Duncan in Boston it is possible they win but it was Garnetts fire and defensive ability they feed off. So I will give him same total 1 championship

Garnett with Robinson his first year I think they win. I also think san antonio would have built the same quality team around Garnett as I think they are best organization in league might have been different pieces but still great team. I also think pop is great coach so I give him 2 more chips.

Overall I think they were both great players although different. I do think that Minnesota never field a team close to most of SA except for year with spree and sam.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Jordan probably could of won

Jordan probably could of won the title in '99 if they brought everyone back but maybe he was suspended or hurt (rumors)

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Yeh they had Marbury,

Yeh they had Marbury, brandon, Billups none of those guys could dribble lol

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
Noting to really to do with

Not really to do with the main topic. I believe Ginobili is the Greatest international player ever to be in the NBA.

Nbanflguy
Nbanflguy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/15/2009
Posts: 1824
Points: 8204
Offline
Noting to really to do with

Noting to really to do with the main topic. I believe Ginobili is the Greatest international player ever to be in the NBA.

What about Dirk?

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
For Never that might be the

For Never that might be the worst post ever Hakeem is the best international player and best player ever

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Hakeem, Ewing, Duncan, Dirk,

Hakeem, Ewing, Duncan, Dirk, and Nash all clearly better than Manu

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
To me Dirk is second to him.

To me Dirk is second to him. Dirk has always been label soft until last year, I do understand way more pressure is on dirk being the focal point of the team.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
Ewing is form Jamaica they

Ewing is form Jamaica they have a bobsled team

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpX1vMDaCmA

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
I forgot those guys are

I forgot those guys are international. Yeah I would say The Dream is the greatest, then Manu, then Dirk, Ewing is 4th on my list of international players.

PulseGlazer
Registered User
Joined: 06/12/2011
Posts: 1281
Points: 1906
Offline
KG didn't play in the post

KG didn't play in the post nearly enough and that makes all the difference when comparing the two. KG was right there numbers-wise in every other case, but just a bit worse everywhere but maybe the glass.

DipoTime
DipoTime's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/09/2008
Posts: 366
Points: 1188
Offline
@dede21

He had the worst post ever? By international player it is commonly known that we mean going to the NBA straight from another country. Just because Hakeem was born in Nigeria doesn't mean he is considered an "international" player. Do you consider Kyrie Irving Steve Nash or even Tim Duncan to be international players? Bc they weren't born in the US. Hakeem went to Houston university and even competed in the 96 Olympics.. For the US!

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
yes I consider Tim Duncan and

yes I consider Tim Duncan and Nash international, Irving is different because his dad was a US citizen but he was born outside the country, Dominique Wilkins was born in France I do not consider him international same situation as Kyrie or Tebow

Nbanflguy
Nbanflguy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/15/2009
Posts: 1824
Points: 8204
Offline
For Never that might be the

For Never that might be the worst post ever Hakeem is the best international player and best player ever

Hakeem best player ever? No not at all.

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
Hahahah, My fault forget

Hahahah, My fault forget everything I said. I have to think about it some more forgot Duncan and Nash are international as well.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
I still think it is hard to

I still think it is hard to justify Manu over Dirk regardless, so Marc Gasol is american and his brother is international according to you lol?

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
I have thought Manu is better

I have thought Manu is better than Dirk, also have been the best current international player in the NBA for years now.

dede21
Registered User
Joined: 03/11/2012
Posts: 401
Points: -1250
Offline
badger what about Enes Kanter

badger what about Enes Kanter is he international or US according to you?, tricky one huh?

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
Who you asking me ?

Who you asking me ?

For_Never_Ever
For_Never_Ever's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/14/2011
Posts: 2980
Points: 3681
Offline
He talks like he isnt from

He talks like he isnt from around here. I think he is somewhere from europe.

RSS: Syndicate content