share

Best GM drafter

knicksfreak
knicksfreak's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 1409
Points: 244
Offline
Best GM drafter

I will probably lose 50 points for this but I think Isiah Thomas is one of the best drafters of all time. Whats everybody elses thoughts on who could be in the conversation.


Knicksboy34
Knicksboy34's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/07/2009
Posts: 2876
Points: -98
Offline
Agreed...he makes alot of

Agreed...he makes alot of Solid picks.

How about our Current Gm? Donnie Basketball makes some good picks.

d-grizzly
Registered User
Joined: 05/05/2009
Posts: 1511
Points: 635
Offline
i liked bulls

i liked how the bulls were put together. but outta sheer luck though...

fliptonn
Registered User
Joined: 06/08/2009
Posts: 544
Points: 232
Offline
kevin pitchard

the blazers gm. hes turned that whole team around from the jail blazers. hes basically drafted the whole team and everyone wants to know what the blazers are gunna do on draft night now. hes drafted the likes of...

roy
aldridge
oden
fernandez
batum
bayless
etc.

basically the whole team. and theyre potential contenders next year

nepaliman_7
Registered User
Joined: 12/06/2008
Posts: 103
Points: 61
Offline
the blazers gm didn't draft

the blazers gm didn't draft fernandez, roy, batum, bayless, or aldridge. he traded for them

mmichnowicz1
Registered User
Joined: 05/21/2009
Posts: 81
Points: 32
Offline
Blazers

they may have traded for them, but a draft day trade is almost like picking a player, and it should count for just as much, and in some cases more, because if your trading the lower rankings player for the higher one, and you get picks, and the lower one is better that is a great deal.

maravich44
Registered User
Joined: 06/02/2009
Posts: 432
Points: 242
Offline
Krause

Didn't take a genious to draft Jordan. Did to get Pippen at the time. Assembled and ruined best team of the 90's. Like him or hate him, Krause was the best and worst if that's possible.

Jerry West was great. Red Aurbach was best of all time!

Knicksboy34
Knicksboy34's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/07/2009
Posts: 2876
Points: -98
Offline
Kevin Pricthard?

No.

He takes the hot guy in the draft....He missed on KD and I think he takes Solid players not future all-star players

Knicksboy34
Knicksboy34's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/07/2009
Posts: 2876
Points: -98
Offline
Krause is a genius man...He

Krause is a genius man...He build the Bulls in the late 80's and by the 91 they won titles.

Then after MJ retired, He blew up and rebuilded the team again....

knicksfreak
knicksfreak's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 1409
Points: 244
Offline
Pritchard has also had alot

Pritchard has also had alot of high draft picks. Isiah makes alot of great picks with low first or second rounders.

d-grizzly
Registered User
Joined: 05/05/2009
Posts: 1511
Points: 635
Offline
no

i'm talking about the bulls now...

fliptonn
Registered User
Joined: 06/08/2009
Posts: 544
Points: 232
Offline
Kevin Pitchard

traded on draft day. everyone thought oden was money in that draft man you can blame him for Durant. all im saying is they were on a steady downward pace for a long time before he took control and turned them around specifically through the NBA draft.

DeRozanfan11
DeRozanfan11's picture
Registered User
Joined: 03/22/2009
Posts: 131
Points: 17
Offline
Kevin O'Connor is one of the

Kevin O'Connor is one of the best Malone, Stockton, and Williams.

knicksfreak
knicksfreak's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 1409
Points: 244
Offline
He made some good moves and

He made some good moves and made out like a bandit on draft day trades. But he still has had plenty of high draft picks. I think Isiah has done "more with less". Isiah is one of the worst traders ever too though. The knicks had Scott Layden then Isiah Thomas. Ouch.

maravich44
Registered User
Joined: 06/02/2009
Posts: 432
Points: 242
Offline
Bulls

Portland fleased the Bulls in the draft day deal they got Tyrus Thomas. Bulls should have had Aldrige or Roy. Bulls also got burned when Jay Williams (2nd pick in draft) had motorcycle accident after rookie year........and when they traded Brand.....and Artest........and when they wouldn't part with fringe player whose name escapes me to get rights to draft Wade. I could go on and on, but I'm getting depressed.

dwat4444
dwat4444's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/23/2009
Posts: 681
Points: 387
Offline
Bennett and rest of thunder owners

Durant was an easy pick but westbrook and green? those were some ballsy choices that really paid off.

fastdan
Registered User
Joined: 06/10/2009
Posts: 746
Points: 881
Offline
Sam Presti is the GM of

Sam Presti is the GM of OKC...he's pretty awesome, but he didn't draft Green..the celtics had already taken him then he did the trade with Ray Allen.

Ch13f23
Registered User
Joined: 05/31/2009
Posts: 94
Points: -335
Offline
TRAILBLAZERS

i think Kevin Pritchard is one of the best if not the best GM right now. just look at the picks, acquisition and trades he made especially during Draft night. Just look at the Portland team right now from the troubled talented Jailblazers to the young talented nucleus they have right now and they pretty look scary in the future.
And regarding about the pick up of Oden instead of Durant i think its still a good pick cause they have B.Roy as a go-to-guy during crunch time comes. While Oden gives them another cornerstone with Aldridge and Roy on their team for the future. Just imagine him(ODEN) Worst case Scenario: Oden becoming a solid defender just like Pryzbilla Portland team would still benefit from him cause they could win games without needing Oden to score. Best case Scenario: Oden becoming a dominant bigman in the game lets say David Robinson Stats at least then Portland is set to win at the very least 2 championship.

j1232e
Registered User
Joined: 05/26/2009
Posts: 1501
Points: 1144
Offline
o connor

only drafted williams. O connor was phillys gm before comming to utah.Hence is why utah and philly always trade with each other. horny. big fez. korver. If I am not mistaken i think he also traded the draft rights of nazr muhamad to philly also.

illinimanmark
Registered User
Joined: 04/15/2009
Posts: 65
Points: 26
Offline
I could be wrong but I

I could be wrong but I think Rod Thorn was the GM when Chicago drafted Jordan. And if we are getting picky about Kevin Pritchard not drafting some players then Presti can't get credit for drafting Green since Boston technically did that.

dose2100
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 39
Points: 9
Offline
its a stupid argument to say

its a stupid argument to say someone didn't draft someone when they did a draft night trade to acquire that pick... i'm pretty sure pritchard told those teams who to draft after he traded for their picks... its a just a technical point to say those players where drafted by the other team then traded...

and yes, pritchard has had a lot of higher picks in the draft, but you can't say that he has really messed up any of the picks... he got the best two players in the 2006 draft, he took the better fit for portland in oden (who is definitely going to become a great big man), and his picks of fernandez, batum and sergio were all great late picks by pritchard, so you can't say he's only done well because he's had high lottery picks...

btw, other than chandler and lee (who is super overrated), what other good pick has thomas made? i don't understand at all how someone could even mention him as a good drafter...

xbadgerhustler
Registered User
Joined: 05/27/2009
Posts: 1960
Points: 680
Offline
I think that the "Best GM

I think that the "Best GM Drafter" definitely has to include draft trades... That just means that you know who you want and you do what you have to do to get them at their exact market value. I mean, he turned, Tyrus Thomas into LaMarcus Aldridge, Randy Foye into Brandon Roy... you just have to have a goal in mind for your team and then go after guys who fit that style. Nicholas Batum is guy that I think they basically outplayed the Spurs for. SA was picking 26 and was going to pick Batum so Portland traded for the 25th pick and got their guy.

You have to know each player's value in every other GM's mind and then maneuver your way to your guy

maravich44
Registered User
Joined: 06/02/2009
Posts: 432
Points: 242
Offline
Durant vs. Oden

At the time I would have taken Oden over Durant and I'm still not sure in the long run that Durant will have a better career. If he's ever healthy, Oden still could turn out to be one of the best centers in the league, and he has the good fortune of not having to carry the whole weight of the team on his shoulders.

I agree trading for a draftable player on draft night is as good as drafting him as far as getting credit is concerned. Portland should be solid for years, and I still see Mike Conley coming soon!

blackflash234
Registered User
Joined: 01/25/2009
Posts: 536
Points: 802
Offline
Kevin Pritchard and Sam Presti

Kevin Pritchard and Sam Presti are the best in the game when it comes to GM's. Look at Portland for example. They're a dynasty in the making and so is Oklahoma City but they aren't at the level of Portland just yet.

maravich44
Registered User
Joined: 06/02/2009
Posts: 432
Points: 242
Offline
It must really suck for fans

It must really suck for fans in Seattle. 30 years since championship team. Now they are turning it around and just left town.

piratejp
Registered User
Joined: 06/11/2009
Posts: 309
Points: -46
Offline
Petrie

As a Kings fan I have to throw in Geoff Petrie. Since returning to the lottery two years ago, he's taken Hawes at 10 & Thompson at 11. The jury is still way out on both, but early results are promising & I think it safe to say that it's maybe likely - certainly possible - that each will be in the top 10 players (in terms of career production) from each of those drafts.

Prior to that, he has mostly drafted late, but nabbed gems such as Hedo Turkoglu, Peja Stojakovich, Kevin Martin & Francisco Garcia. There were a few duds too, but no one hits 100% outside the lottery (heck, no one hits 100% in the lottery), but his track record with the picks he's made is good. In fact, I think one of his worst picks was his first. He took Jason Williams ahead of Paul Pierce, which absolutely freaking killed me at the time. Of course they unloaded Williams for Bibby, so even a borderline bad pick worked out okay in the end.

I think as an overall strategist, I'd give Petrie a C+. But as a talent evaluator & drafter (at least as far as making picks, not manipulating the draft), his name should be in there with the best.

Mr. Basketball
Mr. Basketball's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/04/2008
Posts: 1196
Points: 303
Offline
dunleavy: only drafted 3

dunleavy: only drafted 3 times. those 3 times: thornton at #14. gordon at #7. Deandre Jordan at #35. Mike Taylor at #55. And now Blake Griffin at #1. thats pretty impressive and u can't argue against it.

CorningKingsFan31
CorningKingsFan31's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/11/2009
Posts: 73
Points: -2
Offline
agreed with petrie

got steals with peja and hedo. and look what g-wall turned into. sad we had to let him go to charlotte for expansion draft. yeah, cisco is solid. kevmart was a steal, jt and spence are turning out very nice. i am still upset we took douby. we didnt need him at the time. i really wanted rondo in that spot......imagine that. oh well.

mikeyvthedon
mikeyvthedon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 5606
Points: 13223
Online
Draft GMs

All-time, Jerry West. Currently, gotta go with Pop/RC Buford, those Spurs scouts have eyes for talent. Pritchard is solid, but all of those were trades, albeit trades that involved picks on draft day.

Knicksboy34
Knicksboy34's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/07/2009
Posts: 2876
Points: -98
Offline
Man...I honestly think that

Man...I honestly think that we need to throw in trades in as well. IMO, we need to look at the bad picks as well.

maravich44
Registered User
Joined: 06/02/2009
Posts: 432
Points: 242
Offline
Red Aurbach

Red was the best of all time. He created and maintained Celtic dynasty, outsmarted the league on Larry Bird and continued working his magic prolonging the run getting McHale and Parrish. West was incredible, but Aurbach easily beats him out in my opinion, I think draft day trades such as Portland's work the same as draft picks.

I also wonder how Isiah could be considered one of the best drafting gm's of all time. Compared to his trading, he was a genious, but compared to the average gm, I don't think he was that spectacular. David Lee and Wilson Chandler were nice picks, but Isiah has done nothing special.

Knicksboy34
Knicksboy34's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/07/2009
Posts: 2876
Points: -98
Offline
Isiah picked Damon

Isiah picked Damon Stoudemire and Tracy McGrady.....

I like the Red Auberbach pick but i give you two teams.....

Early-mid 80s Pistons GM..Thomas, Agurrie (by trade), Dumars, Rodman, Salley

and

mid to late Blazers GM..Drexler, Duckworth, Robinson, Elie...

I wish i could find there names

maravich44
Registered User
Joined: 06/02/2009
Posts: 432
Points: 242
Offline
Agree the Pistons GM did an

Agree the Pistons GM did an awesome job putting together that team. Dumars, Rodman and others came from small schools before it was fashionable to draft small school players.

If Portland GM was the same guy that drafted Bowie over Jordan, I think he could be left out of the conversation of great GM's.

Isiah picked those 2, but Stoudemire was highly regarded at AZ and McGrady was a highly coveted high school player. Bulls were very high on him too. They weren't ral sleeper type picks though they were solid. It will be interesting how Isiah does in his new career. Can't do worse than he did in N.Y.!

mikeyvthedon
mikeyvthedon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 5606
Points: 13223
Online
Well....

I know the name of one of the people involved with some of the Blazers players you named, it is Harry Glickman, a good friend of my grandfathers who I have played poker with a few times. Harry is a rad dude, and he did not make those picks necessarily, but he was VP and part owner, so he had some influence. But, would I say the Blazers during that period were the best drafters? I doubt it, those guys had some big time flops, though you are right about those steals too.

I believe I have gone on my rant about Isiah before, but the dude is not really as great as people say. His one real find was Damon, which was dope, but McGrady dropped into the Raptors laps. I remember Isiah saying "he would have taken T-Mac 2 or 3", but dude is full of &$#%#&@!, and I honestly believe he would have taken Adonal Foyle had the Warriors not scooped him. He drafted Marcus Camby, which seemed like the good move at the time, but all 3 guys after Marcus were better, plus of course a lot of other players in that draft. Also, Isiah had no say in drafting Jamison and trading for VC. What did he do in Indiana? I honestly do not know, other than coach badly after All-Star breaks and in the play-offs. Than lets take New York, Wilson Chandler really make people that happy? Ronaldo Balkman really did very little to prove he was worthy of the 22.

Isiah is weak sauce, he was an awful coach and everything he touches turns to garbage. Meanwhile, Pop and RC Buford drafted Tony Parker 28 and Manu Ginobili 57, and they became pillars on 3 championship teams. I would take Manu and Tony over Damon and T-Mac, who barely even had a chance to play together. The Spurs make some other nice late round picks, I think George Hill looks solid and that Mahinmi and Splitter could both eventually contribute. Plus, look at Sam Presti and I know he is not the only one, but the Spurs straight up breed GMs in the league. I think Jerry West is one of the better talent evaluators of all-time, and his 8 rings as a Lakers GM seem to prove that. He traded for Kobe, but his late round picks of Derek Fisher and Devean George were pretty damn nice. He drafted Divac at 26, Elden Campbell at 27, both had pretty nice careers considering. Hooked up Nicky V at 37, and Reuben Patterson at 31, both Bearcats who were damn good second round picks. Jerry did not exactly kill it in Memphis, but the fact that he lead them to the play-offs in his years there is impressive enough to me. Also, if you are going to exclude people who have gotten traded on draft day as picks, than, that is a hell of a lot of GMs out of the picture. Pritchard forecasted the hell out of his picks a few years ago, but in the end, he still traded for the right guys draft day despite what Stephen A(wful commentator) Smith said that day. I would not count out Oden yet either, and have to mention that every GM in the draft most likely would have taken Oden one as well. I at least know that if Seattle at the time picked 1, Oden is in OKC today :)

rvirsal
rvirsal's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2009
Posts: 213
Points: 11
Offline
spurs gm

i don't know his name but he's pretty good. (parker, ginobili, duncan, george hill, scola, -> if he did draft these guys)

isiah thomas was pretty good at drafting also. his "questionable" picks are doing okay in the league now. balkman, mardy collins, david lee, ariza, frye, wilson chandler. he did screw up his trades and fa signings but he had the eye for talent. who would've thought that balkman would go as high as 20 when he wasn't even in the top 300? nbadraft.net had like a 73 player ranking on him. lol

RSS: Syndicate content