This topic contains 15 replies, has 11 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar llperez 14 years, 5 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #36428
    AvatarAvatar
    uknation
    Participant

    This is obvious after seeing some people say the UNC vs Duke was the game of the year. Explain how a game that had UNC winning most of it is the game of the year?  A game of the year is a close game down to the last second. There have been games between teams that had more excitement and a last second shot but the teams weren’t Duke vs UNC its not considered the game of the year. How is this game better than UK vs UNC…lets see

     

    Two higher ranked teams, check

    More college talent , check

    More NBA talent, check

    Last second shot, check

    Good offense

    Good defense

    Close game all the way down to the last second, check

     

    UNC VS Duke

    not as high ranked teams

    less college talent

    less NBA talent

    big lead by a team for a good portion of the game

    bad defense

    last second shot

     

    This is the reason i say some of y’all don’t know basketball. The last couple of minutes and seconds was great, before that the game really wasn’t all that great overall.  A top game means a top whole GAME, not just the last couple of minutes or seconds.

     

    0
  • #635212
    AvatarAvatar
    Tongue-Out-Like-23
    Participant

    Wouldn’t that be a personal opinion though?

    0
  • #635214
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    you forgot to factor in that duke/unc is a great rivalry with lots of history. That alone makes it a game of great interest nationwide

    0
  • #635227
    AvatarAvatar
    mikeyvthedon
    Participant

    Here is the reason that UNC and Duke was a better game:

    It was a better game!

    A good game is not about having the most NBA talent, it is about excitement and sometimes even the unexpected. People are not saying that the players in UNC and Duke are better than the ones on Kentucky. Indeed, I feel Kentucky could easily be better than either team. But, the way the game played out with Duke was super exciting.

    Kentucky against North Carolina was a fantastic game. Kentucky deserved to win, that Anthony Davis block was awesome. The player of the game was more than likely Mike Kidd-Gilchrist, he was great. Still, when John Henson just stood there when Davis swatted the hell out of him, it was a tad disappointing. I truly felt that Indiana versus Kentucky was a better game because of the ending.

    I guess that a game does indeed have a beginning, middle and end. Maybe in that case, North Carolina versus Kentucky was quite exciting in the middle portion. But, the ending tends to stick out. That Austin Rivers shot, with his team being down the entire second half, was awesome. I truly dislike Duke, and think that it was awesome. I was cheering for Kentucky against Indiana, but Christian Watford’s last second shot, also awesome.

    It is really all about preference. You cannot tell someone how to like a basketball game. I think you are fighting a losing battle. We get it, you are a big Kentucky fan. They are the #1 team in the nation and are playing amazing basketball. They have more NBA talent than Duke by a nice portion, probably more than North Carolina as well.

    The Duke versus UNC game had a much better ending, which is what has made it a better game than even the incredible clash with Kentucky and UNC. It being on UNC’s home court also probably played a factor. Anthony Davis’ block on Henson was fantastic, but Rivers shot, even if it was poorly defended, was ice cold. He lived up to subzero with that one. This post is just sour grapes in a situation that really does not call for it.  

    0
  • #635229
    AvatarAvatar
    markyd253
    Participant

    obviously your opinion is biased as you’re a uk fan.

    does it matter that the two teams were ranked higher? nope

    how about more college talent? nope

    more nba talent? nope

    and there was no last second shot no one scored for like the last minute of the game

    where as duke unc

    had a freshman put the team on his back

    an actual last second buzzer beater

    the best rivalry in college basketball

    the team that won fought back on the road

    and how can the unc uk game have good d but unc was in the other game and have bad d? come on son

     

    0
  • #635226
    AvatarAvatar
    uknation
    Participant

    So you’re saying you can’t be considered the best game even if you’re game was overall better than a game that’s a rivalry??  So if Boston vs Lakers comes down to a last shot even though it wasn’t a great game it is automatically considered better than Chi vs the heat that comes down to the last shot and was a close better game overall because its not the rivalry or has the history that Lakers vs Celtics have.

     

    Ok I’ll take that its my opinion that i judge games by how good it is over all plus last seconds over if its a rivalry with history that wasn’t a great overall game. Whats funny during the UK vs UNC game just about everyone on here was praising how good of a game it was every single minute of it but the Duke UNC game no one was praising how great of a game was, they were praising the last couple of minutes and mostly Austin Rivers but no one was saying " wow this is a great game" and if Rivers doesn’t hit that shot it would be even less talk about it.

     

    Ive asked people what makes this a great game, the same answer is the history and rivalry but no one could come up with parts through out the game that made it so great, just the last second shot and Rivers performance. Should things/games be consider the greatest because the history of the two teams or because it is actually the greatest game?

     

    Like a boxing match that is OK and one is winning until the 12th round and then the other boxer knocks the won winning on the score cards out and all of a sudden the whole fight is considered great, even though only the last round was very good

    0
  • #635233
    AvatarAvatar
    Knicksboy42
    Participant

     But you’re complaining about an opinion. To me, Duke vs UNC was the game of the year because I’m a Duke fan, AND it had some awesome momentum swings.  The Rivers-Barnes back and forth was AMAZING.

    0
  • #635235
    AvatarAvatar
    uknation
    Participant

    i’m a UK fan and i can be objective when given a legit reason. Miketvdon gave a very legit reason and from that perspective i can understand. Personally ,like he said, a great game to me is having a great beginning middle and end not just a great end. Like how movies are considered the best by beginning, middle, and end, not just the end.

     

    In reality there have been better games this year than the UK,UNC game and the UNC vs Duke game, but opinion doesn’t have to be reality

    0
  • #635236
    AvatarAvatar
    raybeas
    Participant

    still has to get votes for GOTY. It was hard to hear the TV announcers over the crowd, and a Playboy bunny wannabe was trampled in the post-game celibration.

    0
  • #635237
    AvatarAvatar
    Future_Scout

    SON, cut it out, that is your opinion. maybe for some people a comeback led by a freshman on a way more talented team is more historic and exiting than a a game going back and forth between elite talented teams. its your opinion, i understand

    0
  • #635252
    AvatarAvatar
    apb540
    Participant

    That’s your reasoning of why "some of us don’t know basketball"? 

     

    0
  • #635259
    AvatarAvatar
    sheltwon3
    Participant

    I think because of everything that happened in the game and also the game History come into play.  Also you have a freshmen, son of an NBA coach who also attended make a last second shot over another potential lottery pick.  I think you factor the hype and the outcome and that game had lots of scoring.  It was a game that could have gone either way, it makes it a game of the year contender.  There may have been better games but none with this amount of history and pressure.  Austin Rivers is probably one and done now for sure and if he misses that shot maybe he come back.  Nba scout were definitely at that game.

    0
  • #635285
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. 19134
    Participant

     Sports and movies are different experiences because you watch movies a few times over most of the time.  You know the lines by heart and ect.  In sports most people only watch the game ONCE, therefore the most important part of that is going to be the last thing they remenber which is going to be the last thing they see of the game which is going to be the end of the game.  It’s easier to remenber that Austin River’s buzzer beater then the back and forth play of the UK-UNC game.  Plus UK is the most talented team in the nation and won, that’s never as fun as the underdog winning on a buzzer beater from their star freshman with his Hall of Fame dad watchin in the crowd nonetheless.  

    0
  • #635288
    AvatarAvatar
    Johnny Chill

    Duke vs UNC was the game of the year to date. The national media would agree.

    0
  • #635302
    AvatarAvatar
    delfam
    Participant

     it’s all opinion so nobody can have a right answer. I though UK vs. Indiana was the best game, but that’s just my opinion, there is no right answer.

    0
  • #635307
    AvatarAvatar
    llperez

    best game i saw was stanford vs oregon state. 4 overtimes, great back and forth play, came down to the last shot rimming out at the buzzer. But obviously hype and how high the teams are ranked is important as well and thus stanford/oregon state and numerous other games around the country wont live up to duke/unc in most people eyes.

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login