Rating A Players by stars

BKKnicksfan
BKKnicksfan's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/11/2010
Posts: 2306
Points: -1139
Offline
Rating A Players by stars

I wonder if u were to rate NBA players by Stars (like 2k11) how would you do it? like what would be the perfect example representing the star level? My example

1 star: Ryan Hollins
1.5 stars : Willie Green
2 stars: Landry Fields
2.5 stars: James Harden
3 stars: Taj Gibson
3.5 stars: David West
4 stars: Amare Stoude'mire
4.5 stars: Stephen Curry
5 stars: Kevin Durant


Hale
Hale's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2009
Posts: 5967
Points: 12837
Offline
Curry is better then Amare?

Curry is better then Amare?

mattholdenbrown
mattholdenbrown's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/09/2010
Posts: 127
Points: 153
Offline
if durant is 5 stars what is

if durant is 5 stars what is kobe

TRC1991
TRC1991's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 5321
Points: 10347
Offline
there is a lot wrong with

there is a lot wrong with your initial example and here is a better one

1 = Brian Scalabrine

1.5 = Joey Graham

2 = Darko Milicic

2.5 = Boris Diaw

3 = JR Smith

3.5 = Darren Collison

4 = Josh Smith

4.5 = Yao Ming

5 = Carmelo Anthony

Rafter
Rafter's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/02/2008
Posts: 592
Points: 1371
Offline
Rating

Rating players by stars seems so...restricted IMO.

BKKnicksfan
BKKnicksfan's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/11/2010
Posts: 2306
Points: -1139
Offline
I guess I made a mistake

I guess I made a mistake explaining, thus my points were raped.

I rather have Curry over Stoudemire. I factor in 5 things: Offense, Defense, Intangables, Positional Skills and 3 year outlook

Kobe would be 5 stars as well. The highest level would be 5.

Also, I don't think there would be too many 4.5 to 5 stars guy. Plus, I think Taylor there is some issues with your scale as well. JR Smith is not a 3 star guy to me, more of a 2. Darko could arguably be a 2.5 guy as well. Yao is NOT a 4.5 guy, 4 at the best. What has Darren Collison done to earn a 3.5 level?

I wanna use this to rate future players, so more feedback would be cool!

Grandmama
Grandmama's picture
Registered User
Joined: 09/20/2009
Posts: 2290
Points: 4364
Offline
"I wanna use this to rate

"I wanna use this to rate future players, so more feedback would be cool!"

There is probably a reason nobody has every used this nonsense to rate players...

BKKnicksfan
BKKnicksfan's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/11/2010
Posts: 2306
Points: -1139
Offline
There is probably a reason

There is probably a reason nobody has every used this nonsense to rate players...

Every?

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1205
Offline
lol. Durant isn't on the same

lol. Durant isn't on the same level as kobe though

What has harden done so far to be higher then Landry? (i like both players game by the way

In the end i cant really say you're wrong because this is a opinion poll not really a fact poll and i dont agree with the durant/kobe Fields over harden or curry over Amare but i understand where you're coming from

The nonsense thing was funny because you gotta make sure i you are gonna say something is nonsense, you spell everything correct or that leaves you open to get hit with a comeback..lol

BKKnicksfan
BKKnicksfan's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/11/2010
Posts: 2306
Points: -1139
Offline
So then you would have Durant

So then you would have Durant as a 4.5 guy?

Quincey, I respect your opinion more then others because you know about the game. Give me advice, what would you use to rate players?

llperez
llperez's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/13/2009
Posts: 13134
Points: 15142
Offline
that initial list is pretty

that initial list is pretty whack. If ryan hollins who actually plays and sort of contributes is a 1 star, then what is a bench warmer who doesnt even play? And to me, landry fields, james harden and taj gibson are all pretty much on the same level. I dont see what seperates those 3 in any significant way. And i take amare over curry. At best, they are on the same level.

BKKnicksfan
BKKnicksfan's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/11/2010
Posts: 2306
Points: -1139
Offline
It was a example....we can

It was a example....we can relax now.

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1205
Offline
Kobe,Lebron,Wade,5star CP3

Kobe,Lebron,Wade,5star

CP3 Dwill,Dirk

Durant

If i did star system but i wouldn't because its too hard to figure out. I would just say who are the top level guys then who's below them and Below them and so on and so on.

BKKnicksfan
BKKnicksfan's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/11/2010
Posts: 2306
Points: -1139
Offline
I guess, I haven't been

I guess, I haven't been working on it yet but once I do, I'll try to have a legit explantion what's the difference between the levels.

RSS: Syndicate content