share

How do you think players that skipped college would have done in the NCAA?

LeroyJenkins
LeroyJenkins's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/23/2009
Posts: 773
Points: 2217
Offline
How do you think players that skipped college would have done in the NCAA?

When i ask this i mean players that actually commited to a school and still chose the NBA like Josh Smith,Sebastian Telfair,Robert Swift, etc.

For example i think shaun livingston would have played the 3 at duke and played a turkoglu type role for them...and hopefully would have put on some muscle/weight.


JNixon
JNixon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 12962
Points: 11537
Offline
I think Gerald Green

I think Gerald Green could've used college. He's a gifted talent and athlete, but he has no fundamentals and needed some college coaching. NBA coaches aren't going to be that willing to teach fundamental basketball because they have a bunch of grown men on the team who should know what they're. He would've learned some if he would've been under Coach Sutton for at least 1 year.

joecheck88
joecheck88's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 2817
Points: 2556
Offline
It depends on how long they

It depends on how long they stayed. I think most would have had some struggles their freshman seasons. Guys like Lebron, Amare, and D Howard would have been fine. But JR Smith, Gerald Green, Shaun Livingston, Robert Smith, etc would have probably had up and down seasons, IMO. I think Telfair would have been decent though.

JNixon
JNixon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 12962
Points: 11537
Offline
Could you imagine Rashad

Could you imagine Rashad McCants and J.R. Smith at UNC? Would've been alot of offense and alot of headaches for Roy Williams

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
yeah alot of guys would have

yeah alot of guys would have struggled like a josh smith. i think howard would have had a hard time as wellbut still put up shaq type numbers when shaq was a freshman. i see josh having the type of impact favors had. i think amare would have did his thing though because of how aggressive he is plus he's always been pretty quick for a center/pf

the I in win
the I in win's picture
Registered User
Joined: 11/28/2009
Posts: 2133
Points: 1562
Offline
Lebron has stated that he

Lebron has stated that he would have gone to unc so that would have been unfair for any other team.

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
i read somewhere that he

i read somewhere that he said he would have gone to duke and played for coach k

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
from what ive been looking

from what ive been looking up the past couple of minutes i see a couple of reports of him saying he would have went to ohio state and a lot of recruiting people saying the same thing. kobe has said duke though

McDunkin
McDunkin's picture
Registered User
Joined: 03/17/2010
Posts: 7483
Points: 28333
Offline
I know Amare said he would

I know Amare said he would have gone to mempis and even wished he did a few years ago on espn

Imaking6004
Imaking6004's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 112
Points: 115
Offline
Telfair couldve used college

Telfair couldve used college too. Sebastian is a good passer but doesnt know how to run an offense like a normal PG should. He was way too raw for the NBA when he got drafted. If he spent at least two years in Louisville he couldve been a starting PG in the NBA

Charlie Sheen
Charlie Sheen's picture
Registered User
Joined: 03/16/2010
Posts: 1237
Points: 641
Offline
College is where you figure

College is where you figure out what type of player you will be in the NBA. Look at Evan Turner he's gonna be a beast because he can do alot he's a triple threat(pass,shoot,dribble).Brandon Roy 4 years in school,Dwyane Wade 3 years. Carmelo only stayed 1 year but had an offense built aroung him so he was ready to be the 1st option in an NBA offense.Rajon Rondo he wasn't better than Livingston or Telfair coming out but went to college and now is a top 5 pg in the NBA.

A list of Players who needed college

JR Smith-2 years
Shaun Livingston-1year
Sebastian Telfair-2 years
Gerald Green- 3 years
Josh Smith-1 year
Amar'e Stoudemire- 1 year
Martell Webster- 4 years
Dwiight Howard-1 year

thaprodigy
thaprodigy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 01/18/2009
Posts: 305
Points: 163
Offline
LeBron told Kenny Smith that

LeBron told Kenny Smith that he would've went to UNC on TNT 1time and we would see some of the worst shot selection ever if JR and Rashad McCants were on the same team

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
yeah lebron has told other

yeah lebron has told other peopel he would have gone to other schools as well. i guess we never know where he would have gone

eric palmer
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 103
Points: 200
Offline
LeBron

Yeah, I wouldn't believe anything that man says. When he was a guest picker on College Gameday on the Ohio State campus, he said he would of picked Ohio State hands down. But he's also said he'd pick Duke and UNC, probably some others too.

Cusemen727
Registered User
Joined: 11/13/2009
Posts: 243
Points: 275
Offline
LeBron

Im sure it was a big inside joke between the 2 of them but there was a rumor in cuse that if Carmelo stayed then lebron would of come to cuse.

the I in win
the I in win's picture
Registered User
Joined: 11/28/2009
Posts: 2133
Points: 1562
Offline
amare didn't need college,

amare didn't need college, he got rookie of the year.

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
yeah but thats exactly what

yeah but thats exactly what it was..a rumor...im guessing it was started by a cuse fan

scoutguru
Registered User
Joined: 06/23/2008
Posts: 498
Points: 228
Offline
Yeah, I say always say this

Yeah, I say always say this til this day. If Telfair would've went to college, Louisville would've for sure won the title that year. And for his personal development also, he coulda used the experience. Really needed to hone his skills at the college level. He didn't really look like a can't miss prospect when he came out HS, as compared to Derrick Rose and John Wall coming out of HS. For most PG's however, there's not a good track record with those coming out after HS or one year except for the obvious.

RSS: Syndicate content