share

Who will go down as the better PG?

mwardia
Registered User
Joined: 01/01/2010
Posts: 470
Points: -151
Offline
Who will go down as the better PG?

Steve Nash or J-Kidd


llperez
llperez's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/13/2009
Posts: 11732
Points: 11415
Offline
im not sure who will have

im not sure who will have the better career, but im guessing in 20 years, people will be talking about nash more then kidd.

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
kidd. i dont think its even

kidd. i dont think its even real close as far as looking at the total career and all around game

JordanC20
Registered User
Joined: 04/26/2009
Posts: 577
Points: -84
Offline
Jason Kidd due to better

Jason Kidd due to better statistics but to me Nash is better.

sheltwon3
sheltwon3's picture
Registered User
Joined: 03/30/2009
Posts: 6364
Points: 2607
Offline
depends on who plays longer

depends on who plays longer and I think Nash willl have it when it is all said and done.

Kobe4Prez
Kobe4Prez's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/14/2009
Posts: 34
Points: 30
Offline
Nash

It has to go to Nash. The Career Stats are Semi close. Kidd obviously has the edge there but Nash is a 2 time MVP.

Kidd--13.6ppg/ 9.2apg/ 6.6rpg
- 10 Time All Star
- 5 1rst All NBA team
- 1 2nd All NBA team
- 4 1rst All Defensive team
- 5 2nd All Defensive team
- ROY award

Nash-- 14.6ppg/ 8.2rpg/ 3.0rpg
- 2 Time MVP
- 7 Time All Star
- 3 Time 1rst All NBA team
- 1 2nd All NBA team
- 2 3rd All NBA team

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
i think alot of young people

i think alot of young people will say nash because they dont remeber kidd when he was younger and will base it on what hes doing now. the same way someone may say some pf whos older but playing well had a better career then kg. who ranks were in all time (among pg or guards) scoring rebounding ast steals triple doubles through out there career?

Johnny Kilroy
Johnny Kilroy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 03/30/2009
Posts: 211
Points: 512
Offline
I would say Kidd

Nash wasn't much of a defender and his stats were improved with the Run-n-Gun offense of the Suns!

All that's missing on both resumes is a championship!

NashyMing
NashyMing's picture
Registered User
Joined: 02/08/2010
Posts: 632
Points: 1308
Offline
Kidd has an edge

Kidd is a better all around player, but Nash had won 2 MVPs (almost 3 if not for Dirk to get that one).

However, Nash's MVP season was a product of the run & gun system employed by D'Antoni which inflated his stats to MVP level. I think Kidd would be nearly as impressive if he was in Nash's situation.

As much as I love Steve Nash (my 2nd favorite player), I would have to admit Jason Kidd is a better overall player. Both deserved to be in Hall of Flame though.

Grandmama
Grandmama's picture
Registered User
Joined: 09/20/2009
Posts: 1837
Points: 3568
Offline
Kidd

First of all, one of Nash's MVP's should be Kobe's. Second of all, if you put Jason Kidd in his prime in the Suns offense, Kidd would have put up better numbers and also could have won an MVP. You look at both players during their prime, and Kidd hands Nash a beatdown.

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
who would you take with both

who would you take with both of them in there prime?..easily kidd. i mean come on. nash is good/great ill give him that but kidd in his prime could do anything that nash could do and much more and better except the shooting part. add to that that he was bigger,stronger,better defender and i dont think its really close

The UnderKanter
Registered User
Joined: 06/12/2009
Posts: 2419
Points: 255
Offline
Well for fans it will be

Well for fans it will be Nash, because of his style of play and many people like him. For history, and greatest point guard ever it will be Jason Kidd, because of his better stats, and a more pure point guard. Nash is getting enough assists to be considered a pure point guard but at the beginning of his career he was just fast and able to score very easily. The passing ability I don't think developed until he left Dallas. I am not quite sure on that though, don't quote me on that. History likes pure point guards better then they do combo ones, even though the NBA is now starting to lean towards combo guards, history still tends to rate pure point guards better then they do combo guards.

arman
Registered User
Joined: 05/31/2009
Posts: 390
Points: -237
Offline
In their

In their 20s i say Kidd is better cause he came to league as a star.... nash wasnt a household name in his 20s..... but nash is 36 and he is stil top 3 pg in league and i think that is his truely value as he gets old he is better.... i agree, kidd is more versatile and better defensive player but nash is better shooter.. if i need to choose one player i pick nash cause there arent really a lot of veterans that can be real impact players

Biggysmalls
Registered User
Joined: 12/20/2009
Posts: 671
Points: 1164
Offline
While both have had very

While both have had very good careers, I think its gotta go to Kidd and its not even really close. Jason Kidd has done it all. He scores, he rebounds, he gets everybody involved, and he defends. Did Kidd win the MVP when he went to New Jersey and instantly made that team a contender in the East? Cuz he definitly should have. The guy is a pure point guard in every sense of the word, and all young players looking to play point guard should try to mirror their games to Kidds.

I agree, Nash gets more hype because of the Run n gun style of Phoenix, but Jason Kidd is a rock. He plays far superior defense, he gets everybody involved in the offense, and he has always been a solid triple double threat.

Daprob89
Daprob89's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 186
Points: 111
Offline
Kidd of course

Jason Kidd never averaged less 7.5ast in a season his whole career and he had a handful of seasons were he flirted with a triple-double average

Kidd top 5 best seasons:
07-08 11.3 pts 10.4ast 8rebs
06-07 13.0 pts 9.2ast 8.2rebs
95-96 16.6 pts 9.7ast 7rebs
98-99 16.9 pts 10.8ast 6.7rebs
02-03 18.7 pts 9ast 6.3rebs

And you can argue he had better seasons then the ones shown so JKIDD enough said.

B-ball fan
Registered User
Joined: 08/01/2009
Posts: 1945
Points: 1926
Offline
Kidd

He was on teams in the championship, and he played great defense and rebounded great. Nash does each worse. Nash had his stats inflated by the fast paced Sun's offense. When Terry Porter was coach, he was no better statistically than he was in Dallas.

the I in win
the I in win's picture
Registered User
Joined: 11/28/2009
Posts: 2106
Points: 1522
Offline
I think Kidd has had the

I think Kidd has had the better career but Nash will always be more recognized because of the MVP's

Daprob89
Daprob89's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 186
Points: 111
Offline
Yea he won MVPs but his

Yea he won MVPs but his first one wasnt a MVP caliber season to me...
05-06 Steve Nash 15.5 11.5 (Thats amazing but i feel these guys had better seasons that year)

05-06 Dwayne Wade 27.4pts 7.5ast 4.7rebs (Championship ring)
05-06 Dirk Nowitzki 26.6pts 2.8ast 9rebs (Nba Finals)
05-06 Kobe Bryant 35.4pts 4.5ast 5.3rebs( First Round) Still impressive

JNixon
JNixon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 12949
Points: 11509
Offline
I think Kidd is the better

I think Kidd is the better PG and I don't think it's as close as most are making it seem. I'm quite young, and I think that Kidd is better than Nash. Jason Kidd was an unbelievable PG. He was everything aPG should be, except he wasn't more than mediocre as a shooter. He could do literally EVERYTHING at a ridiculously high level, except shoot. I maintain that he's the best playmaking PG I've ever seen personally..

Nash was a system PG IMO...He was a guy that was an above average PG before he came to the Suns in Dallas. Some people even said he was more of a combo guard than a natural PG back then. He is just a great fit for the Suns system, which IMO is just a free-for-all that inflates stats. He's not truly the elite player that Kidd is. I truly believe that if Kidd would've had Joe Johnson, Amare Stoudemire, Quentin Richardson (back in the day) and Boris Diaw, Jason Kidd would've brought home AT LEAST 1 title...Hell, he got to the Finals with Kenyon Martin and Richard Jefferson as his other impact players, both players are legit 3rd/4th options in the NBA. Two of those Suns guys I listed are guys that are now looking to get max deals in the free agent class that's emerging. Hmmm...That's food for thought.

Give me Kidd everytime...MVP's or no MVP's

LawDeeZee
LawDeeZee's picture
Registered User
Joined: 01/18/2010
Posts: 232
Points: 308
Offline
it's going to be nash ...

it's going to be nash ... neither won a championship and nash won two MVP's - back to back ... that puts him in pretty exclusive company

you can say dantoni's system is a major factor in nash's production - but i can say jason kidd played what i think most would consider his prime years in new jersey when the east was at or close to it's all time weakness

don't spend too much time rationalizing it ... nash was the perfect point guard for that system and he used his abilities to flourish in it ... if you watched phoenix games during those seasons he completely dominated games with his passing as well as timely scoring, jason kidd was obviously the better defender ... you could make an argument for either of them as a passer ... and nash is clearly the better shooter, so when you ask in terms of how we'll look back on them when it's all said and done, i think those two mvp's have to weight pretty heavily

marcusfizer21
marcusfizer21's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/09/2009
Posts: 2521
Points: 4697
Offline
Iggy said it so

Give me Kidd, MVP or no MVP's... In fact he should have been the MVP in 2002 not Tim Duncan...

bigsby22
Registered User
Joined: 02/17/2010
Posts: 19
Points: 16
Offline
Kidd he does it all defends

Kidd he does it all defends passes scores when he needs to, the stat that stands out the most is rebounds 6.6 a game career for a true PG is phenomenal to me

RSS: Syndicate content