share

Who's Better?!

RickyRubio9
RickyRubio9's picture
Registered User
Joined: 07/01/2008
Posts: 2080
Points: 1069
Offline
Who's Better?!

Who is better of the two, Aaron Brooks or Devin Harris, and why?
I'm completely serious with this question, I honestly feel Harris is overrated & I think Brooks may be better at this point and has more potential as well.


JNixon
JNixon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/14/2009
Posts: 12959
Points: 11525
Offline
It's close, but I think

It's close, but I think Harris is better. Brooks had a better year than Harris did last season, but if you compare Harris 08-09 season to Brooks' career season last year, Harris is better. You aren't alone in the thought that Harris is overrated though. I've been saying that since last off-season.

Also, even though the scoring ability of both of them is pretty even and neither is a pure playmaker, Harris is better as a natural playmaker for others than Brooks is, which has to count for alot being that both are PG's. Also, even though Harris hasn't defended for the Nets like he did for the Mavs (largely due to the offensive role he's shouldering), he's still a better defender than Brooks is. Brooks is EXTREMELY mediocre on D.

paint intruder
paint intruder's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/12/2010
Posts: 166
Points: 126
Offline
It depends on what you want

It depends on what you want from your player. If it's shooting I'd go with Brooks, if it's slashing I'd go with Harris. Also Harris has the height advantage over Brooks, so to me he is the safer bet.

RickyRubio9
RickyRubio9's picture
Registered User
Joined: 07/01/2008
Posts: 2080
Points: 1069
Offline
In my Opinion

I think Brooks is a better scorer especially shooting wise & getting to the basket and finishing, if you watch some of his moves. they're amazing for his size.
I didn't think of the size difference though, that's a good point, good reason to pick Harris because Brooks can be a defensive liability, but then again he makes his defender work just as hard guarding him. I think having Yao back there will help make him look better this year & him & Martin have been saying their focus is Defense.. Just have to wait 'till the season to see if it works out.

IndianaBasketball
IndianaBasketball's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 12674
Points: 23861
Offline
IF healthy, I'd go with

IF healthy, I'd go with Harris. He's a top 10-12 point guard when healthy and not too many guards have his combination of size, speed/quickness, athleticism, etc.

Mr. 19134
Mr. 19134's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/21/2010
Posts: 3444
Points: 3410
Offline
I think Brooks is better

I think Brooks is better because he is younger, has more potential, is a slightly better athlete, is an easily better shooter, and most importantly the Rockets win with Brooks. Harris has always been overrated in my eyes. You're talking about the 5th pick of the draft coming out of college as a JR and it took him over 3 years to even average over ten points a game and when he did his shooting percentage dropped down to like 42 percent which is bad.

Harris is a better defender and I wanna say he is a better playmaker but not by much because Harris is not known for making his teammates better.

Brooks is still getting better, I bet Harris never averages over 20 points a game again in his career, not unless he improves his outside shooting which he loves doing but is not that good at.

jas225
jas225's picture
Registered User
Joined: 07/25/2010
Posts: 133
Points: 294
Offline
Mr.

Devin harris averaged 9.9 in his second year and 10.2 pts his third year. So it did not take him over 3 years to even average over 10 pts. And he shot 47% and 49% those years respectively.

And aaron brooks has shot 41, 40 and 43% in his first three years.

I'm not that pro harris, but i would say he has been better, but brooks' season last season could be a sign that he can be better if he holds his numbers.

the lake show
Registered User
Joined: 01/13/2010
Posts: 8202
Points: 1200
Offline
when healthy then its not

when healthy then its not that close...better passer scorer taller and faster..harris. its closer when its a injured harris

RSS: Syndicate content