ScareCrow Versus champTRice we need votes to settle the score....
Who would win if these two teams Played
ScareCrow's Team...Rose.Joe Johnson.Melo. Amare. Dwight Howard
Let me also mention I told him to pick one player from each position and he had First Pick...
He picked Durant...I picked Howard...He picked Bosh..I picked Melo...He picked D.Will...I picked Amare...He picked Dirk(said Bosh was his Center) and I picked Rose...He Then picked Gasol(and made Dirk his Sf) I ended with Joe Johnson....Who do u think would win....
I like champ's team
champTRice's team would win, eventhough he cheated, I think, but why isnt Bron on one of those teams
Yea y'all missed Lebron lol..
I didn't cheat at all. He said no Lebron, Kobe, or Dwade were allowed.
He said one player for each position. "U have to have a Lineup of 1...PG.SG.SF.PF.C."
In the NBA, guys aren't pigeon holed into positions.
Durant has played both the 2 and 3 positions during the season. He can dribble, pass, shoot, and play defense against 2's and 3's.
Dirk can play either forward position.
Bosh can play forward or center.
I used fantasy rules on what positions players could be.
And I also clearly told this guy to draft a team..I gave Him first pick...He picked Durant(who is a small forward) and He ends up being his SG...Dirk is a PF and he's his SF...he wanted Bosh to play at the 4 but then drafted another PF to play the 5...Just for cheating I should put Wade as My @ Guard and just end it/...Rose.Wade.Melo.Amare.Howard....How would he stop any of those two Teams??? That team is super soft...
I think Dirk as a SF is pushing it some, but I agree on Durant and Bosh playing 2 positions. IF anything I think Dirk is better as a stretch center.
I never announced what positions my players were when I drafted them. Guys play different positions all the time. Nobody is stuck in one position. Kobe has played at the point. Lebron has played at the point. That doesn't make them strictly point guards. You said to draft 5 players. I picked 5 players. These guys are versatile players. It's not cheating. Don't be a sore loser.
I said you have to have 1..Point Guard.. Shooting Guard(Durant is a SF) Small Forward( Dirk plays the 4 and 5..not the 3) Power Forward( You Picked 3) Center( Didn't want to pick Bogut or Kaman Huh)
I played by the rules and still have a better TEAM.....All the Durant and Bosh lovers can eat it...they are both Soft and couldn't guard Melo and Amare...Not to mention Gasol and Dirk and Bosh Vs ...Dwight down low...any one of them would be dominated...It'd be kinda funny...Not to mention Rose can D up D.Will and JJ is very unselfish and a great outside shooter...I'd Win....His team would be jacking up 3's....
This isn't a full roster game. This is 5 on 5. As the GM/Coach or whatever you want to call it. I should be allowed to play Dirk, a player who can dribble from the three point line to the basket with either hand, shoot three pointers, and even defend some small forwards. There is nothing wrong with that.
He picked Joe Johnson so he automatically loses.
I'd win and Howard is the key....He'd keep all your guys out the paint...forcing up 3's and jumpers...He'd get all the boards...and if not...Melo and Amare and Rose would just Bully the Other guys for whats left over...JJ and Rose would just break down your guards and feed Amare and D12 for monster dunks...Melo would post up KD or take Dirk off the dribble...same goes for Bosh and Amare...Gasol can't stick D12 be himself...He can't get help when you got shooters and slashers Like Rose.JJ,Melo and Stat...
let me get the rose/howard team. i believe they would dominate physically with howard amare and melo. the second squad is way too soft and lacks defense. rose/howard is also just a better team and i see them working better as an entire unit than the second squad.
Their too soft for D12,Rose,Melo and stat...JJ is the softest guy I have and He makes plays on this team more than scores....He's the shooter...I could have just picked Allen for the 3...
I like Scarecrow's team as well honestly. Too much Euroball on that other team. No physicality other than D-Will.
Rose: He has no consistent jumper. He isn't better than Deron Williams. I'll leave it at that.
Johnson: He isn't this great shooter that you think he is. I'm sorry but you must be mistaken. He isn't more athletic than Durant. Anyway, I will put Dirk on Joe Johnson and have Dirk give him the Rondo treatment. He will be forced to make every jumper in the game against a 7 footer. How do you call my team soft when Joe Johnson is one of the softest disappearing acts in the NBA?
Anthony: Carmelo cannot easily post up Kevin Durant. Durant is strong. He takes everybody off the dribble, but he's not going to drive by Durant every possession.
Stoudemire: What can I say about Stoudemire that hasn't been said against the Lakers?
Howard: He cannot guard the rim and a midrange shooter at the same time. Howard can be shut down one on one while he's on offense.
You say my team is soft. But define soft. Do you mean missing free throws to win games in the playoffs? Do you mean not showing up for playoff games? Do you mean missing free throws to win games in the playoffs? Do you mean not showing up for playoff games? I repeat these because multiple players you have have done those things...this year.
And even if my team lacks defense and athleticism, they are more skilled than your team. Amare plays ZERO defense. Joe Johnson doesn't play defense.
Dirk had the best team and lost to the Warriors....Epic Fail....KD...1 playoff apperarnce...D.Will cant beat LA...D.Fisher hits 3's in his face every time...Bosh....Raptors season Epic Fail...All my guys at least made the Playoffs...Rose is faster and better defender than D.Will...JJ is more versitile than KD...Dirk is not better than Melo...Stat would dunk all over Bosh...And Gasol is only on your team because Kobe makes him look good....Gasol in Memphis EPIC FAIL.........All my guys are #1 option guys....Except for Rose(The Best young point guard in the NBA...) He's unstoppable....D.Will stops himself settling for 3's....
Lay off the 2k10...you can't throw oops all day, fatigue is on.
Dirk had one bad playoff year out of 10. Look up his playoff averages. Kevin Durant is on a young team, much younger than the Bulls. This year was his first experience. It's not like he didn't do his part to win regular season games. Rose has lost 2 straight playoff series without winning one. Rose is not better than Deron Williams. Anybody in the NBA will tell you that. No way Joe Johnson is more versatile than Kevin Durant. Carmelo is better than Dirk, but only slightly. It's not a huge disparity. Dirk can shoot over Melo as much as Melo can score on Dirk. Amare isn't better than Bosh. He's not. At all. No All-Star dunks all over another All-Star. Chris Bosh is better than Amare, he dunks on players all the time. That's not the main part of his game. He has postup moves a smooth jumper and the ability to drive with either hand. Gasol is a great player in his own right. If you don't know that, you don't know basketball. Anybody who is the only quality player on a horrible team would lose a ton of games. Ask Kevin Garnett. Ask Kobe Bryant. Ask Lebron. Ask DWade. Ask Gilbert Arenas. Ask Chris Paul. Ask Paul Pierce. Ask Ray Allen. The list goes on. You only have two number one option guys: Joe Johnson and Carmelo Anthony. You can include Amare, but he's only the number one guy by default because Steve Nash is a pass first point guard. Nash is extremely more valuable than Amare. Rose is definitely stoppable at this point in his career. Especially with Deron Williams on him, he will be stoppable.
I think in due time Scarecrow may have the most negative points in Nbadraft history. Thoughts?
DYNCE has over 22,000 negative points.
Anyone wanna play this game with me they can pick first
Dynce points are flawed and not all really negative i think.
Dino wanna play this game?
You pick first?
Without wade, lebron, and KObe?
1) KD played sg in his first year so it is not cheating to put him there.
2) Bosh could guard a SF in fact i would rather he played SF then Dirk but they both could so it is not really cheating.
3) And KD's team is way more skilled!
4)And D-12 would not have an easy time guarding Dirk or Bosh or Pau!
5)With that said in a 7 game series KD's team would win they are just way more skilled! Melo would score but he would not be able to stop Durant or Bosh or Dirk and the same goes for D-12 and Rose would get worked by DW! Oh and scarecrow stop crying about every little thing! You lost just give it a rest!
Pg: Jarron Collins
Sg: Mario West
Sf: Brian Scalibrine
Pf: John Bryant
C: Brian Zoubek
That team kicks ass!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It';s funny really...KD has had a few good seasons..Melo was arguably the best player on the USA Team during the Olympics...I guess Durant is better than Melo...because you said so...And How did I lose...I have it as a DQ...Mother &$#%#&@! can't read and follow guidelines...1 PG...1 SG...1 Sf...1 PF...1 C....His team has 3 SF's....DQ...plus a few people sided with me and I see the ball riders have backed Him.....
i like scarecrows team
Thats like a 3 to 3 score Homie...J.Nixon Iggy 9, LLPerez and Druneave have voted for me...Hello Kitty and Pacers fans have voted for you...who else...Caleb something... and @ Dino Radja and Revenger Who'd you pick....
I vote for Champs team
I vote for Champs team
i vote champs
And to quote Shaq Diesal...Tell me how my ass Taste...Anybody else notice ever one of my post get the same number of minuses....Dick Riders....Join the Fan Club.....
Yah dino im Pick first
no lebron wade kobe
Give me a reason besides saying that KD would score over Melo...He can't stop Melo inside or outside...
YOU PICK FIRST lol
Actaully im gonna make a new thread
scarecrows by a bit
thanks for the Nod...Check out the Nba Draft Net fantasy draft thread too....
Ok Scarecrow. Here are a few of your comments I will use against you.
1. "All my guys are #1 options on a team." How is this going to work if they all play on the same team? A team isn't all about talent, there needs to be some chemistry. Your team will be a bunch of guys trying to get up their own shots and worrying about themselves.
2. "Gasol is too soft for D-12." Didn't Gasol gaurd Howard last year in the finals and basically shut him down? I know that was a lot of team defense but why can't that happen with Champ's team?
3. "JJ is more versital then KD." Not sure if I should even respond to that because it is one of the dumber comments I have heard. KD is one of the best players in the NBA which is why he was considered for MVP. Was Joe Johnson? No because he disappears in the playoffs and cannot lead a team.
4. "KD has had a couple of good seasons so he is better than melo?" Aren't you making the same argument for Rose saying how is is better than Williams? By the way...that is far from the truth.
5. "You picked Gasol because Kobe makes him look good." That may be the other way around. Kobe lost in the first round and then the next year they make it to the FInals. I do not think that is a coincidence. Gasol is one of the best big men in the league.
If you can't tell, I am with Champ.
Obviously it would be a really close game that can go either way every time. In a series? I would go with the Durant team but only very slightly. It could obviously go the other way with that great of players on either team. But you can't say he cheated. If anything, it wouldn't be good to put players at random positions if they didn't fit. They'd be too slow or too small or something. So, I don't think that is really cheating. Like trying to put Duncan at SF would be a push, and would probably hurt your team more than help it. Dirk can play it, Bosh can play C, and Durant can play 2 guard. The only think that is kind of cheating is letting him get first pick every round. Obviously, that should make his team better than yours. I'm surprised that his isn't better than his is because he had first pick. These are pretty evenly matched.
When has DIrk played at the 3? At center yes
but not sf.
Anyone want to play this game with me?
He started at the 2 in the all-star game, obviously he can atleast play some 3.
Dude as much as i dont like scarecrows trades, ive got 2 admit that his team wud both physically and fundementally destroy u.
Melo is easily the 2nd best forward in the leauge
Rose is 2 eletric
Who u gonna stop Rose or Howard in the paint???
Amare is a physical specimen!!!
Gasol and Dirk are gonna be bullied by Amare and Melo
Ill give the edge 2 Dwill bt Rose is lightning quick
Ill give durant the edge against johnson bt johnson is the better defender
WTF- Bosh on Howard??? hahahahahaha no need 2 explain that 1!!!!
my team is better IMO...I dig everyone's Opinion...We'd give each other a good run no....
You'd lose most every game 155-147.... there's no d in that line-up. Did you pick Don Nelson to be your coach?
You have no height to stop the inside scoring.
also JJ and Rose are good defenders...Melo can be at time too...Amare is the weak link on D but guess whos right there next to him D12...The defensive player of the year 2times over....
Your guards are not going to stop the inside scoring.... and the fact that Melo can play D doesn't get it done not when you have the Amare achilles heal...you'd have your best players fouling out trying to pick up the defensive slack. It's the exact same reason Jerry Colangelo is running the olympic team. There had better be 3 or 4 basketballs for that team you are talking about.