This topic contains 64 replies, has 20 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar Memphis Madness 8 years, 7 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #61503
    AvatarAvatar
    Arc12345
    Participant

     I know this is one of hardest questions in basketball, but who would be on your Mount Rushmore of the NBA? So many names, I’m not even going to name any because I don’t want to sway anyone. But I will list mine as difficult as it is.

    MJ, Oscar, Magic, and Bird.

    So who do you guys got?

    0
  • #1015319
    AvatarAvatar
    Chewy
    Participant

     MJ, Magic, Lebron, Kareem

    I know Russell has the rings, defense and shot blocking. But Kareem has 6 in his own right and I like that he’s all time leading scorer.

    I just recently pushed LBJ ahead of Bird in my head… really hard decision. Can’t go wrong with either.

     

     

    0
    • #1015323
      AvatarAvatar
      Arc12345
      Participant

      Larry Bird > Lebron James

      Lebron is a great stat sheet stuffer, and I’m not hating. But Larry was clutch. And his numbers, in my opinion, are better. Superior shooter obviously. Lebron might be a better passer which is one hell of an accomplishment because Bird could pass the ball. Lebron’s obviously a better athlete, but to me, Larry is the better basketball player.

      0
    • #1015460
      AvatarAvatar
      Arc12345
      Participant

      Larry Bird > Lebron James

      Lebron is a great stat sheet stuffer, and I’m not hating. But Larry was clutch. And his numbers, in my opinion, are better. Superior shooter obviously. Lebron might be a better passer which is one hell of an accomplishment because Bird could pass the ball. Lebron’s obviously a better athlete, but to me, Larry is the better basketball player.

      0
  • #1015455
    AvatarAvatar
    Chewy
    Participant

     MJ, Magic, Lebron, Kareem

    I know Russell has the rings, defense and shot blocking. But Kareem has 6 in his own right and I like that he’s all time leading scorer.

    I just recently pushed LBJ ahead of Bird in my head… really hard decision. Can’t go wrong with either.

     

     

    0
  • #1015321
    AvatarAvatar
    SkalAndJamal
    Participant

    This is super hard cause I dont know if I want a balance between old school and new school, or just what I think is best. If it’s going off what I think is best, I would go- Kobe, Shaq, Magic, Jordan. If I had to do old school and new school, I would go- Kobe, Wilt, Magic, Jordan.

    0
  • #1015458
    AvatarAvatar
    SkalAndJamal
    Participant

    This is super hard cause I dont know if I want a balance between old school and new school, or just what I think is best. If it’s going off what I think is best, I would go- Kobe, Shaq, Magic, Jordan. If I had to do old school and new school, I would go- Kobe, Wilt, Magic, Jordan.

    0
  • #1015327
    AvatarAvatar
    evangelion79
    Participant

    Michael Jordan (Hes the greatest all around player ever, highest scoring average in history)

    Bill Russell (The most championships and an amazing competitor and person)

    Kareem (Most points in history, played well into his 40s while still being very productive)

    Larry Bird ( The most competitive and hardest working player ever. His stats are incredible, but when you take into consideration his lack of athletisism and that he played with a hurt back most of his career its impossible for me to leave him off. Also he had the chance to be only the second player EVER to tecord a quadruple double but willingly sat out the 4th quarter because he had already ‘done enough damage’

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015464
    AvatarAvatar
    evangelion79
    Participant

    Michael Jordan (Hes the greatest all around player ever, highest scoring average in history)

    Bill Russell (The most championships and an amazing competitor and person)

    Kareem (Most points in history, played well into his 40s while still being very productive)

    Larry Bird ( The most competitive and hardest working player ever. His stats are incredible, but when you take into consideration his lack of athletisism and that he played with a hurt back most of his career its impossible for me to leave him off. Also he had the chance to be only the second player EVER to tecord a quadruple double but willingly sat out the 4th quarter because he had already ‘done enough damage’

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015331
    AvatarAvatar
    PulseGlazer
    Participant

     No idea how you leave Russell off.  He and Jordan are gimmes.  Too easy. 

    Hard to do Bird without Magic or Magic without Bird, so Kareem will do to split the difference and he covers the 70s too so I don’t feel so bad about leaving Dr. J off.

    LeBron is probably last to rep modern era, but I wouldn’t be too mad if you wanted Duncan or even Kobe.

    I don’t think it’s about the 4 best – it’s representing eras.

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015468
    AvatarAvatar
    PulseGlazer
    Participant

     No idea how you leave Russell off.  He and Jordan are gimmes.  Too easy. 

    Hard to do Bird without Magic or Magic without Bird, so Kareem will do to split the difference and he covers the 70s too so I don’t feel so bad about leaving Dr. J off.

    LeBron is probably last to rep modern era, but I wouldn’t be too mad if you wanted Duncan or even Kobe.

    I don’t think it’s about the 4 best – it’s representing eras.

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015329
    AvatarAvatar
    DrivingDownTheStreetinmy64

     Larry bird,  steph curry,Jerry west , pistol Pete, Kevin love

    0
  • #1015466
    AvatarAvatar
    DrivingDownTheStreetinmy64

     Larry bird,  steph curry,Jerry west , pistol Pete, Kevin love

    0
  • #1015341
    AvatarAvatar
    Arc12345
    Participant

     Depends what your criteria is. My criteria isn’t representing the eras or it’d be it’s own question. To me, it means who are arguably the 4 greatest players ever. In my mind, I try to envision the 4 playing in any era and STILL being dominant. I think MJ, Oscar, Magic, and Bird would dominate in any era. 

    Obviously it’s tough to leave off Kareem, Russell, Wilt, Kobe, and others…but that’s what makes the question difficult.

    0
  • #1015477
    AvatarAvatar
    Arc12345
    Participant

     Depends what your criteria is. My criteria isn’t representing the eras or it’d be it’s own question. To me, it means who are arguably the 4 greatest players ever. In my mind, I try to envision the 4 playing in any era and STILL being dominant. I think MJ, Oscar, Magic, and Bird would dominate in any era. 

    Obviously it’s tough to leave off Kareem, Russell, Wilt, Kobe, and others…but that’s what makes the question difficult.

    0
  • #1015343
    canadabasketballisrisingcanadabasketballisrising
    canadabasketballisrising
    Participant

     I feel like: Jordan, Magic and Bird have to be there. For the fourth..

     

     

    0
  • #1015479
    canadabasketballisrisingcanadabasketballisrising
    canadabasketballisrising
    Participant

     I feel like: Jordan, Magic and Bird have to be there. For the fourth..

     

     

    0
  • #1015345
    canadabasketballisrisingcanadabasketballisrising
    canadabasketballisrising
    Participant

     I think it should be Irving, Russell, Kareem or oscar as of now. … i cant decide between DR. J and Russell… I go with DR. J tho… 

    0
  • #1015481
    canadabasketballisrisingcanadabasketballisrising
    canadabasketballisrising
    Participant

     I think it should be Irving, Russell, Kareem or oscar as of now. … i cant decide between DR. J and Russell… I go with DR. J tho… 

    0
  • #1015347
    AvatarAvatar
    alex23
    Participant

     MJ,Magic,Wilt,Kareem

    0
  • #1015483
    AvatarAvatar
    alex23
    Participant

     MJ,Magic,Wilt,Kareem

    0
  • #1015355
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Washington – Wilt

    Jefferson – Russell

    Lincoln – Kareem

    Roosevelt – Dr J

     

    Basically, these 4 created the NBA

     

    The next 4 who revolutionized the NBA

    Magic / Bird / MJ / Shaq

    0
  • #1015491
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Washington – Wilt

    Jefferson – Russell

    Lincoln – Kareem

    Roosevelt – Dr J

     

    Basically, these 4 created the NBA

     

    The next 4 who revolutionized the NBA

    Magic / Bird / MJ / Shaq

    0
  • #1015361
    AvatarAvatar
    daggers818
    Participant

    Magic

    Bird

    Jordan

    Kareem

     

    0
  • #1015497
    AvatarAvatar
    daggers818
    Participant

    Magic

    Bird

    Jordan

    Kareem

     

    0
  • #1015366
    AvatarAvatar
    PurpleMonkeyDishwasher
    Participant

     What would make it difficult to select your favorite team?  I would guess everyone would have their personal favorites but I wouldn’t think it would cause any disturbance in the force.

     

    0
  • #1015501
    AvatarAvatar
    PurpleMonkeyDishwasher
    Participant

     What would make it difficult to select your favorite team?  I would guess everyone would have their personal favorites but I wouldn’t think it would cause any disturbance in the force.

     

    0
  • #1015369
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Magic

    Kobe

    Jerry West

    Kareem Adbul-Jabbar

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015505
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Magic

    Kobe

    Jerry West

    Kareem Adbul-Jabbar

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015372
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Jordan

    Pippen

    Rodman

    Phil Jackson

     

    0
  • #1015507
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Jordan

    Pippen

    Rodman

    Phil Jackson

     

    0
  • #1015368
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Bill Russell

    Larry Bird

    John Havlicek

    Red Auerbach

     

     

      

    0
  • #1015503
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Bill Russell

    Larry Bird

    John Havlicek

    Red Auerbach

     

     

      

    0
  • #1015374
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Walt Frazier

    Patrick Ewing

    Willis Reed

    Earl Monroe

    0
  • #1015509
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Walt Frazier

    Patrick Ewing

    Willis Reed

    Earl Monroe

    0
  • #1015375
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Duncan

    Robinson

    Gervin

    Parker

     

     

      

    0
  • #1015511
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Duncan

    Robinson

    Gervin

    Parker

     

     

      

    0
  • #1015377
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Dwayne Wade

    Alonzo Mourning

    Lebron James

    Tim Hardaway

     

     

    0
  • #1015513
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Dwayne Wade

    Alonzo Mourning

    Lebron James

    Tim Hardaway

     

     

    0
  • #1015379
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Julius Erving

    Wilt Chamberlain

    Allen Iverson

    Charles Barkley

     

     

     

     

     

      

    0
  • #1015515
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Julius Erving

    Wilt Chamberlain

    Allen Iverson

    Charles Barkley

     

     

     

     

     

      

    0
  • #1015381
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Isiah Thomas

    Joe Dumars

    Bob Lanier

    Dave Bing

    0
  • #1015517
    AvatarAvatar
    trelos6
    Participant

    Isiah Thomas

    Joe Dumars

    Bob Lanier

    Dave Bing

    0
  • #1015383
    AvatarAvatar
    Grandmama
    Participant

     Jordan

     Wilt

     Kareem

     Magic

    0
  • #1015519
    AvatarAvatar
    Grandmama
    Participant

     Jordan

     Wilt

     Kareem

     Magic

    0
  • #1015396
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. HookShot
    Participant

    For me I consider 3 players shoe-ins: MJ, Kareem, and Russell (no order).

    For the final spot there are various good options, like Oscar Robinson, Wilt and LeBron, but for me it comes down to Magic vs. Bird. Both great players, who not only put up impressive numbers but also made their teammates that much better on their way to multiple championships. This one’s to difficult for me, so I choose Larry Johnson… 😉

    0
  • #1015531
    AvatarAvatar
    Mr. HookShot
    Participant

    For me I consider 3 players shoe-ins: MJ, Kareem, and Russell (no order).

    For the final spot there are various good options, like Oscar Robinson, Wilt and LeBron, but for me it comes down to Magic vs. Bird. Both great players, who not only put up impressive numbers but also made their teammates that much better on their way to multiple championships. This one’s to difficult for me, so I choose Larry Johnson… 😉

    0
  • #1015571
    AvatarAvatar
    Dazzling Dunks and Basketball Bloopers
    Participant

     I’m going with jordan, Russell, bird and magic. 

    I seriously wish I could add a fifth spot for kareem because he deserves to be on there as well but there are only four spots available and I couldn’t see bumping any of the other guys off.

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015436
    AvatarAvatar
    Dazzling Dunks and Basketball Bloopers
    Participant

     I’m going with jordan, Russell, bird and magic. 

    I seriously wish I could add a fifth spot for kareem because he deserves to be on there as well but there are only four spots available and I couldn’t see bumping any of the other guys off.

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015579
    AvatarAvatar
    NBAjunkie81
    Participant

     People usually seperate Centers from the other 4 positions or Pre & Post 1980 which is considered the modern era… From 1960 to 1979 b/c the League was only 10 to 13 teams there were So many great players & the ABA had many players who would end up in the NBA Hall of Fame…

    So minus Centers – I have Magic, Jordan, Bird & Dr. J –  The 1st 3 speak for themselves but people don’t realize that Dr. J in addition to being an unstoppable scorer was a Great rebounder & shot blocker too… His ABA ROOKIE year as a 21 y/o AVERAGED 27.3 points, 15.7 rebounds!!! 4.0 assists & 2.3 blocked shots! these are Center #’s – Insane for a 6’7” small forward to Average 10+ rebounds per game between 21 & 30 years old… 

    Centers I have: Wilt, Kareem, Shaq & Tim Duncan (Russell & Hakeem are right there too, I agonized over my decision top 4, b/c really these 6 are so even…

    Pre & Post 1980 (centers included)

    Pre: Oscar Robertson, Dr. J, Wilt & Russell (no particular order)

    Post: Magic, Bird, Jordan, Shaq – Jordan accomplish A LOT post 32 y/o – so Lebron might squeeze out Shaq over the next 5 years – we’ll see…

    And Finally All Time – just Pure individual Talent: Wilt, Jordan, Bird & Magic (no particular order)

    My top 10 post 1980: Magic, Bird, Jordan, Shaq, Duncan, Isaiah Thomas, Hakeem, Lebron, Kobe, Dwayne Wade (no partuicular order & just based on pure freak talent & I didn’t count any players Under 30)

    My top 10 Pre 1980: Dr.J, Russell, Oscar, Wilt, Kareem, Moses, Walton, Elvin Hayes, George Gervin, Earl the Pearl Monroe (no particular order)

    My Top 10 post 2000: (so players drafted in the Mid 90s up to 2015): Shaq, Duncan, Lebron, Kobe, Wade, Durant, Steph Curry. Dirk Nowitzki, Iverson, Nash

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015444
    AvatarAvatar
    NBAjunkie81
    Participant

     People usually seperate Centers from the other 4 positions or Pre & Post 1980 which is considered the modern era… From 1960 to 1979 b/c the League was only 10 to 13 teams there were So many great players & the ABA had many players who would end up in the NBA Hall of Fame…

    So minus Centers – I have Magic, Jordan, Bird & Dr. J –  The 1st 3 speak for themselves but people don’t realize that Dr. J in addition to being an unstoppable scorer was a Great rebounder & shot blocker too… His ABA ROOKIE year as a 21 y/o AVERAGED 27.3 points, 15.7 rebounds!!! 4.0 assists & 2.3 blocked shots! these are Center #’s – Insane for a 6’7” small forward to Average 10+ rebounds per game between 21 & 30 years old… 

    Centers I have: Wilt, Kareem, Shaq & Tim Duncan (Russell & Hakeem are right there too, I agonized over my decision top 4, b/c really these 6 are so even…

    Pre & Post 1980 (centers included)

    Pre: Oscar Robertson, Dr. J, Wilt & Russell (no particular order)

    Post: Magic, Bird, Jordan, Shaq – Jordan accomplish A LOT post 32 y/o – so Lebron might squeeze out Shaq over the next 5 years – we’ll see…

    And Finally All Time – just Pure individual Talent: Wilt, Jordan, Bird & Magic (no particular order)

    My top 10 post 1980: Magic, Bird, Jordan, Shaq, Duncan, Isaiah Thomas, Hakeem, Lebron, Kobe, Dwayne Wade (no partuicular order & just based on pure freak talent & I didn’t count any players Under 30)

    My top 10 Pre 1980: Dr.J, Russell, Oscar, Wilt, Kareem, Moses, Walton, Elvin Hayes, George Gervin, Earl the Pearl Monroe (no particular order)

    My Top 10 post 2000: (so players drafted in the Mid 90s up to 2015): Shaq, Duncan, Lebron, Kobe, Wade, Durant, Steph Curry. Dirk Nowitzki, Iverson, Nash

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015645
    AvatarAvatar
    JR Ryder
    Participant

    Michael Jordan – Not only the best player to ever play, but globalized basketball market wise.

    Bill Russell – He may not have been the first african american basketball player, but he was its first great player.

    Magic Johnson/Larry Bird – Greatest individual rivalry perhaps in basketball, ushered in the golden age of basketball in the 80s.

    0
  • #1015510
    AvatarAvatar
    JR Ryder
    Participant

    Michael Jordan – Not only the best player to ever play, but globalized basketball market wise.

    Bill Russell – He may not have been the first african american basketball player, but he was its first great player.

    Magic Johnson/Larry Bird – Greatest individual rivalry perhaps in basketball, ushered in the golden age of basketball in the 80s.

    0
  • #1015648
    AvatarAvatar
    oogells
    Participant

    Popeye Jones

    Sam Cassel

    Bryant Reeves

    Nate Robinson

     

    It’s a peice of art, and I think those faces would look good next to each other. 

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015512
    AvatarAvatar
    oogells
    Participant

    Popeye Jones

    Sam Cassel

    Bryant Reeves

    Nate Robinson

     

    It’s a peice of art, and I think those faces would look good next to each other. 

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015654
    Robb_CRobb_C
    Robb_C
    Participant

     I actually wouldn’t have a problem leaving Jordan off the mount rushmore, cause if you think about it how much of a forefather is MJ really? He did take the league to incredible heights but the guys before him really were the ones who paved the way for him to make a living doing it..thats what mount rushmore is about, not who was the greatest but who paved the way for us to be the greatest.. That being said heres my list.

    George Mikan- Hes the George Washington of the game the first forefather, countless rules and theory is based off his play, he was the first real star the NBA had.

    Elgin Baylor – Hes the Thomas Jefferson as far as forefathers, without Elgin the Minneapolis Lakers would have went bankrupt, meaning hes the reason the Lakers and one of the NBAs greatest franchises exist today. 

    Bill Russell- Between all the Social issues and the Civil rights movement Russell stood for, he helped paved the way for players now.

    Julius Erving- Dr. J is the greatest influence on the modern NBA, he brought the cool factor and the entertainment factor to the league, Magic and Jordan did it better no doubt but Dr.J is the one who started it all and for that reason he has to be on the mount

     

    0
  • #1015518
    Robb_CRobb_C
    Robb_C
    Participant

     I actually wouldn’t have a problem leaving Jordan off the mount rushmore, cause if you think about it how much of a forefather is MJ really? He did take the league to incredible heights but the guys before him really were the ones who paved the way for him to make a living doing it..thats what mount rushmore is about, not who was the greatest but who paved the way for us to be the greatest.. That being said heres my list.

    George Mikan- Hes the George Washington of the game the first forefather, countless rules and theory is based off his play, he was the first real star the NBA had.

    Elgin Baylor – Hes the Thomas Jefferson as far as forefathers, without Elgin the Minneapolis Lakers would have went bankrupt, meaning hes the reason the Lakers and one of the NBAs greatest franchises exist today. 

    Bill Russell- Between all the Social issues and the Civil rights movement Russell stood for, he helped paved the way for players now.

    Julius Erving- Dr. J is the greatest influence on the modern NBA, he brought the cool factor and the entertainment factor to the league, Magic and Jordan did it better no doubt but Dr.J is the one who started it all and for that reason he has to be on the mount

     

    0
    • #1015568
      AvatarAvatar
      JR Ryder
      Participant

      20 years from now, kids will still be wearing Michael Jordan’s shoe. Cant say the same thing about Dr. J. What other athlete do you know has that kind of impact?

      0
    • #1015703
      AvatarAvatar
      JR Ryder
      Participant

      20 years from now, kids will still be wearing Michael Jordan’s shoe. Cant say the same thing about Dr. J. What other athlete do you know has that kind of impact?

      0
  • #1015582
    AvatarAvatar
    LerinErin
    Participant

     Hmmm

     

    Russell…… . Read Simmons the Book of Basketball (not a Celts fan it hard to argue)

    Jordan….. No need to explain

    Magic…. as much for love of the as his amazing talent.

     

    Jabbar…. Player I really dislike a ton. He basically refused to rebound his last few Seasons but a truly amazing player 

     

    0
  • #1015717
    AvatarAvatar
    LerinErin
    Participant

     Hmmm

     

    Russell…… . Read Simmons the Book of Basketball (not a Celts fan it hard to argue)

    Jordan….. No need to explain

    Magic…. as much for love of the as his amazing talent.

     

    Jabbar…. Player I really dislike a ton. He basically refused to rebound his last few Seasons but a truly amazing player 

     

    0
  • #1015600
    AvatarAvatar
    Hitster
    Participant

    MJ, Kareem, Wilt and Bill Russell.

    0
  • #1015736
    AvatarAvatar
    Hitster
    Participant

    MJ, Kareem, Wilt and Bill Russell.

    0
  • #1015625
    AvatarAvatar
    Memphis Madness
    Participant

     I would wear a Dr. J. shoe.

    Ok, ok…

    NBA Mount Rushmore:

    MJ: BEST ever.

    Magic: GREATEST ever.

    Bill Russell: WINNER. Mr. Basketball IQ.

    Wilt: The Myth. I am not sure that the 100 point game and the 55 rebound game really happened.  Averaged 50 points a game for an entire season?  Didn’t see it… led the league in assists one year?  BUT, the reason I have him on the NBA Mount Rushmore… he was on the two BEST regular season teams before the ABA-NBA merger.  Well, ok, I think the NBA sent out George Mikan to create a rogue minor league, try out some new things, showcase Dr. J, then bring them into the NBA fold down the line.  But, I digress.  Wilt was on the great Sixers team that won 68 games.  Then he was on the Lakers team that won 69 games including 33 straight.  

    My Mount Rushmore includes the greatest pro sports dynasty in US history.  The 72 wins Bulls team alpha dog, the maestro of the ’87 Lakers (and many more showstopping Showtime teams), and a couple of dominant Wilt squads.  

    Put another way, if you had an ALL TIME NBA draft you take MJ.  You take Magic.  You take Bill Russell.  And, no way Wilt isn’t a top 4 pick.

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0
  • #1015762
    AvatarAvatar
    Memphis Madness
    Participant

     I would wear a Dr. J. shoe.

    Ok, ok…

    NBA Mount Rushmore:

    MJ: BEST ever.

    Magic: GREATEST ever.

    Bill Russell: WINNER. Mr. Basketball IQ.

    Wilt: The Myth. I am not sure that the 100 point game and the 55 rebound game really happened.  Averaged 50 points a game for an entire season?  Didn’t see it… led the league in assists one year?  BUT, the reason I have him on the NBA Mount Rushmore… he was on the two BEST regular season teams before the ABA-NBA merger.  Well, ok, I think the NBA sent out George Mikan to create a rogue minor league, try out some new things, showcase Dr. J, then bring them into the NBA fold down the line.  But, I digress.  Wilt was on the great Sixers team that won 68 games.  Then he was on the Lakers team that won 69 games including 33 straight.  

    My Mount Rushmore includes the greatest pro sports dynasty in US history.  The 72 wins Bulls team alpha dog, the maestro of the ’87 Lakers (and many more showstopping Showtime teams), and a couple of dominant Wilt squads.  

    Put another way, if you had an ALL TIME NBA draft you take MJ.  You take Magic.  You take Bill Russell.  And, no way Wilt isn’t a top 4 pick.

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login