share

Derrick Rose- Not Just The MVP

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
Fritz he still needs to get

Fritz he still needs to get alot better defensively on a consistant basis. Youre right he comes out to play when the best are in town, he is such a competitor, but he needs to do it every nght. His shot selection is kind of iffy, but at the same time I feel that is just his confidence. he feels he can make any shot and when a player has that kind offensive package you cant really blame him for that.

I stand by my statement, Rose is not the best passer, not the best rebounder, not the best defender. But if I had to choose one player to put on my team, to make sure that my team would win games its him.

tuck243
tuck243's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/31/2008
Posts: 1053
Points: -333
Offline
Great debate

First off if yu going to compare Derrick Rose compare him to similar players... Not who yu would rather have... Compared to someone like Wade for instance... D. Rose is the better player... Rose has a knack for winning....

A few of yu r too harsh on the man n not viewing the guys yu say r better than him in the same light... The only Superstar that shot better than him from 3 is Durant n he barely did that... Since he is up there in 3pt % as the other players, by saying he needs to improve that to be better than them is non sense... Kevin Durant still have a lot of holes to fill, as so LeBron... EVERY superstar takes bad shots n turn the ball over in key situations... So, PLEASE give me something that the rest of the league is doing better? He didn't have Noah or Boozer for a good portion of the season n willed his team to wins... In fact OVER a Heat team where he was obviously the best player on the floor, especially late... So, I would rank em LeBron, Kobe, Rose... If hot any of these 3 r interchangeable... If cold they r with KD, Wade, Howard, n sometimes a focused Melo... That's it...

Malik-Universal
Malik-Universal's picture
Registered User
Joined: 07/08/2010
Posts: 3406
Points: 3125
Offline
i dont think is the best

i dont think is the best player in the league... but the best PG and possibly a top 7 player or so...

tuck243
tuck243's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/31/2008
Posts: 1053
Points: -333
Offline
to piggy back off what someone just said

D. Rose is up there with MJ, Kobe, and Tracy... These r the only players I can think of the past 20-25 years that got good quickly... They definitely added something to their games on a year to year basis, trying to have no holes... Jordan did it so fast he quit after the 3rd championship because he had nothing else to add or prove... Good point...

M-DYMES
M-DYMES's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/14/2009
Posts: 2643
Points: 6864
Offline
People actin like

People actin like crabs...always jumping on Rose's dick. I used to be a huge fan but Im starting to come down a bit just b/c this whole love affair everyone seems to have wit Rose is sickening me. He's a great guy and player so I can see why, but this is just gettin ridiculous.

"Up there with MJ, Kobe, and Tracy"...so much wrong in that statement.

1st off Tracy doesn't belong in that conversation with MJ and Kobe watsoever. Clearly u are biased juding by ur avatar.

2nd...Rose played at this caliber for 1 season. MJ and Kobe been doing it over a decade atleast. Give it some time before you put him on the throne. There is no rush.

mikeyvthedon
mikeyvthedon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 5559
Points: 12472
Online
Sorry to throw my hat into the ring.....

But, I think Derrick Rose is fantastic, he is honestly my favorite player behind LeBron. I loved Derrick as a prospect in HS, was amazed by his athleticism and agree that he is a winner and a fantastic leader. I was one of the "Derrick Rose will be the best PG in the league after two years" people, yet at the same time I guess I wondered if he would surpass the once mainstays of Chris Paul and Deron Williams. Well, he has, and this season he well surpassed my expectations of him. Plus, he has always seemed to play incredibly in the play-offs, which he has made every year he has been in the league. Still, I have MAJOR reservations of saying he is better than LeBron James.

Leadership is incredibly subjective, and while Rose has been the best leader in the league this year, I think putting LeBron down in this quality is INCREDIBLY played out. Yes, his game 5 against Boston last year was atrocious, and he was not himself through a majority of the series, seemingly losing his composure. Still, I may be alone here, but did he really quit on his team? People seem to forget that while he may not have been himself offensively (though he had two monster games in their wins), he shut Paul Pierce down in every game besides the Game 5 awfulness. So, there is that.

Also, at 22 years old, LeBron did indeed lead a Cleveland squad to the NBA Finals. This team may not be the current Derrick Rose Bulls team, but they beat an impressive Pistons squad and came back from a 2-0 deficit to do so. Not to mention, LeBron's Game 5 performance in that series was one of the more impressive individual performances I have seen in play-off history. He literally tried to get his team involved, and when that was not enough, he carried them on his back and scored 29 of their last 30 points.

I am not expecting me saying this is going to make LeBron any less of a "clown", in your eyes, and he has done things that may make him deserve the moniker. People do not like his dancing, lightheartedness and sometimes utter obliviousness to being humble. "The Decision" was stupid, he will have a hard time living it down. He even does have the awful quality of sometimes seeming like he is not accountable for his actions, which can be mindnumbing. But, he is the best player in basketball, like him or not. You could take Derrick Rose over him, but keep in mind that they are in completely different situations at this point in their career, and that while Derrick is a leader, he has a supporting cast that gells incredibly well, plus talent, depth and size on his team that LeBron never had in Cleveland.

One last futile counterpoint, is that if we are going to play the "LeBron is a jerk" card or question his attitude and abilities in the leadership department is to maybe look at the difference between he and Rose's upbringing. LeBron was the only child of a mother who had him at 15 years old. He has had hangers on, but I see very little example of actual positive male role models in his early (or possibly even later) life. Gloria James seems like a loving mother, and I do not know her personally, but I can not see how more people do not question how in the hell LeBron turned out as well as he has. I think it is a miracle personally. Meanwhile, Derrick Rose had an incredible support system with his brothers, who tried to keep hangers on at bay. It kind of reminds me of the Marbury family with Steph, but fixing the obviously huge holes in that scenario and instilling a competitive fire in place of a chip on his shoulder. Really, if it comes down to it, Derrick Rose was giving much better building blocks than LeBron James in the leadership department. Still, he has a ways to go to catch LeBron James as a complete basketball player, and I do not think all of the criticism of LeBron is warranted. He is different than Derrick Rose, but we really do not know if that is a good or bad thing yet. It will more than likely come down to rings, and they should both be fighting for some. Win or lose, Rose may be a better leader, but I still think that LeBron James is the best basketball player in the league right now, and his ability indeed is enough to make him a constant threat for an NBA championship.

TallmanNYC
TallmanNYC's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/04/2010
Posts: 1967
Points: 1110
Offline
Put me down on the list of

Put me down on the list of Rose haters if thinking that Rose is not the best player in the game makes you a hater. A great player, I'm fine with. Top 10 in the league, sure, I will go there. Any higher than that and I can't agree with you. I want to see more production over a longer period of time. Sure there is potential, but no more than a lot of PGs and other young players have. John Wall is putting up better numbers in his rookie year than Rose, for example. I'm just as excited about the potential that Blake Griffen has as I am about Rose (not saying Blake is better now, I'm talking potential).

But I think the Rose-Lovers are going to have their bubble burst. In case you haven't noticed, the Bulls are struggling to beat the Pacers on their home court. The Pacers are possibly the worst playoff team this year, maybe tied with the Sixers. Rose is scoring points, but it is taking a lot of shots for him to get there. Looking at these games, there is no guarantee the Bulls even make it out of the first round. They probably will, but they should be crushing an eighth seed and in paticular this eigth seed. They are lucky that it doesn't get much tougher in the next round facing either the Hawks or the Magic.

Right now the Bulls aren't looking like an elite team. By the way, this was predicted by lots of people. A lot of people said that the Bulls were dominate this year because of their bench and the quality of defense they got from them which is especially helpful on back to back game nights. But everyone is rested in the playoffs, so the bench isn't as helpful. It is about your starters. The problem that some people said about the Bulls is that their starters aren't actually one of the top starting fives in the league.

Hale
Hale's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2009
Posts: 5778
Points: 12547
Online
M-Dymes The guy who put Rose

M-Dymes

The guy who put Rose with MJ and Kobe was based off of what they do to add to their games in the offseason. He didn't say he was at their level. He improves something dramatically every year, so his work ethic is at least somewhat comparable to Jordan and Kobe.

Hale
Hale's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2009
Posts: 5778
Points: 12547
Online
Ok wow but ESPN is taking it

Ok wow but ESPN is taking it too far. There is a SportsNation quiz asking who would win one on one, Derrick Rose or MJ in his prime...WTF?

tuck243
tuck243's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/31/2008
Posts: 1053
Points: -333
Offline
M-Dymes

Yu sound like a moron n don't know how to debate correctly (even tho I just called yu out your name but its true)... I'm not being bias, I said these r the only players I can THINK of... Meaning it might be some I missed #1... Secondly, I'm not saying Rose is MJ, I'm saying these guys were adding things to their games at a rapid rate... Not a long duration of time, RAPID rate (I used the word quickly before)... And if yu r going to condemn what anyone has said, EXPLAIN yourself... I hope your vocabulary is intensive enough to write your logic in a paragraph rather than giving your opinions with no proof... I don't give a ! what yu think Dymes if yu have nothing to back it...

tuck243
tuck243's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/31/2008
Posts: 1053
Points: -333
Offline
this LeBron taking his team to the finals is a lil overrated

Other than the Detroit series (which he was an absolute beast in) he didn't play a quality opponent... Remember the East was a cake walk back then... Outside of Detroit, Miami was the only contenders with a healthy Shaq n Wade.... That Detroit series was ridiculous... No one wanted to guard him... he did that pick n roll all damn day n nobody stopped it... Now, when he got to the finals the Spurs gave the blue print on how to stop that man, and he hasn't been back since... with the best record in the NBA 2 years in a row, while looking like the best team and the beast player he's come up short... Stop giving me the names on his squad they still won 60+ games n didn't make it...

NYCarolina
NYCarolina's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/18/2011
Posts: 35
Points: 8
Offline
LeBron took his team to the

LeBron took his team to the finals. Call it whatever, he put a TERRIBLE team on his back and lead them to the Finals.

tuck243
tuck243's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/31/2008
Posts: 1053
Points: -333
Offline
and got swept

With Boobie playing great n another All-Star on his team... Z...

tuck243
tuck243's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/31/2008
Posts: 1053
Points: -333
Offline
and with a team with MORE

talent he didn't take them there... So, what does it mean when yu has more talent n can't reach the finals??? It's been 5 years n yall keep bringing that up... He didn't win, the END... And just "making" it to the finals shouldn't define how great yu are... The only series where he "put" them on his back was that Detroit series... The rest he did his job just like any superstar... Calm down...

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
Im not "jumping on Roses dick

Im not "jumping on Roses dick" Dymes. Beggining of the year he was no better then Westbrook, Rondo, Paul, or Williams for me. But seein what he does game after game, no slowing down Id takehim over anyone. thats just ho it is. Every time the Bulls win a game within 5 points you have one person to blame. I cant say that about any other player in the NBA. He just wins those games.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
Theres no other arguement for

Theres no other arguement for me. All I can say is that he wins games. Thats proven. He wins them, he prevents losses, and thats it. What else do you want from a player in the NBA. I dont see Lebron icing games like Rose does. Durant and Westbrook do it together. Westbrook did it by himself for a while but noticeably got fatigued quickly. Lebron and Wade do it together and quite frankly against top tier teams they dont do it at all. Who else does it? Pierce and Kobe? Who do those guys play along with, KG, Allen. How about that stacked Lakers team, we saw Artest of all people win the Championship for LA last year. How about Nowitzki. Ill take Rose over any of those guys.

M-DYMES
M-DYMES's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/14/2009
Posts: 2643
Points: 6864
Offline
McGrady I back my sh-it up

McGrady I back my sh-it up regularly if it is something I find relevant and I care about. Frankily I don't give 2 fu-cks about people's love for Derrick Rose or your infatuation with T-Mac. By this 'jumping on Rose's dick' im saying its not that he's not a great player. He'll he was the best player this year IMO, although LBJ and Dwight were very close as well and if given the same situation, I think may have had even more highly regarded as MVP. Im just saying that he comes up this often on boards and talk shows across America and it gets sickening seeing anyone getting this much attention...its almost christ-like.

And tuck243, Im sorry I didnt "back up" my shi-t with u. I apologize for not reading your post entirely, but as soon as that line came up I lost any interest in your statement. I read it through again and agree with you too some extent. But, T-Mac, MJ, Kobe, they all did this over many season and continued to improve. Its great that Rose took that level of a stride in one year, but lets wait a bit before talking about his improvements being as extravagent as those 3 players. I do agree with you that it was great improvement for one year though.

And just so you know...no sweat off my ballsack if u disagree or dont give a fu-ck wat i say. Imma say what I say and atleast Im just man enough to admit my short-comings. Frankily, the only reason I didn't debate hard was what I was addressing was something that had no merit being debated because I misunderstood your meaning and therefore it seemed as if your statement was just so ignorant that there was no need for explanation. And im willin to cut the internet &$#%#&@!in, shake hands wit u, and call it all squared off and be straight wit u.

Hitster
Hitster's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/17/2010
Posts: 3144
Points: 2203
Offline
With this debate, I think we

With this debate, I think we have to consider whether we are just talking about this season or a player's career as a whole. D-Rose is a deserving MVP but does that make him a better player overall than every other NBA player, for the regular season I say yes but overall I'd say no.

I've been on the D-Rose MVP bandwagon as long as anyone else but to immediately put him ahead of Kobe, LeBron and co is questionable in my opinion. I'd say he is clearly one of the top 5 players in the league at the moment maybe even a strong case for top 3 but I want to see him more during postseason before we crown him as the best.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
I want to see him more during

I want to see him more during postseason before we crown him as the best.

And you will.

mikeyvthedon
mikeyvthedon's picture
Registered User
Joined: 06/13/2008
Posts: 5559
Points: 12472
Online
Boobie had two great games

Against the Pistons, but remember that Zydrunas was basically an All-Star at a time when the East had little to offer at the Center position. I felt that Z being chosen over LeBron his rookie year was a slap in the face. Still, the Pistons series was huge for him, they were still a strong defensive team that LeBron destroyed. Boobie had a great Game 6, but I feel like LeBron was that teams offense, much like Rose is Chicago's. Call LeBron an overdribbler or whatever, but the guy makes things happen, and he was what gave Boobie those triples.

Yes, the East was weak, it was a different NBA back than, but it was an impressive achievement, and he did it at 22. That team would have no chance without him, they would be at best an average team, just like Chicago would be without Derrick Rose. Even though LeBron played poorly in those Finals, he was about the only thing keeping Cleveland close to winning. Plus, in the subsequent series against the Celtics and Magic which he lost, I still feel like he played incredibly hard.

The Celtics last year was an anomaly, at least offensively in Games 2, 4 and especially 5, but he was not letting people beat him. His teams would constantly get crushed on defense, which became a strength of his over time. Not only that, but he did become more efficient offensively over time as well. It is not like he does not work hard to improve his game. I think people here almost think he takes basketball for granted, maybe in some of the things he does or says off the court, but I think that he rapidly improved as well. Went from 20.9 to 27.2 to 31.4, and every season since he has added and improved in his game. You can call him a quitter, or dislike him, but I think he wants to win and people should realize that it took a number of good players a while to do so. Predict his downfall and Rose's uprisal, be happy if you do, but I have a feeling that LeBron is going to win some rings down the line, and I look forward to seeing what happens if they do indeed play Chicago.

Steroid
Steroid's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/13/2010
Posts: 842
Points: 1052
Offline
The "winning" argument is

The "winning" argument is moot. So what? LeBron or any other superstar isn't as much as a winner as Rose? All these guys have been winners since high school, so it's stupid to even think that. It takes more than one person to win a game anyway. It's more than just "icing" games also. There are 45 important minutes just as well as the last 3. People want to talk about what happens in the last couple of mins and last shots, blah, blah, but they don't remember what happened the first 40 something minutes of what the team or individual players did to help put their team in that hole. Talk about those minutes too. Some of you don't look at it that way though.

IndianaBasketball
IndianaBasketball's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 12525
Points: 23375
Offline
I don't understand the

I don't understand the Derrick Rose hate... He seems to get new hate every season.

He still has a few holes in his game, but his improvement from season to season is phenomenal. You can mention him in the same breath as players like MJ and Kobe when it comes to coming back next season a lot better than they were the season before. There's no reason to think he won't become a complete player in the very near future.

What's there not to like? He's humble... He holds himself accountable. He's unselfish. He can take coaching/criticism. He doesn't make excuses. He's a great leader. He makes his teammates better. His work ethic is out of this world. He's 100% about winning and nothing else. And he has that killer instinct/clutch gene that's rare. He has that unique ability to literally will his team to wins on a night to night basis... Like he just won't let his team lose.

I won't say he's the best player in the league, but he's clearly a top five player who's stock is on the up... And he's arguably the best closer in the league at 22 years old.

M-DYMES
M-DYMES's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/14/2009
Posts: 2643
Points: 6864
Offline
There is Derrick Rose hate?

There is Derrick Rose hate? I certainly haven't seen it yet. All i hear is people raving about him non-stop. I have yet to talk to anyone who doesn't like the guy...

If you're a D-Rose hater please let me know. I just want to know if they exist.

And OhCanada I'm not saying you're jumpin on his dick. But it seems like the majority of the people I've talked to seem to be developing a deep infatuation for the guy. And like I said, I really like him as a player and person, but the level of people's love affair for him and the rate that it is growing makes me kind of sick. ESPN is jonesin for some Rose dick and plenty of other media outlets and forums are wanting their fix too.

Hitster
Hitster's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/17/2010
Posts: 3144
Points: 2203
Offline
I agree that D-Rose's

I agree that D-Rose's defensive abilities do get overlooked so it will be interesting to see if he comes anywhere on the all defensive teams as people are sometimes surprised how often Kobe,LeBron,D-Wade and going back a few years Jason Kidd made the all first or 2nd NBA defensive teams. This shows that they are not just elite offensive players but they contribute on both ends of the court and I can see D-Rose developing along the same lines.

TallmanNYC
TallmanNYC's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/04/2010
Posts: 1967
Points: 1110
Offline
It ain't hate when we say

It ain't hate when we say lets wait.

The Rose "haters" are just saying, let's see how he does in the playoffs. Let's see him do this for a few years in a row. Everyone likes his game and likes his attitude. He is inspiring his teammates and the fans. All good. But best player in the league? Too soon to say that.

I hope we see a lot of Rose in the playoffs. Right now they are struggling to beat the Pacers at home in the first two games, so it doesn't look good. Rose is closing out games, but he is taking a ton of shots to get those points. He hasn't dominated like D. Howard has in these playoffs, for example. And the Bulls don't look as good as the Heat now.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
He hasn't dominated like D.

He hasn't dominated like D. Howard has in these playoffs, for example.

He most definitely has dominated..not quite as effiecently as Howard or productive but he is still dominating. Orlando is 1-1, Chicago is 2-0. They won both games, and the Pacers have been a matchup nightmare for Chicago all year long.

Well at least since Vogel has been coaching they have been.

TallmanNYC
TallmanNYC's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/04/2010
Posts: 1967
Points: 1110
Offline
I should have said Rose

I should have said Rose hasn't played as well as D. Howard because you are right Rose has been outstanding.

Don't fault Howard if the Magic don't make it out of round one. Their second best guys are Jameer Nelson and Turkoglu, neither of whom would start for the Bulls. Hell, I'm not even sure if either would even get significant run as part of the Bulls' bench.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
Nelson is a very capable PG

Nelson is a very capable PG in my opinion. He torched Felton last year. Turkoglu is skilled but his dedication is very questioned, Jason Richardson is very solid but as you said hasnt showed up, and they have solid depth and defense. Theyve moved so many pieces recently that roles are hard to define and the chemistry just isnt clicking, noone can blame Howard if he left. Lets just hope he doesnt have his own "decision" broadcasting.

I really think Jason Richardson would be the perfect SG for Chicago actaully.

TallmanNYC
TallmanNYC's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/04/2010
Posts: 1967
Points: 1110
Offline
Jason Richardson would be an

Jason Richardson would be an upgrade at SG for Chicago, especially if he can return to the way he used to play. He just hasn't been performing well at Orlando.

I wasn't trying to knock Nelson. But of course he wouldn't start for the Bulls because they have Rose and you can't start Nelson at SG. And while Nelson is a solid PG, you have to admit he is nowhere near to being at the level of player as any of Boozer, Deng or Noah.

DanEboy
DanEboy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/25/2008
Posts: 2473
Points: 6472
Offline
Howard has 26 turnovers

Howard has 26 turnovers through 4 games.....he has to take some of the fault for their losing.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
Ill take 40-points, 20

Ill take 40-points, 20 rebounds and 6-turnovers from a player anyday. He is producing half his teams offense, and rebounding, of course you can live with him commtting a third of their turnovers.

DanEboy
DanEboy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/25/2008
Posts: 2473
Points: 6472
Offline
He needs to take more than 14

He needs to take more than 14 shots. Again, as big and imposing as he is, he needs to step it up late in games. Give me a guy who can stop him? yet still, he doesn't overpower when needed.

Working on his free throws would help a lot too.

FastAndFurious
FastAndFurious's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/05/2009
Posts: 3564
Points: 9115
Offline
Dude's really be trippin

Like fareal yall really be trippin, where have yall been the last 8 years? I understand yall are mad and disgusted that LBJ23 has more talent than your whole family combine lol.

No but seriously have yall forgot that Lebron career averages are 27 7 7

That Lebron is really a walking triple double

"He's not a leader" HA the Cavs where the best team in the NBA if I can remember for the last couple years

09-10 61-21

08-09 66-16

And let's not forget they did make a trip to the NBA Finals in 06-07

Kill the noise, Rose hasn't even been out of the first round yet! He hasn't accomplished anything in all honesty besides a Rookie of the year award that Lebron won as well.

By Lebron's 3rd year they were already talking he might just be the 2nd best SF ever right behind Bird already.

Rose isn't even a top 10 all time PG yet, I do think he will get there, but he's not yet.

Lebron is just so great it's really absurd to even think Rose is better than him.

But you guys really don't understand so lets go into depth:

Lebron James:

One of four players to average 20 5 5 as a rookie

One of seven to average 25 7 7 for a season

One of three to average 30 7 7 for a season

One of four to average 31 7 and 6 in a season

One of two to average at least 27 6 and 6 for six consecutive seasons

One of two to post at least 2000 points 500 rebounds 500 assist for at least 5 seasons

ONLY player in NBA HISTORY to average at least 26 6 6 for their career

ONLY Player in NBA HISTORY to post at least 2000 points 500 rebounds 500 assist 100 steals in four straight seasons

One of three players to average 30 10 7 in postseason play

Then he has mumerous youngest player awards like the youngest to:

Record a trip doub in the playoffs

To score 30

To score 40

To win an all-star game mvp

To score 2,000 points in a season

To average at least 30

and its alot more seriously

While Rose has.......none

Only calim to fame was getting his FIRST trip doub this season

Stop playing like Lebron aint been doin this man

DanEboy
DanEboy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/25/2008
Posts: 2473
Points: 6472
Offline
I don't think anyone on here

I don't think anyone on here has said Rose is a better player than LeBron. And keep throwing out all the stats and numbers. If he doesn't start winning some rings all of those numbers won't mean shi.t. Ask Karl Malone if he cares about his stats.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
Rose has one that I know

Rose has one that I know of...I think its youngest player to win the MVP and I also think he took that from Lebron. Anyways that is a nice bunch of stats you put together.

DanEboy
DanEboy's picture
Registered User
Joined: 12/25/2008
Posts: 2473
Points: 6472
Offline
Actually it was Wes Unseld. I

Actually it was Wes Unseld. I could have sworn it was LeBron as well.

FastAndFurious
FastAndFurious's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/05/2009
Posts: 3564
Points: 9115
Offline
The first post someone said

The first post someone said they are starting to believe that Rose is not just the MVP but the best player in the league....I can read.

Also things were said like Lebron's not a leader which he is so I just added some extra info so yall can come off the Derrick Rose cloud and back to reality.

BlackFalcon
Registered User
Joined: 04/24/2011
Posts: 7
Points: -25
Offline
MVP vs Best Player vs Best Scorer

Lets define each:

MVP = best player on the best team

Best Player = makes the most significant overall contributions

Best Scorer = PPG average, 1on1 ability, and game-closing ability.

Lets choose one for each:

MVP = Rose

Best Player = Lebron

Best Scorer = Was Kobe for past 10 years or so. This year it's Kobe/Durant 1a and 1b, with Rose an extremely close third.

TallmanNYC
TallmanNYC's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/04/2010
Posts: 1967
Points: 1110
Offline
Hey BlackFalcon, you say MVP

Hey BlackFalcon, you say MVP = best player on best team.

So if the Spurs win one more game during the regular season and the Bulls one less, then Manu is MVP? It seems rough for the award to be decided based on just one or two regular season wins, especially since the Spurs play in the deeper West and they only have 1 less win than the Bulls. How about if the Melo trade happens in November and Denver goes on the post-trade tear for nearly the entire season. Denver would probably have ended with the best record the league then. Who is MVP off the Denver team? Is Nene now your MVP?

I think it is too simple to just look at team with the best record and pick from that. MVP is a lot of things and I don't think people agree about what the award is. You can tell by how it gets decided that for some people it includes "the story" of the season (which is Rose and the Bulls). That is kind of like making it a "Player of the Year" award (which is why Jimmer won POY even though nobody in their right mind thinks he was the best basketball player in college).

For other people MVP is about how would the team do without that player. That is why Lebron and Wade don't stand a chance because half the people out there think Lebron is the key and that he and Bosh would be fine without Wade and the other half think Wade is the key and that he and Bosh could win plenty without Lebron. Kobe also loses points because lots of people have Gasol as the best power forward in the league right now (I'd have him third after Nowitzki and Aldridge). Rose doesn't have to share the stage with any top tier star. Lots of people who vote this way think Howard is the most irreplaceable player and the player who's team would most fall apart if he were to go down.

Finally there are those who think MVP is for the best player. I think those folks are the minority because otherwise Shaq and Kobe would have a lot more MVPs. I'm glad MVP isn't decided on "best player" because it would be more boring with basically some guy winning it year after year during his prime. I like that the award sort of floats around.

IndianaBasketball
IndianaBasketball's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 12525
Points: 23375
Offline
"There is Derrick Rose hate?

"There is Derrick Rose hate? I certainly haven't seen it yet. All i hear is people raving about him non-stop. I have yet to talk to anyone who doesn't like the guy...

If you're a D-Rose hater please let me know. I just want to know if they exist."

First, it was he couldn't shoot. He developed a consistent mid-range jumper. After Ben Gordon left and he was struggling with an ankle injury, they said he didn't have what it took to take over games and be his team's go-to player. He became a great closer for his team. Next, it was he had no three-point range... He's made more three's this season than his first two seasons combined. Then people started saying he didn't get enough assists, had average playmaking and didn't make his teammates better. He finished this season top ten in assists. They said he was an awful defender... He's the starting point guard on the best defensive team in the league and has made improvements in that area. They said he couldn't lead because he was too quiet. He's become a great leader this season and has been more vocal. They even said he didn't get to the line enough... Teams haven't been able to keep him off of the line since. Now, it's he hasn't won a playoff series. It's only a matter of time.

Rose just continues to answer his critics and when he does, they bring up something else. Truth is, he gets better every season and soon, the critics won't have anything to bring up.

Steroid
Steroid's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/13/2010
Posts: 842
Points: 1052
Offline
I guess Jordan wasn't a

I guess Jordan wasn't a winner until he started winning rings, and Jordan was older than LeBron is right now before he won a championship. He didn't start "winning" until he got Pippen and Jackson. I can almost guarantee that LeBron will win a ring before Rose will. The Bulls are lucky that they won't have to face Miami or Boston in the second round, so that is the best thing they will have going for them this playoffs. Even if LeBron never won a ring, he will still be a top 3 player when he's done. LeBron will never get the respect he truly deserves if he wins a championship anyway because people will say he played with Wade and Bosh.

FastAndFurious
FastAndFurious's picture
Registered User
Joined: 08/05/2009
Posts: 3564
Points: 9115
Offline
Exactly you can't even argue

Exactly you can't even argue with people about Lebron, people know deep down he is the best thing walking, but he won't ever get the respect he deserves and it's messed up.

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
That was a nice miss by

That was a nice miss by Lebron last night. Whens the "best player in the league" gonna start winning games in crunch time? I would expect the best player in the league to win those type of games for his team every single time he had that oppurtunity, especially one with as many cock riders as Lebron. Yeah I said it!

OhCanada-
OhCanada-'s picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/08/2010
Posts: 5644
Points: 4969
Online
When Lebron gets the ball in

When Lebron gets the ball in the half court, 10 seconds left, crunch time, iso, against a strong defensive team, does anybody really think he is going to score? I have my doubts everytime.

IndianaBasketball
IndianaBasketball's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/09/2009
Posts: 12525
Points: 23375
Offline
"Even if LeBron never won a

"Even if LeBron never won a ring, he will still be a top 3 player when he's done."

I doubt it. Top ten maybe. IF LeBron doesn't win a ring, he'll be remembered for two things... Putting up great regular season numbers, but never winning the big one. And his decision to leave his kingdom to join another superstar and still coming up empty handed.

Kobe could win another championship and STILL not be top three, so I don't know how LeBron could be top three without one.

aamir543
aamir543's picture
Registered User
Joined: 04/11/2009
Posts: 5059
Points: 5558
Offline
I agree he is not the best,

I agree he is not the best, but he will get the mvp rightfuly because he carried a team without Boozer and /or Noah for more than half the season. I know people with throw out stats to disprove that, but what he did was amazing. But I do believe that Lebon,Wade,Dwight, Durant and Kobe are a step ahead, but he is only 22!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He still has a full growth curve ahead of him! He is only a college senior!

TallmanNYC
TallmanNYC's picture
Registered User
Joined: 05/04/2010
Posts: 1967
Points: 1110
Offline
Lebron puts up amazing

Lebron puts up amazing numbers in the post season as well as the regular season. His playoff average (and this is six straight years of being in the playoffs) is 29 points, 8.5 rebounds and 7.2 assists. Even Jordan's numbers aren't quite as good. You can knock him about his ability to get that last second bucket. That is a big problem and a fair criticism. But don't imply that he is just puts up numbers in the regular season. Lebron brings it in the big games as well.

RSS: Syndicate content